Skip to main content
Commonmark migration
Source Link

#Yes, I would argue you are immune.

Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working.

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

#Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working.

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working.

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

fixed header formatting (for accessibility)
Source Link
V2Blast
  • 50.3k
  • 10
  • 223
  • 306

Yes, I would argue you are immune. #Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working.

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working.

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

#Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working.

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

as comment noted, you don't actually have to pick a subtype
Source Link
Zhuge
  • 3.5k
  • 2
  • 21
  • 32

Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working (presuming, of course, you picked the proper subtype for your casting of Protection from Evil and Good).

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working (presuming, of course, you picked the proper subtype for your casting of Protection from Evil and Good).

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

Yes, I would argue you are immune.

While this is not explicitly called out by the description of the staff, I think the text of the staff's effect and the spell lean heavily toward your strategy working.

As you have pointed out, the spirit in the staff is explicitly attempting to possess the user, and Protect from Evil and Good explicitly protects against possession. This seems quite reasonable even though the staff did not call out this spell specifically in its description.

As additional support, the staff's description says that Dispel Evil and Good can be used on the affected creature to exorcise the spirit and force it back into the staff. The effects of Dispel Evil and Good and Protection from Evil and Good have significant similarities, with Dispel being a higher level with some additional affects, and both share the line about ending possession. Therefore I would expect that if Dispel is meant to be able to use its effect to dispel the spirit, Protection should be able to use the similarly-worded effect to protect from it.

These two points together make me think that Protection from Evil and Good should be sufficient protection from the spirit of the staff attempting to possess you.

Source Link
Zhuge
  • 3.5k
  • 2
  • 21
  • 32
Loading