Tag Info

Hot answers tagged


DM Rulings and 1e AD&D Rules Combine for a reasonable outcome This answer requires a caveat: there is no strict rule about critical hits in the 1e books, to include Unearthed Arcana, but a lot of 1e DM's use critical hits of varying sorts. The rules in the DMG, p. 61, explicitly put critical hits outside of the rules. 1: Can a Frost Brand weapon ...


The answer to all aspects of this question is “Ask your DM”. Fortunately, your DM has made it very clear how these things work, so yes: this is how these things work. I get that you don't like the ruling, but this is AD&D, where it's the job of the DM to decide the Truth About the World, including making decisions about how magic items function in the ...

Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible