680 reputation
515
bio website
location
age
visits member for 3 years, 7 months
seen Oct 5 '13 at 15:55

Jul
22
comment Fighter (Essentials) Weapon Talent
Thanks @ObliviousSage. I like the background you gave and, even though you gave no mechanical reasoning based on the Rule as Written (RAW), it does shed some logical light on the situation and why they are not compatible.
Jul
21
comment Fighter (Essentials) Weapon Talent
What supports your idea other than character builder, which is flawed?
Jul
20
comment Fighter (Essentials) Weapon Talent
The weapon talent feature of Fighter (knight) and Fighter (slayers) as it relates to styles of combat.
Oct
8
comment Can a prone immobilized creature stand up?
@Mark Rogers: the answer is still here in the event someone else thinks the same way, and through reading they can get a clear understanding of where the rules clear it up.
Dec
17
comment Can a prone immobilized creature stand up?
Rules compendium, pg232 supports standing up with the immobilized condition.
Dec
17
comment Can a prone immobilized creature stand up?
I retract my answer because the Rules Compendium, pg232 clearly says that an immobilized creature can stand up.
Dec
12
comment Can a character with the Alchemist feat make Assassin poisons?
I agreed until I read the DMG. RAI, the Poison Use is suppose to be a Daily but RAW poisons are alchemic items and the DMG has Carron Crawlers Brain Juice as a normal lv. 5 poison.
Dec
9
comment Does “Pact Initiate” grant the pact boon, too?
As I read the Eldritch Pact hybrid (PHB3) it clearly states: "This class feature functions as the warlock class feature, except you don't gain the at-will or the Pact Boon granted by it." It clearly says that you don't gain the pact boon there but not in the Pact Initiate.
Dec
8
comment Where are the rules for a knight?
Also, Eladrins have a variant Knight in dragon magazines (can't remember which one at the moment).
Dec
7
comment What should be the first 5 feats a Barbarian picks?
Just thought I'd mention that Lances give +1[W] while mounted and charging, and counts as a spear.
Dec
7
comment What should be the first 5 feats a Barbarian picks?
Hey, no fair. I met the parameters. Str and Con all went into the feat listing. Focused on Striking and survivability. I only made a suggestion at the end to give the guy some more options just in case. Just because it's doesn't look like a traditional build doesn't mean i went off topic.
Dec
7
comment Can a prone immobilized creature stand up?
I think your confused here. If 'immobilize' specifically says "you cannot move unless teleported, push, pulled or slid (forced movements)" then why are you 'AS A NON-RULE MAKER' saying that includes standing up? I think they would've included that in some errata. Also, in the rules compendium, standing up IS a move action.
Dec
7
comment Do monster templates still exist in post-Essentials D&D 4e?
Monster Templates can be found in the DMG, Monster Manuals or Open Grave. These templates are recommened for monster but you can apply them to Player Characters with caution. Also, even intelligent artifacts/items surve as templates.
May
8
comment Does cover also grant concealment?
As I read this 'Rules of the Hidden Club'... you still have to MOVE. 'Move 0' refers to falling prone then standing up, which are move actions where you do not move outside of the square. You can NEVER substitute a move action to make a stealth normally. '...any move action, or any action that lets you move.'
May
4
comment Does cover also grant concealment?
You make a stealth as 'part of a move action'. You have to move unless something grants you a stealth check. Please show me, anywhere in the history of D&D, where you can make a stealth check without moving (without a feat, item, etc)
Apr
4
comment Final Fantasy Style/Tales of Symphonia Style Summoner in 4e
I'd suggest an Artificer. I'm too lazy to give a fully explanation of how they fit into your Final Fantasy dream.
Mar
23
comment Out-Of-Control Characters
Well both. How do you suggest handling problem players and problem characters. Let say that a PC is trying to control your campaign in-character and he built his character very powerfully (ie: insane diplomatic).