11,481 reputation
23290
bio website
location
age
visits member for 4 years, 2 months
seen May 20 at 16:23

May
25
accepted Do monsters higher or lower level than the PCs play well in combat?
May
24
asked Do monsters higher or lower level than the PCs play well in combat?
May
24
comment Impact of removing Dragonborn from Khorvaire
For an answer to your second question, this question might be helpful: What changed in Eberron between 3.5e and 4e?
May
24
revised What are the “fiends” referenced in Eberron?
Expanded answer with regard to Eberron
May
24
answered Old School Holy Avenger in 4e?
May
24
comment Old School Holy Avenger in 4e?
If I understand the question correctly, the key difference is that he's looking for 100% magic resistance as well. Unfortunately, that kind of power doesn't mesh with 4e. Attack powers are no longer classified into magical and non-magical, as they were in 3e, and complete immunity to a certain damage type is considered far too powerful for even a high-level 4e item. The closest equivalent ability in a 4e weapon is resist 30 to one element (e.g. Chill Wind weapon, or Icingdeath).
May
24
answered What are the “fiends” referenced in Eberron?
May
20
asked How do masterwork armours work (e.g. Feyleather, Starleather)?
May
18
comment Can you use Shrink Item on a living creature?
I like your line of thinking.
May
16
accepted How does Swords & Wizardry differ from Labyrinth Lord?
May
14
comment Why do characters with a high prime requisite gain bonus XP?
@Badmike Thanks! I'd be really interested to hear what you find out.
May
14
awarded  Nice Question
May
13
asked Why do characters with a high prime requisite gain bonus XP?
May
13
asked How does Swords & Wizardry differ from Labyrinth Lord?
May
8
answered Who actually makes the Magic Books that boost stats?
Mar
29
awarded  Nice Answer
Mar
12
revised Does precision damage effect incorporeal creatures?
Added ghost touch, clarified answer
Mar
11
answered Does precision damage effect incorporeal creatures?
Mar
6
comment Why does the “insubstantial” quality exist?
D&D 4e also tends to protect PCs from wasting their best powers to a frustrating random miss. Daily powers deal half damage on a Miss, or are Reliable. Monsters no longer have abilities like 50% miss chance or spell resistance. It's reasonable that Insubstantial exists because it's an improvement over 3e's Incorporeal, rather than filling some new design role.
Mar
6
comment Why does the “insubstantial” quality exist?
It's a hunch, but a reasonable one. The same creatures that had Incorporeal in 3e have Insubtantial in 4e, and it has a similar effect (50% miss chance vs 50% damage reduction) and meaning (the creature is partially not-there and partially ignores your attacks).