Questions tagged [house-rules]
House rules are small fan-created additions and replacements to core rules in a rules set, and this tag should be used when there are locally-created rules at the core of the question. In most cases, they are not officially sanctioned by the designer, in contrast to optional rules (see the [optional-rules] tag). For creation of substantial new content or rules subsystems, use the [homebrew] tag instead.
157
questions
157
votes
22
answers
20k
views
How do you help players not focus on the rules?
Background — My Group's Gaming Style
When I GM, I run games loosely from a rules standpoint, and do not feel bound to adhere to what the rulebook says when it doesn't make sense in a given situation. ...
24
votes
3
answers
11k
views
What Are Freedom of Movement's Limits?
What conditions and effects does the spell freedom of movement [abjur] (PH 233) overcome?
I want a fair, reasonable, and consistent method to determine what spells and conditions are overcome by the ...
27
votes
11
answers
76k
views
How to allow cantrips to be changed
The wizard in my game has requested the ability to change out his cantrips similarly to his higher level spells. His justification is that every other wizard spell is memorizable, so having fixed ...
26
votes
5
answers
2k
views
Which balancing issues, if any, would arise from allowing PCs to spend actions on bonus action features?
I understand that RAW, features/spells/etc. that require a bonus action (e.g. Bardic Inspiration or Healing Word) cannot be used with a regular action instead (see this question).
However, what would ...
21
votes
3
answers
5k
views
What effects do critical and fumble tables have on D&D 3.5?
Just getting some extra damage, and just missing, seem pretty boring. A lot of people like to spruce things up by having critical hits and natural-1 fumbles result in a roll on a special table, which ...
100
votes
13
answers
33k
views
3d6 vs a d20: What is the effect of a different probability curve?
What is the effect on game play of replacing d20 rolls with 3d6 rolls in a D&D 4e campaign?
I started thinking about this after reading this question where the example was given of playing a d20 ...
35
votes
3
answers
4k
views
What overpowered combinations would be available if I allow a bonus action to be used in place of a standard action?
It has come up in game a couple of times that a player might want to cast a spell that has a casting time of 1 bonus action using their "main" action (if they have another bonus action they also want ...
22
votes
3
answers
5k
views
How can I convert D&D 5e Saving Throws into Defences?
In D&D 5, the saving throws for spells has the following formula:
The DC is set to 8 + prof bonus + magical stat bonus.
The target then makes a saving throw, adding their stat bonus and hoping ...
20
votes
4
answers
15k
views
If Beast Master Rangers could use bonus actions to attack with their companion, what problems would occur?
If a clause was added to Beast Master Rangers to allow them to spend a bonus action to have their companion to make a single attack after the ranger makes their own Attack action, what would the ...
6
votes
3
answers
4k
views
Writing a better Weapon Focus feat
Last time a played D&D it was 3.0, and I remember thinking the Weapon Focus feat is kind of dull, but it's sometimes a prerequisite for more advanced feats.
So I would like to rewrite it something ...
27
votes
5
answers
6k
views
Balancing Spellcasters; Spontaneous Casters versus Prepared Casters
So ask any optimizer and they'll almost always tell you the same thing: in 3.5 classes that prepare spells are better than spontaneous spellcasters. It's generally not thought of as even a contest. ...
19
votes
3
answers
3k
views
Balance implications of removing unseen-attacker advantage when mutually unseen
The rules for unseen attackers (PHB p. 194-195) specify that attacking a creature that cannot see you = advantage, and attacking a creature you cannot see = disadvantage:
When you attack a target ...
19
votes
6
answers
17k
views
How do I adjudicate attempting to put manacles on an unwilling creature?
I have a player in my campaign who has recently wanted to use manacles. While the Player's Handbook entry for manacles describes in a pretty detailed way how difficult it is to escape from manacles, ...
14
votes
3
answers
2k
views
Where does a traveler arrive when a planar location's unspecified?
When a creature is successfully targeted by an effect that transports the creature to another plane but no location on that plane is specified, where does the creature arrive?
If the plane is the ...
7
votes
3
answers
2k
views
What if standing up from prone didn't provoke attacks of opportunity?
For an upcoming campaign I'm considering making a house rule saying that A creature can take a move action that doesn't provoke attacks of opportunity to stand up from prone. Alternatively, I'm ...
6
votes
4
answers
917
views
What effects would allowing same-class multiclassing have on interclass balance?
In Pathfinder, taking multiple copies of a class is controversial from a rules-based perspective. Most of the groups I have played with allow same-class multiclassing in 3.5 but not Pathfinder. I ...
68
votes
17
answers
79k
views
I dislike how players accurately place fireballs. Is there an alternative?
I'm running 5e on a grid with minis. The one thing that I hate is when sorcerers or wizards cast a fireball that perfectly hits enemies in the AOE. The player counts the squares on the grid to ...
22
votes
10
answers
5k
views
How do I tweak this crouching rule to balance it?
My ranger uses light crossbow. A few sessions back, he flavored his movement and attack as "I move there, and crouch before attacking." In character, previously he taught the others that it ...
22
votes
7
answers
4k
views
What are the consequences of removing the potential for critical hit extra damage on spell attacks?
Current table has a house rule that spells attacks can not deal extra damage through critical hits. They have the rule that you can critically succeed or fail on a natural 20 or 1 on saving throws.
...
21
votes
6
answers
4k
views
What issues could arise with this Advantage/Disadvantage Variant?
Background
In the Player's Handbook, it is specified that Advantage and Disadvange sources effectively "cancel out" regardless of how many there are of each:
If circumstances cause a roll ...
21
votes
3
answers
6k
views
Can an invisible creature see themselves and their own gear?
Suppose there's an everyday ordinary human character who becomes invisible, either due to quaffing a potion of invisibility or from somebody casting the invisibility spell on him. This causes both him ...
20
votes
7
answers
4k
views
What balance issues would arise from a house rule imposing a saving throw versus exhaustion after a PC falls unconscious?
In my last campaign, some combat encounters got pretty ridiculous, mainly due to some player characters falling unconscious and getting back up every turn. I remember one combat encounter in ...
19
votes
7
answers
3k
views
Is this alternative initiative house-rule balanced?
As a fairly new DM, one thing that has commonly occurred in my sessions so far is my PC's starting combat outside of initiative.
For example after a telepathic conversation with a Nothic was going ...
19
votes
3
answers
3k
views
How would changing critical hits like this affect my game?
Everyone gets excited when they see that dice roll turning up a 20. A 20 on a test means that you succeeded on what you were trying to do in the best way possible — it's a rewarding situation that ...
18
votes
4
answers
5k
views
Will this house-rule method of choosing prepared spells unbalance the game?
I have a party consisting of two PCs; a lv5 fighter (3 fighter, 1 rogue, 1 barbarian) , and a lv5 ranger (4 ranger, 1 cleric).
Focusing on the ranger for the purposes of this question. She doubles as ...
17
votes
3
answers
3k
views
How to determine PC genetics in D&D for the purpose of creating 2nd generation PC's [closed]
I remember watching "The Dungeons & Dragons Experience" and one of the people featured in the documentary mentioned how him and his friends had developed a way to blend and randomize attributes of ...
16
votes
3
answers
6k
views
What are the impacts of permitting casters to concentrate on 2 spells?
A common lament at tables I play at from players is often the inherent limitation on being able to maintain concentration on only one spell at a time. This doesn't just come from casters, but also ...
10
votes
1
answer
45k
views
What is the conversion rate for Sorcery Points to Spell Points?
On page 288-289 of the DMG, there is an optional rule: Variant: Spell Points.
I frequently use this optional rule at my table. I'm interested in streamlining resource-management even further, by ...
5
votes
2
answers
32k
views
Where can I find Matt Mercer's Critical Role House Rules?
I'd like to use house rules from Critical Role in my own campaigns, and while we may tweak them once we've tried them, they seem to work well for Matt and his players, so what they use would be a good ...
37
votes
6
answers
17k
views
Making aging relevant: How can I translate premature aging into a mechanical effect?
My group is about to come across a haunted sunken keep with an adversarial Ghost mini-boss. Being mostly composed of Humans (because who doesn't want a free feat?), I expect them to be particularly ...
29
votes
3
answers
16k
views
Would allowing a Thief (with Fast Hands) to use the Healer feat's tending action as a bonus action be balanced?
Related: usable objects with Fast Hands
The Healer feat states:
[...] As an action, you can spend one use of a healer’s kit to tend to a creature and restore 1d6 + 4 hit points to it, plus ...
26
votes
10
answers
5k
views
Does rolling AC to oppose an Attack Roll impact game balance?
I really like the concept of rolling d20 against each other during ability checks like grappling, etc. I want the same thing for normal attacks, so the defender would also roll a d20 + (AC-10).
Would ...
21
votes
2
answers
6k
views
Why is allowing players to stack their skill proficiency bonus overpowered?
I am the DM for a campaign and play with the following house rules:
When gaining proficiency in any skill (during character creation, taking the Skilled feat, etc.), you may choose a skill more than ...
20
votes
1
answer
1k
views
What are the balance effects of counting instances granting Advantage and Disadvantage to determine Advantage?
This is based on the text in Page 5 of Xanathar's Guide to Everything:
Even if more than one factor gives you advantage or
disadvantage on a roll, you have it only once, and if you
have ...
20
votes
3
answers
2k
views
How to use table seating order for initiative without nerfing initiative-based features?
Although I've experimented with the alternative initiative rules in the DMG and with other ideas I've read about online, I always return to the standard initiative rules in 5e combined with initiative ...
17
votes
9
answers
1k
views
What are the pros, cons, and hitches of having only the players roll dice?
I ran a variant of DnD3.5 a few years a go with this house rule Player Only Rolls. The basic of the idea was that the referee never rolls at all. The players roll to attack vers the creatures AC. They ...
16
votes
6
answers
25k
views
Drawing and sheathing weapons as one item interaction
In PHB, page 190, it explains about the free item interaction:
You can also interact with one object or feature of the environment for free, during either your move or your action. For example, you ...
15
votes
6
answers
3k
views
Consequences of having half damage on attacks that tie AC as house rule?
Typically if an attack roll equals the AC of a target then the attack does normal damage. I quite like the idea of making it a glancing blow, dealing half damage instead, this would help clue the PCs ...
15
votes
4
answers
4k
views
How does replacing Advantage with a flat +2 affect Champion critical hit damage output?
My DM does not like Advantage/Disadvantage. While I disagree with his reasons on this, he has decided to replace it with a +2/-2 rule and I respect him (mostly) enough to follow his rules.
I recently ...
14
votes
1
answer
1k
views
Impact of swapping Flags for Bonds in Dungeon World?
An answer on this site recently pointed me to Rob Donoghue's Flags system as a possible replacement for Dungeon World's Bonds.
How does this system impact game play and table dynamics?
I'm ...
13
votes
3
answers
7k
views
Advantage on damage rolls - is it still balanced?
Something that bothers me about the advantage/disadvantage system is that it doesn't actually affect how much damage you do in a single attack, only the likelihood that the attack will hit. For ...
13
votes
3
answers
20k
views
Will adding helmets unbalance the game?
I can't find any mention of a helmet in the Player Handbook in the armour table, and the only helmets I can find are magic items like The Helm of Telepathy.
Would it be unbalanced to allow helmets to ...
13
votes
3
answers
8k
views
Is this the correct way to resolve a missed Ice Knife?
Ice Knife:
Make a ranged spell attack against the target. On a hit, the target takes 1d10 piercing damage. Hit or miss, the shard then explodes. The target and each creature within 5 feet of the ...
12
votes
3
answers
7k
views
Would adding Necromancy spells to the Druid's spell list break anything?
I am new to D&D and will be starting with a group of other beginners in a few days. We got ourselves 5e and will have a four-character group: a rogue GMPC, a barbarian, a paladin and a wizard (or ...
11
votes
3
answers
4k
views
Is it possible to substitute actual items for the material components in spells?
Generally speaking, material components and focus objects for spells (or at least, the ones without costs listed) are there purely for flavour and the occasional lame joke (like using fur and an amber ...
11
votes
2
answers
11k
views
Would it be game breaking to allow a Warlock to use his Mystic Arcanum to cast his spells at a higher level?
I'm looking for ways to make the Warlock feel more flexible with his castings, and I like this solution, especially since it's limited by how few spellslots Warlocks have of higher level spells (...
11
votes
2
answers
4k
views
Are there any balance issues with allowing thrown Javelins to be drawn for free like ammunition weapons?
Weapons that have the ammunition property, such as bows and crossbows, can be used without having to worry about the action economy with regards to the ammunition itself (such as arrows or bolts) as ...
11
votes
3
answers
2k
views
Mechanical side effects of randomised Initiative in 5e
Initiative
I am starting a new 5e campaign and I am planning to use randomised initiative.
I feel recording initiative take too long, for both my players and me. I tried grouping monsters and pre-...
10
votes
4
answers
39k
views
How to limit the power of "Find Steed" spell when allowing other creatures to be summoned
Our Paladin just hit 5th-level and he's taking the Find Steed spell. The spell is incredibly powerful: a free mount that never disappears unless it drops to 0 hit points (you can resummon it twice per ...
10
votes
3
answers
2k
views
Would these multi-classing house rules cause unintended problems?
I'm part of an RPG Group that plays multiple campaigns in multiple systems. Lately, two of our members have announced interest in a D&D 5e campaign, which isn't a system this group has played ...