Take the 2-minute tour ×
Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

This question came to me in direct relation with my question about world-hopping with alchemical materials.

I have checked the Basic Set and GURPS Magic but couldn't find any information on this. It seems that the mana level of the world/region is important for magical actions, such as spell-casting, but there is no reference to magical objects also being able to exist...

By magical objects I mean innately magical objects, such as dragon's blood or the dust of a fairy, not an enchanted item or tool.

Can magical objects exist in a no mana world, and if not, why?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 7 down vote accepted

There is no answer to this because GURPS is not in the business of telling you how "the world" works—there is no default "the world" in GURPS. You provide the world(s) and your own laws of magic, GURPS steps in with rules you can use to represent those.

How do you want this to work? Okay, now that is how it works.

share|improve this answer

Rules as written states that no, magic items will not work.

"No Mana: No one can use magic at all. Enchantments and permanent magic effects are suspended and do not function while within a no-mana zone.". -- Magic 6, Mana Sidebar (Emphasis mine)

Executive summary

Magical items are rendered inert, so nothing magical can ever work in a no mana zone. If the item has any magical properties at all, they are suspended. Even if that object cannot cast a spell directly (or have any direct ambient effect) and can only be used for making potions, it is rendered inert. This is because Alchemy is considered magic ("Elixers are magical in nature" Magic 212).

TL;DR

Naturally magical objects

"Natural" magical objects, such as dragon's blood or a unicorn's horn would be rendered inert in a no-mana zone. If the objects was brought from another dimension or outside area they would no longer be magical when they arrived in the no-mana zone. Of course, if they were brought out of the no-mana zone they would once again be magical as they were simply being "suspended" (see above quote.)

Creating and Using Magic Items

It should be noted that since magic does not exist on this world that enchantment spells cannot be cast, and thus all "crafted" magic items would need to come from "the outside". Anyone using such an item would be unable to activate it or use its ambient ability (in the case of Boots of Haste and a +1 DR piece of armor, respectively).

Alchemy

Alchemy seems like a different beast but is not. Alchemy cannot be learned in a no-mana area (Magic 210). Elixirs are called out as "being magical in nature" (Magic 212). This is strengthened by the fact that characters with magic resistance gain this resistance vs alchemy (Magic 213).

Magically Dependent Beings

In addition, magically dependent beings (beings with the actual Magic Dependency disadvantage) would suffer greatly if they came to that world. Faeries, for example, would immediately begin to diminish if they happened upon this world. (Dependency, B130).

share|improve this answer
2  
Please cool it on the comments. They are not for extended discussion or arguments. Post your answer, improve your answer, or not, based on comments. Spend your effort on constructive contribution, not on ephemeral things that will be deleted quickly. –  Brian Ballsun-Stanton Aug 3 at 12:21

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.