Hot answers tagged

35

Tasting isn't quaffing. Chances are he didn't gargle the potion to get a feel for what was in it, he got a bit on the tip of his finger and then rubbed it on his tongue. He would be able to tell from just a bit of a taste that no this is not a potion ow why is my tongue burning. If he explicitly states that he sucks the potions down like a vacuum cleaner ...


29

As BESW said, don't expect the game system to model reality. That said, if you need to figure out stats for potato tea... It's an ingested poison. As the SRD says, Ingested poisons are virtually impossible to utilize in a combat situation. A poisoner could administer a potion to an unconscious creature or attempt to dupe someone into drinking or ...


25

Malignant poison reads As a full-round action, the alchemist can increase the save DC of any poison by 4 and increase its duration by 2 frequency increments (for example, large scorpion venom lasts 8 rounds instead of 6 and drow poison lasts 4 minutes instead of 2). Additionally, malignant poisons take effect immediately and do not have an onset ...


24

As far as I am aware, there is no way to give a creature the incapacitated condition directly. However, there are 4 conditions that give a creature the incapacitated condition as part of their effects. These are: Paralysed Petrified Stunned Unconscious There are a number of ways to apply these conditions without damaging your beloved pet. Within the ...


22

If he explicitly swallows "a gulp" of draconic acid (presumably analogous to Black Dragon breath) then yes, he's very very dead. That falls into the "inescapable death" situations described in the core books (trapped in a pit with the roof descending to crush you, drowning in an acid pool etc.). Human stomach acid has got nothing on the kind of ...


21

Your GM was right... technically... and depending on the details. And he was right for a reason other than the one he gave. Your explanation of the situation could be interpreted in two ways. When you say: "When I affected an enemy with it, my GM succeeded the 1st save" ...if you meant the enemy had already failed a save before the GM made his 1st ...


16

The Green Dragon's breath is described as: Poison Breath (Recharge 5-6). The dragon exhales poisonous gas in a 90-foot cone. Each creature in that area must make a DC 22 Constitution saving throw, taking 77 (22d6) poison damage on a failed save, or half as much damage on a successful one. It is "poisonous gas" the Dwarf gets advantage on the ...


14

So, this is how poisons (and most other afflictions) work: You suffer the effects every time you fail a save The frequency tells you how often you make a save, once the onset time has passed If there is no onset, you make a save immediately The poison is finished when the conditions for a cure are met, or the duration has elapsed For black adder venom, ...


14

The DC for Poison is a formula. The static value listed in a monster's stat block is a convenience so that GMs don't have to calculate it themselves. From the d20 SRD: The Fortitude save DC against a creature’s natural poison attack is equal to 10 + ½ poisoning creature’s racial HD + poisoning creature’s Con modifier (the exact DC is given in the ...


13

All attacks do a minimum of one point of damage regardless of damage penalties. Therefore the poison would still potentially affect the target. If penalties reduce the damage result to less than 1, a hit still deals 1 point of damage. Note that in Pathfinder the rule is slightly different - If penalties reduce the damage result to less than 1, a ...


13

There is no rule inconsistency; it is a disconnect between game logic and real-life experience. D&D is not a reality simulator; its mechanics are abstracted and --as you've noticed-- the value of things are proportionate to their use in adventuring rather than the difficulty in making them or the value of their component parts. While many people play ...


12

I don't know the RAW answer, but from a practical standpoint I would say that ingesting a contact poison causes the effects - it IS coming into contact with you, against soft tissue no less! It will also likely get on your lips if it's in a drink. Ergo, eating contact poison should poison you. If the poison is baked into something, or added before/during ...


12

So first of all, the poison list isn't meant to list "anything that could be poisonous if ingested," which includes a lot of stuff, but things that are useful as proper poisons (subtle, easy to deliver, etc.). Compare solanine (the stuff in potatoes) to arsenic (which is listed on the poison table) - not only is it less than half as poisonous (requiring ...


12

The DM is in his right to say that, but he should discuss it with you or make it clear that this kind of house rule exists beforehand That said, did he specify why it "doesn't make sense"? The poison having 2 saving throws serves to make it harder to resist, so it actually does make sense that those two dice rolls are in place. To directly answer your ...


12

It is a bit unclear what do you mean by the word "affected". If you just delivered poison, then your DM was right. In this case his NPC's first save would be to not be poisoned at all. He doesn't need to make more than that one save no matter what type of poison you use. Check the bottom of this page for "How Do Poisons Work?" summary. But if his NPC ...


11

The DMG pp. 257-258 has a bit of what you're looking for: descriptions of fourteen sample potions, with damages and costs. A few individual descriptions contain enough detail to make (some) ingredients obvious--see Carrion Crawler Mucus and Serpent Venom, for example. As for crafting poison... During downtime between adventures a character can use the ...


10

You gain the effect of an injury poison continuously while the poison remains potent. From the catalogue of poison types (DMG p. 257): Injury. A creature that takes slashing or piercing damage from a weapon or piece of ammunition coated with injury poison is exposed to its effects. In the case of Basic Poison (PH p.153) the duration is quite ...


10

As you stated in your question, this is a creature ability, not a weapon bonus. You can think of this as an elite fighting style where the drow are trained to keep their weapons poisoned as part of the fighting style by whatever theatrical method you choose. Perhaps the elite drow keep the outer layers of their greaves soaked in this poison, and after each ...


9

A creature needs only the feat Simple Weapon Proficiency and a blowgun to make all of its iterative ranged attacks The blowgun is the only simple ranged weapon capable of making iterative attacks without devoting additional resources to doing so. Unlike a crossbow or sling, no extra time's needed to load a blowgun. Unlike a thrown weapon, the feat Quick ...


9

The books do not appear to specify exactly what effects count as 'poison' for the purposes of Dwarven Resilience. However, the Monk has a similar feature: Purity of Body At 10th level, your mastery of the ki flowing through you makes you immune to disease and poison. And Crawford has stated in a Sage Advice column that this makes the Monk immune ...


9

No, if these attacks were meant to inflict the poisoned condition they would specify. For example, the Sprite has an attack that does this: Shortbow. Ranged Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, range 40/160 ft., one target. Hit: 1 piercing damage, and the target must succeed on a DC 10 Constitution saving throw or become poisoned for 1 minute. If its ...


9

It's actually very difficult to drink real acid, unlike poison or household detergents. At 8:52 this person accidentally drinks the glass with sulfuric acid and immediately spits it out. He ends up with 2nd degree burns in his mouth, but is alive. "I take a single gulp." does not mean that he swallows it while his mouth is already burning, especially not as ...


8

Although the word "remain" is confusing here, I would tend to answer that yes, you have to make both saves (unless the poison description states otherwise). In the case of drow knockout poison, the results could be expressed as this: Fail/Fail: It knocked you out cold, right from the get-go. Fail/Pass: It got the drop on you, but you shook it off and got ...


8

You would regain consciousness after 1 minute and remain conscious until after the delay poison wears off. This is because "remain unconscious for 2d4 hours" is the secondary damage of the drow poison. You don't receive the secondary damage while under the effect of the slow poison, therefore you will not remain unconscious. If they don't regain ...


8

Scores a hit RAW Attack Roll An attack roll represents your attempt to strike your opponent on your turn in a round. When you make an attack roll, you roll a d20 and add your attack bonus. (Other modifiers may also apply to this roll.) If your result equals or beats the target's Armor Class, you hit and deal damage. It doesn't matter if ...


8

Damage Reduction is covered in the special ability section, under Damage Reduction. Whenever damage reduction completely negates the damage from an attack, it also negates most special effects that accompany the attack, such as injury poison, a monk's stunning, and injury-based disease. Emphasis mine. Temporary hit points are not covered specifically ...


8

To add some homebrew poison support, here are a few: A nasty Poisoner PrC. 3.5 implementation of real-world poisons. Rules for creating custom poisons. And to toot my own horn: I have performed an overhaul of the 3.5 poison system myself. It's not so much an addition to as it is a replacement of the old mechanics, but it does make them significantly more ...


8

P.258 of the DMG describes Drow Poison as one of their poison examples. So "why don't Drow in 5e, from the lowest pleb to the highest priestess, use poison?" They do, as mentioned in the Monster Manual, and in Out of the Abyss: (possible PC spoilers)


8

The DM should supply a brief narrative to encourage the player to have his character attack the nearest creature appropriately The effects of confusion without narrative support can lead to all sorts of negative metagaming, especially when a character's forced to attack an ally, like the character taking unreasonable and deliberate penalties ("I'm right ...


8

The basic poison found in the PHB can be bought, created, and used like any other mundane item. The Adventurer's League Player's Guide allows you to use almost all PHB rules. D&D Player’s Handbook™ (all rules except rolling ability scores and hit points, some alignment restrictions) The Adventurer's League FAQ specifies that you can only use DMG ...



Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible