Take the 2-minute tour ×
Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. It's 100% free, no registration required.

What are ways to incorporate a luck stat into a d20 based system as a seventh stat of 10+/- or just a direct modifier. Should the player have the ability to choose or change it in character generation, or should it be something assigned by the DM?

I'd like the luck stat to be able to adjust d20 rolls. Examples could include:

  • a direct and always-on bonus to critical confirmation rolls
  • a number of re-rolls per day/session/adventure
  • a straight of luck roll to see if something around them happens or is present

Please follow Good Subjective, Bad Subjective and describe the results in play of your experience with a Luck stat.

share|improve this question
    
Dungeon Crawl Classics comes to mind as a D&D with a Luck stat. You should take a look at what Goodman Games does with it. –  okeefe Apr 19 at 14:49

3 Answers 3

up vote 7 down vote accepted

Assuming you want it to be a seventh ability score, here’s an idea. It expands on a mechanic I have used often in my games and find quite useful.

The Luck Score

Luck is an ability score. It ranges from 0 upwards, and produces a Luck modifier equal to ⌊Luck/2⌋-5, as all ability scores do. Be sure to modify your character generation rules to account for a seventh ability score (e.g. multiply your Point Buy by 7/6, figure out a roughly median value for a new entry in your ability array, or just keep rolling).

To maintain the ability to improve ability scores as you level up, +1 to an ability score of choice is recommended at the following levels: 4, 7, 10, 14, 17, and 20, instead of 4, 8, 12, 16, and 20.

Luck Checks

Luck checks consist of rolling 1d20 and adding your Luck modifier. They may be used to gauge your results in a game of chance, or at other points when the DM decides luck is particularly relevant.

Skills

No skills are based purely on Luck; by definition if you can train in it, it’s not pure luck.

Luck 0

Having your luck reduced to 0 results in immediate and extremely unlikely death.

Luck Nonability

Creatures with a nonability for Luck, that is, Luck –, simply behave as if Luck did not exist as an ability score for them. Such creatures receive no Action Points (see below).

Creatures with and without Luck

I cannot go through all the creatures out there and assign them Luck scores, so here are some rules of thumb. Mindless creatures and non-living creatures (most constructs, the undead) usually have Luck –, as do most creatures of the Animal type and many of the Magical Beast type. Lawful outsiders also often lack a Luck score. For the rest, the more aggressive and reckless a creature is, the more likely it is to have a high Luck score.

Magical Bonuses to Luck

Bonuses that improve luck are rarer than those for other ability scores. In reliable, item form, they are almost unheard of, though powerful items like the luck blade may offer some. The rabbit’s luck spell is just like the cat’s grace spell but for Luck, and in that it is a 4th-level spell for clerics, druids, paladins, rangers, sorcerers, and wizards. Bards receive it as a 2nd-level spell, however. No mass rabbit’s luck spell is known.

Luck and Action Points

Action Points are the primary advantage of a high luck score, and the primary disadvantage of a low luck score. They are a creature’s ability to “get lucky” on things it does.

Action Points per Level

Now then, Luck controls a creature’s use of Action Points, which are defined in much the same way as they are in Eberron Campaign Setting. A creature gains a number of Action Points when it levels up equal to 5+⌊Level/2⌋, so 5 at first level, 6 at second and third levels, 7 at fourth and fifth levels, and so on. These points, when spent, are not refreshed until the next time that creature levels up. Any points remaining when the creature levels up are lost; they do not “carry over.”

Good Luck

When you have Luck greater than 10 (“good luck”), the effect of expending an Action Point is to roll X‍d6, where X is your Luck modifier, and taking the highest value rolled and adding it to the result of an attack roll, a skill check, an ability check, or a saving throw. You may only choose to use an Action Point after the numerical value of the roll is known, but before the effects of that roll are known.

Bad Luck

When a creature has Luck less than 10 (“bad luck”), a number of its Action Points are given to the DM to use against it. The number is equal to how much less than 10 the Luck score is (so 1 for Luck 9, 5 for Luck 5).

For these Action Points, the DM may choose to expend an Action Point and subtract the highest result of the X‍d6 rolled from an attack roll, a skill check, an ability check, or a saving throw. The DM must choose to do so before the unlucky creature has rolled, however. After the DM has done this, the Action Point is transferred back to the unlucky creature.

The Action Points not given to the DM cannot be used against the creature. However, these Action Points, as well as those the creature receives after the DM has used one of the Action Points he received, are not useful to the creature for the usual purpose of adding a bonus to an attack roll, a skill check, an ability check, or a saving throw. They may be useful for feats and class features, however.

Neutral Luck

For a creature with Luck 10, expending an Action Point in this manner does nothing (since zero d6s are rolled). There may, however, be other opportunities to use them.

Frequency Limits

In no case may more than one Action Point be used on the same roll. The DM is furthermore prevented from expending a bad luck Action Point more than once per round for a given creature with bad luck.

Feats and Class Features

The feats and class features in Eberron Campaign Setting and elsewhere that rely on Action Points may be used with these Luck-based Action Points, with the following modifications:

  • Action Boost (EBCS): Instead of X‍d6 becoming X‍d8 permanently, this feat gives you the optional ability to change X‍d6 into (X-1)d8. Additionally, you may take Action Boost again to get the option of changing X‍d6 into (X-2)d10, and a third time to get the option of (X-3)d12. These options cannot be used if you have bad luck.

  • Action Healing (FoE): If you have Luck 15, you may use two of the options rather than only one. If you have Luck 19, you may use all three at once, every time you use an Action Point this way.

  • Action Surge (EBCS): This requires Luck 19 as well as BAB +3.

  • Heroic Channeling (FoE): This requires Luck 15 in addition to its usual requirements.

  • Heroic Companion (MoE): Your animal companion, special mount, homunculus, or other companion creature uses your Luck modifier for determining its use of your Action Points with this feat.

  • Heroic Spirit (EBCS): The 3 bonus Action Points you receive cannot be used against you, even if you have bad luck.

  • All feats based on Dragonmarks and applying to Action Points (there are a lot of those) may treat a character with Luck 15 as having a Least Dragonmark, a character with Luck 19 as having a Lesser Dragonmark, a character with Luck 23 as having a Greater Dragonmark, and a character with Luck 27 as having a Siberys Dargonmark for the purposes of requirements and effects of the feat on uses of Action Points. Any effects of the feat that do not involve Action Points are unusable if you do not actually have the required Dragonmark. In no situation does Luck allow you to use the spell-like abilities of a Dragonmark you do not have.

Finally, a new feat is added:

  • Warded Against Disaster: When you have bad luck, the DM may use Action Points against you no more than once per encounter.

Conclusion and Analysis

I have played with Eberron-style Action Points many, many times, and find the system enjoyable. The addition of an actual Luck ability score here changes a few things about the system, but because you are rolling a number of dice and choosing the highest, there are diminishing returns on very-high luck (which is why I changed Action Boost as I did). The very-limited ability to get additional Action Points, and the slow rate of refresh, ensures that Action Points remain special and important.

I particularly like that there’s a whole feast of already-existing feats and class features that immediately tie into Luck, through the existing Action Point options.

The bad luck mechanics are the ones that are most tricky. I believe I have found a solid balance there: they are decidedly negative, but not so bad that it’s insane to allow yourself to have negative Luck.

I am definitely interested in feedback on how this works out in a game.

share|improve this answer

For years during AD&D Second Edition, I always added two custom stats, a Luck stat and a Perception stat, including use in a five year long deep in-character campaign. The Perception stat has obviously been superseded by the Perception skill in d20 but was invaluable at the time. The Luck stat I used worked in this way.

  1. You would roll d20 against Luck whenever there was basically a random chance of something going your way or not. There was always a bunch of advice on the topic of luck out in the RPG-sphere with people variously saying "roll 50/50!" or "just say yes!" but I found those options to have insufficient texture to them. So for example, when the party is in a room, and we're not using minis and no one's bothered to tell me where they are, and the thief pulls a lever setting off a flamethrower trap that covers part of the room, it's a Luck roll to see who's standing in the blast area. Or when the party is split up and a random encounter occurs, who is it that the roper tries to snag first. Or if someone's disarmed in a fight in the forest and they want to know if there's a nearby branch sufficient for use as a club, that's also a Luck roll. This has the advantage of taking some decision-making off the GM and giving a more simulated world feel to gameplay. It's not the GM being arbitrary and telling you there's not a nearby branch, it's you rolling your stat.

  2. You could cash in a Luck point - a point permanently deducted from the Luck stat - to get some kind of major save. Not a bonus to a roll, but an "escape death" or "auto-succeed" or similar. See Pathfinder Fate Points for a little more on general approaches, but over time I've found that "bonuses to a roll" like Action Points become more of a fiddly pain than they're worth, and players would rather just have a smaller amount of "save your butt for reals" chips to cash in. Note that in this scheme the more you do it, the worse your Luck becomes, and the more things don't go your way on an ongoing basis. I'd very occasionally award a Luck point (less than once a level) for some death-defying act of heroic badassness (conducted without using a Luck point).

I used this a long time in 2e. It was very successful, even though I suspect in some games the cannibalization of Luck points wouldn't work ("I use them all then roll a new character, woot!"), my games had a lot of character association and simulation and so we didn't have that problem. I used Luck rolls a lot and players definitely valued having a good Luck stat. It couldn't necessarily get you out of trouble, but it could keep you from getting into it in the first place, and no one wanted to dump-stat it much.

With the rise of 3e the main problem with using this scheme directly becomes the advent of point buy. When rolling stats, adding a seventh (or eighth, or whatever) has no imbalancing effect, but with d20, the more stats you have, the more points you have to give for point buy, the more someone can min-max their Strength and dump everything else and make it the party's problem. Though real men roll their stats, enough people have adopted the cult of the custom build that I had to change approach from having it as a stat.

One thing I've done is to use Charisma as the Luck stat. "It's how much the gods like you, too" is the explanation for that combination. So when someone's looking for that branch to club someone with, it's a Charisma check. This is mostly successful, but the heavy min-max culture of d20 does end up generating those "CHA 24" types that have a perfect Luck. Of course, I guess that's how Seoni stays within that dress she wears. As a result, I stopped using the stat as ablative for hero point/luck point purposes and do that separately.

share|improve this answer

The Myriador conversion of the Fighting Fantasy adventures included a version of the Luck mechanic for d20. It wasn't hugely fleshed out, but (relevant portion of review)

The original Fighting Fantasy books had a Luck attribute. Myriador now makes it a d20 mechanic. Luck starts off as any attribute, including its modifier. (Eg. a Luck of 16 gives a +3 modifier.) Luck is usable in almost any situation: As a bonus to hit, increase in AC, damage reduction, skill check bonus, etc.. Essentially, BEFORE the dice are rolled, a player announces he will make a Luck check, and reduces his Luck by one. He then rolls a d20 and adds his modifier, against a Luck DC, typically 10. For every two points above 10, he receives a +1 modifier. But if he fails by six or more, he receives a -2 modifier. Luck can be regained through Luck-related magical items and normal regeneration of ability points. Like experience points, the GM may also award Luck. If you use a point-generation system for characters, they start off with an additional five points, since they now have an additional ability score. For existing characters, the GM can simply fiat that these five points go into the character's Luck attribute.

The Pathfinder Advanced Player's Guide also includes a Hero Point mechanic.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.