Take the 2-minute tour ×
Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

At 19th level, you become the ultimate jack of all trades. Your sharp mind and keen sense of your surroundings allow you to duplicate almost any ability you witness. At the start of each day, choose three extraordinary class abilities. Each ability must be available to a standard character class at 15th level or lower, and must appear on the advancement table or in the text description for that class. By spending 4 inspiration points as a free action, you gain the benefits and drawbacks of one chosen ability for 1 minute. You use the ability as if your level in the relevant class equaled your factotum level. You can use each chosen class ability once per day.

What should I prepare in a social situation? Combat? Skill? What about sheer versatility?

share|improve this question
1  
Where book is this from? –  Drew Jun 16 '13 at 10:05
1  
@Drew the Factotum is in Dungeonscape. –  KRyan Jun 16 '13 at 11:58
1  
Sounded like a nice ability, until the "spend 4 inspiration to use it during 1 minute" and "only once a day each" –  Cristol.GdM Jun 16 '13 at 14:56
add comment

1 Answer 1

Some ambiguity

Unfortunately, Cunning Brilliance is not very clear about what, exactly, it gives you, and what, exactly, are legal options for it. Worse still, there are abilities that are not clearly Extraordinary or not.

Which classes?

Factotum refers to “standard character classes” – a phrase used anywhere else in the rules, so far as I know. The general consensus is that this means any base class, but it’s certainly not the only possible interpretation. It might just mean any class that’s legal in your game. It could conceivably mean only Core classes, or even just Core base classes.

For the purposes of this answer, I’m going to go with the general consensus and stick to base classes. I’ll mention the best Core options available just because if nothing else, we can be pretty sure those are in play.

Which abilities?

There are two questions here.

First, how does one handle “grouped” abilities? Rogue special abilities, for instance, are all listed under one class feature that Rogues get repeatedly: can you take the “special abilities of a Rogue” as a class feature, and therefore get four of them, as a Rogue 19 would? The ability explicitly says that you get the feature as would a character with levels in the class equal to your Factotum level, even above 15, provided you first get the ability at or before 15th.

Second, do abilities “default” to Extraordinary if no other qualifier (Su, Sp, etc.) is listed? There’s evidence to suggest that they do, even though this was almost certainly unintentional. In fact, in some books there are creatures who are listed as having the Extraordinary ability to cast spells – as in, cast spells the same way a Wizard or Sorcerer does, as spells, but the the ability to cast spells is Extraordinary. Since the Spellcasting class feature of various classes is never given a tag (Ex, Sp, Su, etc.), does this mean you can choose “the Spellcasting ability of a 19th-level Wizard” for Cunning Brilliance?

For the purposes of this answer, I’m going to say yes to the first but no to the second when it’s an ability that grants access to obviously not-Extraordinary abilities (i.e. you can argue that Spellcasting is an Extraordinary ability, but even if it is it’s an Ex ability that gives access to non-Ex abilities, spells, it seems to fall well outside the intent of Cunning Brilliance).

My answer will basically take this from the most liberal reading to the most conservative one.

Suggestions

Dubious Ex abilities

These probably aren’t legal, but some people make the argument that they are. They have additional problems beyond their legality, though.

Spellcasting

Spellcasting is the most powerful class feature in the game, and if you can get it on a Factotum (who has the incredible Cunning Surge), that’s fairly devastating. I certainly wouldn’t allow it in my games unless the Factotum seemed to be really struggling to keep up with his teammates.

The other major problem is that you only get the ability for a minute, and you therefore do not have time to prepare spells or even to refresh spontaneous spell slots. That eliminates the Archivist, Beguiler, and Wizard, which were probably your best choices.

The Sha’ir class from Dragon Compendium, however, can prepare spells in a few rounds. They’re Charisma-based and require a lot of Diplomacy, but those are pretty good things for a Factotum to have. Thus, you could use Cunning Brilliance to get Sha’ir spellcasting, and that’s pretty awesome.

A note: the ability to manifest psionic powers is explicitly a Psi-like Ability (Ps), not Ex. Which is a shame, from this perspective, since you can refresh PP in just a full-round action after resting, and Psion powers would be awesome for a Factotum.

Meldshaping

Not as powerful as spells, just as unlikely to fly, and also still suffering from the 1 hour preparation issue. The only reason I mention it is because they are pretty good, and you could use Shape Soulmeld to get some before using Cunning Brilliance, and use the Essentia you get for them. Doesn’t wind up being a particularly good use of Cunning Brilliance anyway. From Magic of Incarnum.

Definitely Ex, questionable “grouping”

The general consensus is that these abilities are legal for Cunning Brilliance, but I’d double-check with my DM before using any of them.

Maneuvers

Warblades only get access to Extraordinary maneuvers, which make them pretty safe on that front. Whether you have to spend all three Cunning Brilliances on getting the Maneuvers Known, the Maneuvers Readied, and the Stances, however, is another matter – using all three like that is a much less good deal. And once again, maneuvers need to readied, and that takes five minutes: four more than you’ve got.

The solution here is to dip into an initiating class at level 9 or 18, and take the Adaptive Style feat. Now readying takes just a full-round action. I suggest that you dip Swordsage for some of the nice Supernatural maneuvers he gets, since you won’t be able to get those from Cunning Brilliance, and for Assassin’s Stance. Missing Factotum 20 is no big loss compared to what this dip can get you. It’s a good idea even if you aren’t allowed to use Cunning Brilliance to get maneuvers.

Initiators are found in Tome of Battle: Book of the Nine Swords.

Auras

Marshal Auras are explicitly Extraordinary, and explicitly introduced all within a single class feature that’s gained at level 1. This is probably one of the best answers, and one of the least dubious for those that give you so much. Ironically, though, the Minor Auras are probably better than the Major ones. This is another option that works best for a high-Charisma Factotum. Marshal is from Miniatures Handbook.

Knight Challenges

Once again, all granted by a single, Ex class feature gained at level 1. Each individual item in the list is also Ex. So it seems legal, but again YMMV.

The main attraction here is Loyal Beyond Death, which you get at Factotum 20. That’s up to 10+Cha rounds of being immune to death unless they destroy your body. That’s pretty darn good. Test of Mettle is also fairly good (one of the few aggro-drawing abilities in 3.5), and Call to Battle and/or Bond of Loyalty have their uses. Knight is from Player’s Handbook II.

Fighter Bonus Feats

If you can just choose all of those feats as a single class feature, well, that’s an awful lot of feats. Arguably allows you to take the Fighter-only feats as well, though only Weapon Supremacy is any good.

Rogue Special Abilities

A number of these are pretty nice, and you arguably get four of them. Crippling Strike, Defensive Roll, Skill Mastery, and the Bonue Feat are probably the best options.

Single-shot Ex abilities

These are almost certainly intended to be covered by Cunning Brilliance.

(Greater) Rage

Rage is awesome, and Barbarians get Greater Rage early enough for you to bump yourself up to that one. Unless your DM rules that all of the __ Rage abilities form one ability, in which case you get both Tireless Rage and (at 20th) Mighty Rage, which is awesome.

(Greater) Ferocity, Whirling Frenzy

These Rage variants, from the Cityscape web enhancement “Urban Class Features” and Unearthed Arcana, respectively, are also very good.

Precision Damage

Rogue, Scout, Ninja, and so on give precision damage in various forms: you can even stack these to get a huge amount of damage. Not really the most interesting use of the ability, but it is a powerful one. Ninja and Scout are both from Complete Adventurer.

Camouflage and Hide in Plain Sight

The Scout gets these at 8th and 14th, respectively, which is important because the Ranger doesn’t get Hide in Plain Sight until 17th. They are otherwise identical to the Ranger versions. Painful to use two Cunning Brilliances on this, but the effect is quite good.

Special mention: if prestige class abilities are allowed, the Eye of Lolth’s version of Hide in Plain Sight is ridiculously good: it’s Ex, but works like the Assassin version of Hide in Plain Sight, covering both the concealment and observation requirements of Hide. Eye of Lolth is in Drow of the Underdark.

Blindsense

The Scout also gets Extraordinary Blindsense, out to 30 ft. as of 20th level. Not a bad choice.

Core-only

In Core only, your best options are Rage and Rogue special abilities. Fighter Bonus Feats if allowed.

share|improve this answer
    
The FAQ suggests that: "When in doubt, the DM should decide if an unmarked ability qualifies. Anything that lacks a clear, supernatural element should be fair play." I know you personally don't care for the FAQ, but it obviously will help convince some DMs, and is therefore worth mentioning. –  starwed Jun 16 '13 at 16:42
    
Oh, and oddly, the druid's Animal Companion ability is (Ex). Good luck explaining that one, though. –  starwed Jun 16 '13 at 16:43
    
@starwed The problem with Animal Companion is it takes 24 hours to summon a new Animal Companion, and you cannot have the feature that long. –  KRyan Jun 16 '13 at 17:01
    
A sentence under Knight Challenges seems to be missing some words. "these seem like a pretty safe option. You" –  Ernir Jun 16 '13 at 17:40
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.