I would classify myself as a powergamer. Most of the characters that I make are carefully optimized and crafted. However, the most "Fun" I ever had in a game was when my character was not optimized and was pretty average accross the board. What are some good methods to go from a powergamer to a more roleplaying type role? I know I could just make my characters differently, outside of that is there anything I could do to make my characters more interesting to me? I already write backstories and character histories... Any help would be appreciated.
closed as not constructive by MadMAxJr, wax eagle, CatLord, Oblivious Sage, Brian Ballsun-Stanton♦ Mar 11 '13 at 21:32
As it currently stands, this question is not a good fit for our Q&A format. We expect answers to be supported by facts, references, or expertise, but this question will likely solicit debate, arguments, polling, or extended discussion. If you feel that this question can be improved and possibly reopened, visit the help center for guidance. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.
1. Try to identify what, exactly, causes you to have more fun with not-optimized characters.
I respectfully disagree with those saying there isn't a question here, but I do think some introspection will go a long way here.
If you have more fun with non-optimized characters because you spend so much time and effort optimizing that it feels like work that is slightly different than if the optimization seems to get in the way of roleplaying which is slightly different than if your characters are outclassing the others.
2. Try putting story first.
As others have said in the comments, its a fallacy to think you can't both optimize and role play well. But the reason that fallacy exists is that it is easy to let optimizing get in the way of the story. Some people are fine with that, and there isn't anything inherently wrong with it. But it sounds like you aren't one of them or you wouldn't be asking this.
So, if you fit in that category(and I do), then try to make sure you prioritize story first, your own preferences a very close second, and then optimizing third (I didn't say leave it out...). Personally, I tend to like gishy characters (fighter/Mages and things along those lines). I tend to play them even in systems when I know that a straight up Mage is more powerful. But, I make sure my concept fits in the story first, and then I do optimize to the extent I can.
Lots of people can put optimization first and still roleplay well developped characters with good backstory, but (at least for me) that is harder and less fun. But I personally also don't entirely skip optimizing...after all being ineffective isn't fun either.
3. If all else fails, have someone else make the character for you.
If all else fails, have someone else make the mechanical portion of the character for you. Then you don't have to worry about optimizing.
You may want to write the backstory and let them read make a mechanical character that generally fits that, or you can write in the backstory around the character sheet they give you. Either way, you are focusing on the backstory, they are worrying about how (or if) to optimize.