Take the 2-minute tour ×
Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

While looking through some classes I found the Archivist class from the Heroes of Horror (page 82). While reading through the spellcasting and prayer book sections however, I find that the wording is really confusing.

Spellcasting: An archivist casts divine spells, drawn primarily from the cleric spell list although he can eventually uncover, learn, and prepare noncleric divine spells spells. Unlike clerics, archivists prepare spells from a prayerbook, a collection of copied divine spells. To learn, prepare, or cast a spell, an archivist must have an Intelligence score equal to at least 10 + the spell level. The Difficulty Class for a saving throw against an archivist’s spell is 10 + the spell level + the archivist’s Int modifier.

This section is rather straight forward use the cleric spell list in general, and eventually you're able to learn spells taken from scroll into your prayer book.

Like other spellcasters, an archivist can cast only a certain number of spells of each level per day. His base daily allotment is given in Table 5–1: The Archivist. In addition, he receives bonus spells per day if he has a high Wisdom score (see Table 1–1 on page 8 of the Player’s Handbook). He must choose and prepare his spells ahead of time by getting a good night’s sleep and then spending 1 hour studying his prayerbook. The archivist decides which spells to prepare while studying.

Here's where I start to get confused, the base spells you know come from the table. The bonus spells he has are derived from the table in the PHB 1, which is per the norm. But in the next section, the Prayerbook is where I'm just turned on my head in confusion.

An archivist begins play with a prayerbook containing all 0-level cleric spells plus three 1st-level cleric spells of the player’s choice. For each point of Intelligence bonus the archivist has, the prayerbook has an additional 1st-level cleric spell. At each new class level, the archivist gains two new cleric spells for his prayerbook; these can be of any spell level or levels that he can cast (based on his new archivist level).

So you start play w/ all the orisons for clerics in your prayerbook, which is a little overpowered but understandable, and 3 spells at the start. On top of those 3 spells you gain 1 spell slot? per bonus Int modifier? Then as the the player advances they gain 2 new spells to be assigned anywhere (obviously not in spells higher then those you can cast) So then would a character get 2 new spells on top of the modified spell allotment? Which would imply that at say level 2 you would have 3 casts of orisons, and (a spec'd int) approximately 7 casts of level 1 spells PLUS the bonus 2 from continuing forward in Archivist class. So then is the chart included what you cast during battle? OR is it the table you use when you're gaining spells?

share|improve this question
    
Do not answer in comments. –  Brian Ballsun-Stanton Mar 19 at 3:50

1 Answer 1

up vote 15 down vote accepted

It helps to think of the archivist as a divine wizard

That’s what he is, with a “prayerbook” instead of a “spellbook” but they work the same way.

Here, I’ll go through the two of them side-by-side to show you. Note that in all cases, when I say “wizard,” I am ignoring the Specialist option for wizards; the wizard in each example is a “generalist.”

Spells per day

A wizard may prepare a number of spells of each level as listed in their Spells per Day table, as well as additional spells for having a high Intelligence score.

An archivist works the same way, except the bonus spells are for having a high Wisdom score rather than Intelligence score. This change is important because everything else an archivist does is based on Intelligence; this split between Intelligence and Wisdom is known as dual-ability dependence, and is a pretty big deal (for example, a wizard could have a very low Wisdom score, relying on his strong Will save to counteract that, but an archivist needs Wisdom for the bonus spells).

Bonus spells are a mechanic common to all spellcasters; the only thing that changes is the ability score used. In all cases, these are only spell slots, not spells known. The amount of bonus spells is given in Table – Ability Modifiers and Bonus Spells.

Spells “known”

Neither archivist nor wizard knows spells the way a sorcerer does; they require an external aid, namely the prayerbook or spellbook. These books may contain many, many spells, but the archivist or wizard must prepare his spells per day (as determined above) ahead of time, so they only have access to a limited subset of the spells they “know” (that is, have in their prayerbook or spellbook).

Neither the archivist nor the wizard has a table indicating their spells known, because they may add as many spells as they can find/afford/fit into their prayerbooks/spellbooks. The table you see is for Spells per Day only.

Both archivist and wizard require that their Intelligence score (not bonus) be at least 10 + the spell’s level to add it to their prayerbook/spellbook, and they must be a high enough level to cast it in order to prepare it.

Other divine spellcasters, like cleric or druid, also must prepare their spells ahead of time, but need no book, since their spells come from their deity or divine forces. In a sense, the gods or powers that such spellcasters pray to form a gigantic “spellbook” for these classes.

Initial spell/prayerbook

A wizard starts play with a spellbook that has every cantrip from the Sor/Wiz list in it, as well as three 1st-level Sor/Wiz spells, plus an additional 1st-level Sor/Wiz spell per Intelligence bonus.

An archivist starts play with a prayerbook that has every orison from the Cleric list in it, as well as three 1st-level Cleric spells, plus an additional 1st-level Cleric spell per Intelligence bonus.

Free spells on level-up

A wizard gets to add two Sor/Wiz spells of up to the highest level he can cast to his spellbook every level.

An archivist gets to add two Cleric spells of up to the highest level he can cast to his prayerbook every level.

Additional spells

Here’s the tricky bit. Both archivists and wizards can add more spells to their prayerbook/spellbook. This costs money, but ultimately not that much money. They have to find the spells to copy them into their books, but this also means they can take advantage of a lot of spells they come across.

Wizards are fairly straight-forward. The spell must come from the Sor/Wiz list, and it must be copied from an arcane scroll or spellbook. For examples, a wizard could copy into his spellbook a scroll of protection from evil that was written by a sorcerer (i.e. arcane scroll, spell is on Sor/Wiz list), but not a scroll of protection from evil that was written by a cleric (on Sor/Wiz list, but not arcane), nor a scroll of cure light wounds written by a bard (arcane, but not on Sor/Wiz list).

Archivists are similar, with one major difference. Where a wizard must copy an arcane scroll or spellbook, an archivist must copy a divine scroll or prayerbook. However, where a wizard can only copy spells that are on the Sor/Wiz list, the archivist doesn’t care what spell list it is on. As long as the scroll or prayerbook is divine, the archivist may copy it, prepare it, and cast it (assuming they can cast spells of that level).

Balance and design

You seem to be a bit confused why things are the way they are, and you questioned the balance of things at least once, so I want to explain what’s going on.

To begin, the archivist is a phenomenally powerful class. It is one of the top five most powerful classes in the game, in fact. The wizard is as well, which is hopefully not surprising at this point since the two are nearly identical. The others are the artificer (Eberron Campaign Setting), cleric, and druid.

I’m going to ignore the oddball (the artificer); for the other four, all are considered to be in the top “tier” because they get extremely powerful spellcasting (up to 9th-level spells, the best there are, and from very good spell lists), and they can change which spells they have every day. That flexibility is fundamentally incredible, and it is that fact alone that separates these spellcasters from the next tier, which includes for example the sorcerer (literally the same list as the wizard, but can’t change spells so easily).

So yes, these classes are incredibly powerful. You’ll notice that three are from the original Player’s Handbook – Wizards simply underestimated what they could do, overestimated what other classes could do, and made mistakes making them.

The archivist was written much later, but was based on the cleric and wizard, so it inherited their power. Since the cleric could already access the entire Cleric spell list, the archivist needed something extra to justify the prayerbook: that extra something was the ability to scribe any divine spells, not just Cleric spells. The archivist also gets pretty nice class features, so it splits between Int/Wis instead of being pure Int or pure Wis. That’s how it got to be the way it is.

share|improve this answer
    
Nice to know that I should consider them as a wizard since that gives me something to work with. –  WalkieTalkie Mar 20 at 3:03

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.