Take the 2-minute tour ×
Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I used the Make Some option to have Fudge dice while waiting for my Evil Hat Fudge Dice to arrive. Now they're here, but my d6s are still all Sharpied up.

The Sharpie will smudge and smear and get all over whatever I roll the dice on, but it won't come off cleanly. I've tried Simple Green, rubbing alcohol, more Sharpie and rubbing it off, dry erase marker and rubbing it off... My dice are now grey-on-grey Fudge dice with random black pips peeping through.

They're ordinary white plastic game dice, from a variety of sources. How can I get them less Fudgey and more d6y again?

share|improve this question
4  
You can't get it off? I've never been able to get it to stay on... –  Clockwork-Muse Apr 5 at 18:02
1  
I'm posting as a comment and not an answer 'cause I'm not sure it will work, but I usually use alcohol to remove sharpie and it usually works. Sometimes I use hand-sanitizing alcohol gel and that works too. (never tried it on dice) –  TecBrat Apr 7 at 3:25

5 Answers 5

I'm afraid the economically viable answer is "don't". You seem to have spent some time and resources on trying to clean the dice, if you had spent it on buying new dice, you would have ended up with a whole bag of them.

If you aren't emotionally attached to exactly this set of dice, go out and buy new ones.

You may want to find a simple department store that has board games, because if your role playing game stores around you are anything like mine, a set of 2c chinese made plastic cubes suddenly becomes "$brandname quality dice". And somehow with that branding, they get a pricetag that is just unbelivable. Go to a store where they sell dice, not brands and you will get new dice for less than the amount you would have spent on cleaning chemicals at your local supermarket.

share|improve this answer
1  
Fair enough, but since I have yet to spend more than about an hour applying dabs of already-at-hand home supplies to a couple dice, and I hate replacing things if I can re-use them, I'm still hoping for non-replacement strategies. –  BESW Apr 5 at 13:05
2  
+1. If you're spending more than about $0.15 per die on cleaning them (labor included), you'd be better off buying new ones. A standard Chessex 36d6 set will cost you a little over $6 in most places, and for $30 you can get enough cheap dice to hurt you if you drop them on your toe. I'd suggest just treating the sharpie-marked ones the same way as you'd treat, say, used scrap paper. You made something with them, got some use out of them, learned something in the process, and now they've served their purpose. –  Ilmari Karonen Apr 6 at 14:22

The only success I have ever had removing sharpie from a surface is with...sharpie!

By applying new sharpie over the old, and wiping clean immediately, I have removed sharpie from a non-porous surface - a whiteboard where someone had used sharpie instead of removable marker.

My theory is that the solvent in the new sharpie dissolves the pigment in the old one. Use a light color if you can - not black or red.

Good luck!

share|improve this answer
2  
I've sometimes had success with using erasable markers to dilute/remove non-erasable ones. –  keshlam Apr 6 at 22:01

Acetone (nail-polish remover) will completely and cleanly remove Sharpie, as the pigments used in Sharpie are soluble in acetone.

CAUTION:

Make certain that your dice are not made of polystyrene, as this plastic also dissolves in acetone. Most dice are not made of polystyrene, but just in case, this is fair warning.

Dampen a paper towel with acetone and wipe the surface of your dice. You will probably need to repeat several times, using a clean piece of acetone-dampened paper towel each time.

You can get pure acetone nail polish remover (without all the nasty scents and additives) in the pharmacy section at Walmart or Walgreen's or Wal-whatever.

share|improve this answer
5  
Note: Make sure the remover you buy contains acetone. "Non-acetone nail polish remover" is often right next to the acetone stuff, and won't do a damn thing to remove anything but the cheapest nail polish. –  Yamikuronue Apr 5 at 23:43
1  
This would be my go-to solution. That said, be careful around the pips. Depending on the dice, if the pips were painted on the acetone may remove the pip color too - though this can be remedied by the actual problem (sharpie them back on >_>) –  Doc Apr 6 at 2:58
    
+1 for the exact answer I had in mind before (luckily) reading. –  CatLord Apr 9 at 3:32

Sharpie ink consists of a solvent (ethanol), a dyestuff and a resin which is dissolved in the ink but will harden into a film once the ink dries. Some Sharpies also use pigments, but from the evidence I would suspect this one uses dyestuff.

The root problem is migration of dyestuff into the substrate, even if it looks solid to the naked eye. Glass and metals are migration-proof, but the polymers used for articles to which some printing has been applied must have some surface irregularities for the printing ink to stick well. ABS is a good example. When you apply Sharpie ink to these polymers, you can only remove it cleanly within the first few minutes. Even after several hours, some traces will remain, and this only gets worse with time.

I guess nvoigt has given you the best advice so far.

share|improve this answer

Mr. Clean Magic Erasers

Mr. Clean Magic Erasers are perfect for removing all kinds of markings from almost anything except paper products. These erasers use microfine abrasive material, rather than chemicals, to sand marks away on a microscopic level. However, much to my great surprise, even though they are abrasives, they do not scar plastic unless you scrub REALLY hard for a LONG time. I used them to restore valuable old video game cartridges to like-new condition, so I didn't want the plastic to be abraded and I was amazed at how even the dirtiest, most marked up Nintendo 64 cartridge could be made to look almost brand new with Magic Erasers.

Even better, because they don't use/contain chemical cleaners, you don't have to worry about chemical odors or chemicals messing up the plastic like some chemicals can.

In addition, they are commonly found in many stores in the cleaning supplies section and they are very inexpensive, around $1.50 for a box of 2 and one eraser will last a long time.

Here is what the box looks like:

enter image description here

However, they sometimes have different boxes, here are some pictures.

To use them, just get them a bit damp & scrub until the marker goes away. Often the marker can go away pretty quickly. Sometimes you have to scrub for a while, but it will almost always go away after a while. Just be careful not to scrub down in the pips too much if you have paint in them, or you'll scrub off the paint.

I learned this trick from a used video game store owner when I was buying and cleaning old video games & equipment. These Magic Erasers worked SO well, getting tons of marker marks and scuff marks off video game cartridges, video game consoles, walls, etc. -- stuff I never thought would come off the plastic, and the erasers don't abrade the plastic at all, unless you scrub REALLY hard for a LONG time (then you start to see a very fine change in the way light reflects off the area).

I highly recommend them!

share|improve this answer
    
Fun fact: Magic Erasers are made of Melamine foam - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melamine_foam –  Cthos Apr 8 at 18:52
    
Almost gave the +1 however there is a cheaper, easier answer but I'll have to keep it in mind for other situations. –  CatLord Apr 9 at 3:34
    
Nice trick with these is if you buy the large ones (the size of a kitchen sponge), then you can cut it down to many matchbox sized mini-sponges –  Oxinabox May 24 at 14:27

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.