Reputation
485
Top tag
Next privilege 500 Rep.
Access review queues
Badges
1 4 12
Newest
 Good Answer
Impact
~29k people reached

Feb
2
comment How would a Flesh to Stone'd Hydra with Shape Stone cast on it regrow limbs once Stone to Flesh is cast on it?
@Urbatin Find detail isn't possible with Stone Shape. You can make things like crude doors or coffers. You can't make a flower bed, and certainly not a still growing flower bed.
Jan
22
comment How would a Flesh to Stone'd Hydra with Shape Stone cast on it regrow limbs once Stone to Flesh is cast on it?
@GMJoe It's not just you! There are a plethora of different spells that could result in a similar outcome. The problem is I don't know which spell he intends to use. I wanted to answer the question he asked, and show him how it is possible to come to that conclusion, but without knowing exactly what he intends to I had to make some assumptions.
Dec
12
comment What do I get the druid that has everything?
An amulet with a +2 bonus to wisdom that gives advice on occasion would be great for a new player.
Nov
22
comment Divided party on a deserted island
I don't think you even need to telegraph over-much. Like, what do you expect when you've been shipwrecked on a jungle island and leave the group?
Oct
31
comment How does a DM handle time limits in-game?
Put a giant clock in the arena and make it "ding" every fifteen minutes and "dong" the number of hours.
Oct
31
comment How can I strategise IC with the other players when my PC is stupid?
This is basically what I have in a comment I just made, with the exception that your bad ideas can have deep insight to guide the player in the right direction.
Oct
31
comment Using Intimidate and/or Diplomacy to kill enemies
@NeilSlater I think that's fair. Personally, my call as a DM would be to allow players to possibly acquire allies through the Diplomacy skill, although that ability is not explicitly stated. It just makes sense within the context of what diplomacy actually is. However, were they then to attempt to get an NPC to do something potentially harmful, and the NPC was to question it, it would be all about bluff. If they lied, anyway. If they tried to explain why it would be best if the NPC took the hit for the group, it would be Diplomacy against a high DC.
Oct
31
comment Using Intimidate and/or Diplomacy to kill enemies
What if your argument is that they would be better suited standing in a different part of the room?
Oct
31
comment Using Intimidate and/or Diplomacy to kill enemies
The less the NPC would want to take the action, the higher the DC would be on an intimidate or diplomacy check, it seems to me.
Oct
1
comment No Meat-Shield Dilemma
A player in a group of mine once crit on multiple seduction roles to advance through a hostile area.
Jul
1
comment Why is a brutal 3 vorpal scythe called “Death's Scythe”?
I understand the cultural references to Death as wielding a scythe in the guise of the grim reaper, I just want to know why this specific weapon design, is referred to as Death's Scythe.
Jul
1
comment In D&D 4E, Changelings can keep other forms when sleeping?
I convinced a dm to allow me to play as a changling once... he swore he would never do it again.