Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by user27327
Bounty Ended with Dale M's answer chosen by CommunityBot
Notice added Draw attention by user27327
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by CommunityBot
Tweeted twitter.com/StackRPG/status/865415806137413633
deleted 4 characters in body
Source Link
user27327
user27327

After answering this question about how deep can PCs go underwater, I started wondering how long can you keep swimming before you die. Here are the constraints:

  • You can breathe underwater (ex, via magic items or spells)

  • Your speed is 30 ft and you have no swim speed

  • You are diving straight down, and the water is deep enough to accommodate your travel

  • You are not benefiting from Adv/D.Adv beyond what Exhaustion grants you

  • You die only when you reach an Exhaustion level of 6

  • The RAW is strictly followed, note we are not trying to be simulationist

Asking for a 100% chance of death is typically not useful, and in this case it is intuitively not (a +30 minimum for Con save guarantees survival, but that isn't interesting because nobody can normally achieve that).

So, to be useful, how long can a creature swim according to the constraints above before they have a probability of death equal to 95% or greater?

After answering this question about how deep can PCs go underwater, I started wondering how long can you keep swimming before you die. Here are the constraints:

  • You can breathe underwater (ex, via magic items or spells)

  • Your speed is 30 ft and you have no swim speed

  • You are diving straight down, and the water is deep enough to accommodate your travel

  • You are not benefiting from Adv/D.Adv beyond what Exhaustion grants you

  • You die only when you reach an Exhaustion level of 6

  • The RAW is strictly followed, we are not trying to be simulationist

Asking for a 100% chance of death is typically not useful, and in this case it is intuitively not (a +30 minimum for Con save guarantees survival, but that isn't interesting because nobody can normally achieve that).

So, to be useful, how long can a creature swim according to the constraints above before they have a probability of death equal to 95% or greater?

After answering this question about how deep can PCs go underwater, I started wondering how long can you keep swimming before you die. Here are the constraints:

  • You can breathe underwater (ex, via magic items or spells)

  • Your speed is 30 ft and you have no swim speed

  • You are diving straight down, and the water is deep enough to accommodate your travel

  • You are not benefiting from Adv/D.Adv beyond what Exhaustion grants you

  • You die only when you reach an Exhaustion level of 6

  • The RAW is followed, note we are not trying to be simulationist

Asking for a 100% chance of death is typically not useful, and in this case it is intuitively not (a +30 minimum for Con save guarantees survival, but that isn't interesting because nobody can normally achieve that).

So, to be useful, how long can a creature swim according to the constraints above before they have a probability of death equal to 95% or greater?

Mod Moved Comments To Chat
added 74 characters in body
Source Link
user27327
user27327

After answering this question about how deep can PCs go underwater, I started wondering how long can you keep swimming before you die. Here are the constraints:

  • You can breathe underwater (ex, via magic items or spells)

  • Your speed is 30 ft and you have no swim speed

  • You are diving straight down, and the water is deep enough to accommodate your travel

  • You are not benefiting from Adv/D.Adv beyond what Exhaustion grants you

  • You die only when you reach an Exhaustion level of 6

  • The RAW is strictly followed, we are not trying to be simulationist

Asking for a 100% chance of death is typically not useful, and in this case it is intuitively not (a +30 minimum for Con save guarantees survival, but that isn't interesting because nobody can normally achieve that).

So, to be useful, how long can a creature swim according to the constraints above before they have a probability of death equal to 95% or greater?

After answering this question about how deep can PCs go underwater, I started wondering how long can you keep swimming before you die. Here are the constraints:

  • You can breathe underwater (ex, via magic items or spells)

  • Your speed is 30 ft and you have no swim speed

  • You are diving straight down, and the water is deep enough to accommodate your travel

  • You are not benefiting from Adv/D.Adv beyond what Exhaustion grants you

  • You die only when you reach an Exhaustion level of 6

Asking for a 100% chance of death is typically not useful, and in this case it is intuitively not (a +30 minimum for Con save guarantees survival, but that isn't interesting because nobody can normally achieve that).

So, to be useful, how long can a creature swim according to the constraints above before they have a probability of death equal to 95% or greater?

After answering this question about how deep can PCs go underwater, I started wondering how long can you keep swimming before you die. Here are the constraints:

  • You can breathe underwater (ex, via magic items or spells)

  • Your speed is 30 ft and you have no swim speed

  • You are diving straight down, and the water is deep enough to accommodate your travel

  • You are not benefiting from Adv/D.Adv beyond what Exhaustion grants you

  • You die only when you reach an Exhaustion level of 6

  • The RAW is strictly followed, we are not trying to be simulationist

Asking for a 100% chance of death is typically not useful, and in this case it is intuitively not (a +30 minimum for Con save guarantees survival, but that isn't interesting because nobody can normally achieve that).

So, to be useful, how long can a creature swim according to the constraints above before they have a probability of death equal to 95% or greater?

edited title
Link
user27327
user27327

How long can creatures with no swim speed swimtravel in deep water before they die?

added 193 characters in body
Source Link
user27327
user27327
Loading
added 33 characters in body
Source Link
user27327
user27327
Loading
Source Link
user27327
user27327
Loading