Take the 2-minute tour ×
Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Yesterday I had the privilege of losing my Holy Symbol to a story point. (We all lost everything but our clothes.) How can I determine what powers, if any, I can use without my Holy Symbol?

share|improve this question
This just happened to us. I wish I'd found this before spending two encounters just flailing about with a stick because I thought I couldn't use healing word. –  detly Nov 11 '14 at 1:44

1 Answer 1

up vote 24 down vote accepted

You can use (almost) all of your powers when disarmed and without implements.

ImplementDDI and WeaponDDI powers don't prevent you from using them if you lack the appropriate tool: they simply allow you to get a bonus when you have the appropriate tool.

When using an Implement (keyword) power you make an unmodified ability check (usually Wisdom-based for Implement Cleric powers) against the target defense (as per definition of attack roll).

When you hold a magical implement (e.g.: a holy symbol), you get to add the implement's enhancement bonus to both attack rolls and damage rolls with Implement powers (and a damage boost in case of critical hit).

Also note that you can take advantage from any implement you are proficient with (not only holy symbols). If your Cleric took the Arcane InitiateDDI feat, then he can use even magical staves, wands and orbs to improve his Cleric powers.

A non-magical implement does not provide any bonus (except for flavor or feat support) unless it is a superior implement. Superior implements cost more but provides a varied array of advantages (properties similar to those of weapons).
For example, the Astral SymbolDDI costs 18 gp but has the Distant (+2 range of ranged and area powers) and Energized (radiant) (+2/+3/+4 damage bonus with Radiant powers) properties. Its base version is non-magical, but it you can buy or create an enchanted version of it.
You gain proficiency with a single type of superior implement by taking the Superior Implement TrainingDDI feat.

Lack of proficiency with an implement you are using means that you gain no advantage from its superior or magical bonus and properties.

When using a Weapon (keyword) power while unarmed, you make an unmodified ability check (usually Strength-based for Weapon Cleric powers) against the target defense (usually AC).
However, unarmed attacks have no proficiency bonus, so you lack a thick +2 or +3 modifier.

When you wield a non-improvised weapon you get a proficiency bonus to attack rolls with Weapon powers.

When you wield a magical weapon, you also get the weapon's enchantment bonus to attack rolls and damage rolls with Weapon powers (and a damage boost in case of critical hit).

Lack of proficiency with a weapon you are wielding means that you don't apply the weapon's proficiency bonus and gain no advantage from its magical bonus and properties.

Some powers may require you to wield specific weapons or implements. In this case, they explicitly state this requirement in their Requirement line of the power block. This is usually found in Rogue powers, for example.

share|improve this answer
For the sake of anyone else who was confused by the ambiguous wording of the Red Box booklet (or just wants a RAW ref), p62 of the PHB says "Without a holy symbol, a cleric can still use these powers, but he or she doesn’t gain the bonus provided by the magic implement." –  detly Nov 11 '14 at 1:42

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.