In New World of Darkness Mage, the Hierarchy of Sins is less than clear about some cases. Specifically, it is a Wisdom 4 sin to "Harm someone with magic".
In other sourcebooks, is there a more clear definition of what this means? Specifically, I'm looking at two examples:
- I use a Matter spell to enchant a gun, and then shoot someone for extra damage. Am I harming with magic? Does the answer change if someone else permanently enchanted that gun and gave it to me?
- I use a Life spell to increase my Strength and then punch someone. Is that harming with magic?
In both cases, I'm getting extra dice on an aggressive action, but they definitely feel like they should be different than hitting someone with a fireball.
Note: I'm familiar with the existing errata, but I don't feel it adequately addresses this issue. Also, I'm looking for cited proof of written rules, not how it should be, I already have an opinion there.