Take the 2-minute tour ×
Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I would really like my pally to use just ONE weapon, and wield nothing in their other hand (or at least appear to do so), but I don't really see any thing that makes it beneficial at all. Using 2 weapons or a sword and shield just seem all around better. Is there anything that adds benefits to one weapon at all? Or is there an alternative to a shield that isn't an obvious weapon, like a glove or something?

share|improve this question
    
Götz von Berlichingen. Maybe not precisely a paladin, at least not by his most famous quote, but well... you know. –  Damon Mar 19 '14 at 23:47

4 Answers 4

up vote 8 down vote accepted

No.

Based on the latest playtest material of 2013.10.14 there is no incentive to leave a hand empty.

And logically, why would there be one? You have two hands, use them. If you miss a hand, just strap a shield to your forearm.

share|improve this answer

To offer an alternative answer to the accepted one:

Yes.

Remember that role playing is not all about combat. You can have a character that only uses one hand in battle, sure! And you can have a really good time, and you can look bloody awesome at the same time.

Furthermore, having a free hand could open some possibilities in the narrative during battle, for example manipulating objects, using improvised weapons, or dragging a companion out of danger, whilst still wielding your primary weapon, GM permitting.

If you're looking for a weapon for your off-hand, on the off-chance you need it, you could opt for the Cestus, which is a type of battle glove. Here are the stats for this weapon in D&D Next:

Cestus| Simple| 1 gp| 1d4| bludgeoning| 1 lb.| Light

Perhaps your GM will permit you to have a magical cestus, which gives you a bonus to AC, or a bonus to damage with it.

If your character has lost an arm through some horrific accident, or was born one-handed, that's not the end of the adventure for that character. You can still participate in battles; you can still take part in investigations; you can still explore the ruins of that lost temple over there.

Not everything about RP is about min/maxing your character's statistical abilities. It's about telling a story, as a group, and about having a good time.

Speak to your GM and perhaps she will weave something into the campaign for you.

This answer is not specific to the paladin, but could apply equally to a paladin or most other class types.

share|improve this answer

Yes but only in a specific kind of campaign.

People often fight/fought with a sword and a free hand in real life. Why do they do it?

  1. Shields are not gentlemanly. You don't visit the court of a neighboring kingdom in full plate with a two-handed battle axe or a broadsword and shield. You don't attend state dinners with your massive wall of metal. But you can do this with a rapier, or a longsword, or some other medium-length gentleman's weapon. A shield, oddly, is a threat, because it is heavy and bulky and awkward so if you're carrying it people assume you're looking for or at least expecting a fight.

  2. Shields are against the Rules. When you do fight someone, you probably challenged them to a duel, like a proper gentleman. You could do that mounted-on-a-horse-with-a-lance style, in which case yeah, you really need a shield. But you could also do that on foot, in which case the one-handed weapon is going to be the weapon of choice (Though in D&D 2-handers unfortunately are actually better here, unlike in real life).

  3. Shields don't fit into windows, crawl spaces, or your boot. If you're sneaking into a place to do some on-the-down-low stabbing, a shield just isn't gonna do it. Now, as a Paladin you don't sneakily assassinate political figures very often in most campaigns. But you could.

So in a 5e game where looking like a soldier is a bad thing, not using a shield makes sense.

share|improve this answer

You should take "Great Weapon Fighting" and then us a versatile weapon like long sword...then you can use it to do extra damage with two hands or just hold it in one if you like how it "looks". Also you will be able to grapple whenever you want.

cheers.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.