How can I reward Cthulhu characters for going mad?

Question

I like it when, in Cthulhu games, Investigators go mad. With that in mind, I'd like to give some reward for the first Investigator to go mad.

For example, perhaps, at the beginning of the next game, the player whose Investigator went mad first in the last game gets first choice of character.

I'd like something I can use both in Trail of Cthulhu and Call of Cthulhu. I'd also like something that affects the game, something more than just a social reward (a social reward would be, for example, getting the last beer).

Any ideas?

Answer 1

I'd like to see it work by creating some kind of link between the character who goes mad, and the one that follows. If you want a simple mechanical solution, get the player to select one mundane skill (i.e. not Mythos), preferably knowledge-based, from the first character's sheet. The next character then gets this skill at the old character's level for free.

Maybe it's a mystery to them that they have this knowledge. Maybe they experience bits of the old character's life in dreams, or occasionally stumble across their possessions. Or maybe they've trained in this skill, and it seems completely normal to them. You'd have to keep making it different, or it could get rather old. Could be fun, though.

Answer 2

How about one or two mystical tomes already extant in the PC's book collection? You can decide whether they've already been read or not.

How about allowing the PC to start with some small amount of Cthulhu Mythos knowledge (with the associated affect on the PC's sanity levels applied, of course).

These would seem to be in keeping with the kind of intertextual event that you're rewarding.

Answer 3

I am only familiar with CoC (and especially older editions...) the first thing I can imagine would be to give an increase to POW for their character.

Either a reroll (just once, just POW, keep the best score) or a flat +1 or +2 to the rolled result.

This way you get:

1) A reward 
2) Something that is not unbalancing
3) Something that is not Mythos related... or better yet, 
   it is, but not in the opposite sense, see #4
4) Something that makes the character (slightly) less prone 
   to becoming mad the next time.

Answer 4

A colourful description of the lurid effects of their mania on the outside world is usually reward enough for players in my Lovecraftian games. Description of the character dying messily also seems to go down well. Then again, my players are usually so aware that madness and/or death are inevitable for CoC characters that they're almost edging for it from the start so your mileage may vary.