Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/StackRPG/status/1498719728965230604
Became Hot Network Question
adjusted title to match question in body; clarified phrasing; fixed quote formatting to match source; edited tags
Source Link
V2Blast
  • 50.3k
  • 10
  • 223
  • 306

Can a Fire Elementals and setting ObjectsElemental only set objects on fire by attacking them?

I've found an odd discrepancy in the Fire Elemental's ability to set "stuff" on fire

I've found an odd discrepancy in the Fire Elemental's ability to set "stuff" on fire.

In the Fire Elemental description's statblock in the Monster ManualMonster Manual, itthe description of the Fire Form trait states (emphasis mine):

Fire Form.Fire Form. The elemental can move through a space as narrow as 1 inch wide without squeezing. A creature that touches the elemental or hits it with a melee attack while within 5 feet of it takes 5 (1d10) fire damage. In addition, the elemental can enter a hostile creature's space and stop there. The first time it enters a creature's space on a turn, that creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage and catches fire; until someone takes an action to douse the fire, the creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

This is all well and good, and means the Fire Elemental can wreak havoc on large swaths of enemy creatures as it moves through them.

  It would also appear that this would set both friend and foe on fire, since there's no distinction in the description of creatures.

However, there's no mention of objects until we get to the Fire Elemental attacksElemental's Touch attack (bold for emphasis mine):

Touch. Melee Weapon Attack:Touch. Melee Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, reach 5 ft., one target. Hit:Hit: 10 (2d6 + 3) fire damage. If the target is a creature or a flammable object, it ignites. Until a creature takes an action to douse the fire, the target takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

By RAW, it would appear that while Fire Elementals can ignite and damage lots of creatures by moving through them, and the ability to set objects on fire is limited to touchTouch attacks only. This seems odd, as its fire does affect both friend and foe.

Am I right in limitingthat its ability to set objects on fire to requiring a touch attack? Or is this a grey area where the failure to extend thislimited to objects is an oversight in the rulestargeted by its Touch attack? Or is this a grey area where the failure to extend this to objects is an oversight in the rules?

Additionally, if for some reason thisits Fire Form trait did affect objects, wouldn't that mean that it sets fire to every flammable object it moves through?

(Worth noting: This question has (sort of) been asked before, but for Pathfinder 1e, not D&D 5e.)

Fire Elementals and setting Objects on fire

I've found an odd discrepancy in the Fire Elemental's ability to set "stuff" on fire

In the Fire Elemental description in the Monster Manual, it states:

Fire Form. The elemental can move through a space as narrow as 1 inch wide without squeezing. A creature that touches the elemental or hits it with a melee attack while within 5 feet of it takes 5 (1d10) fire damage. In addition, the elemental can enter a hostile creature's space and stop there. The first time it enters a creature's space on a turn, that creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage and catches fire; until someone takes an action to douse the fire, the creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

This is all well and good and means the Fire Elemental can wreak havoc on large swaths of enemy creatures as it moves through them.

  It would also appear that this would set both friend and foe on fire, since there's no distinction in the description of creatures.

However, there's no mention of objects until we get to the Fire Elemental attacks:

Touch. Melee Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, reach 5 ft., one target. Hit: 10 (2d6 + 3) fire damage. If the target is a creature or a flammable object, it ignites. Until a creature takes an action to douse the fire, the target takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

By RAW, it would appear that while Fire Elementals can ignite and damage lots of creatures by moving through them, and the ability to set objects on fire is limited to touch attacks only. This seems odd as its fire does affect both friend and foe.

Am I right in limiting its ability to set objects on fire to requiring a touch attack? Or is this a grey area where the failure to extend this to objects is an oversight in the rules?

Additionally, if for some reason this did affect objects, wouldn't that mean it sets fire to every flammable object it moves through?

Worth noting: This question has (sort of) been asked before, but for Pathfinder not 5e.

Can a Fire Elemental only set objects on fire by attacking them?

I've found an odd discrepancy in the Fire Elemental's ability to set "stuff" on fire.

In the Fire Elemental's statblock in the Monster Manual, the description of the Fire Form trait states (emphasis mine):

Fire Form. The elemental can move through a space as narrow as 1 inch wide without squeezing. A creature that touches the elemental or hits it with a melee attack while within 5 feet of it takes 5 (1d10) fire damage. In addition, the elemental can enter a hostile creature's space and stop there. The first time it enters a creature's space on a turn, that creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage and catches fire; until someone takes an action to douse the fire, the creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

This is all well and good, and means the Fire Elemental can wreak havoc on large swaths of enemy creatures as it moves through them. It would also appear that this would set both friend and foe on fire, since there's no distinction in the description of creatures.

However, there's no mention of objects until we get to the Fire Elemental's Touch attack (bold for emphasis mine):

Touch. Melee Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, reach 5 ft., one target. Hit: 10 (2d6 + 3) fire damage. If the target is a creature or a flammable object, it ignites. Until a creature takes an action to douse the fire, the target takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

By RAW, it would appear that while Fire Elementals can ignite and damage lots of creatures by moving through them, the ability to set objects on fire is limited to Touch attacks only. This seems odd, as its fire does affect both friend and foe.

Am I right that its ability to set objects on fire is limited to objects targeted by its Touch attack? Or is this a grey area where the failure to extend this to objects is an oversight in the rules?

Additionally, if for some reason its Fire Form trait did affect objects, wouldn't that mean that it sets fire to every flammable object it moves through?

(Worth noting: This question has (sort of) been asked before, but for Pathfinder 1e, not D&D 5e.)

Removed thanks ; edited tags
Source Link
Thomas Markov
  • 154.5k
  • 30
  • 864
  • 1.2k

I've found an odd discrepancy in the Fire Elemental's ability to set "stuff" on fire

In the Fire Elemental description in the Monster Manual, it states:

Fire Form. The elemental can move through a space as narrow as 1 inch wide without squeezing. A creature that touches the elemental or hits it with a melee attack while within 5 feet of it takes 5 (1d10) fire damage. In addition, the elemental can enter a hostile creature's space and stop there. The first time it enters a creature's space on a turn, that creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage and catches fire; until someone takes an action to douse the fire, the creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

This is all well and good and means the Fire Elemental can wreak havoc on large swaths of enemy creatures as it moves through them.

It would also appear that this would set both friend and foe on fire, since there's no distinction in the description of creatures.

However, there's no mention of objects until we get to the Fire Elemental attacks:

Touch. Melee Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, reach 5 ft., one target. Hit: 10 (2d6 + 3) fire damage. If the target is a creature or a flammable object, it ignites. Until a creature takes an action to douse the fire, the target takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

By RAW, it would appear that while Fire Elementals can ignite and damage lots of creatures by moving through them, and the ability to set objects on fire is limited to touch attacks only. This seems odd as its fire does affect both friend and foe.

Am I right in limiting its ability to set objects on fire to requiring a touch attack? Or is this a grey area where the failure to extend this to objects is an oversight in the rules?

Additionally, if for some reason this did affect objects, wouldn't that mean it sets fire to every flammable object it moves through?

Thanks in advance!

Worth noting: This question has (sort of) been asked before, but for Pathfinder not 5e.

I've found an odd discrepancy in the Fire Elemental's ability to set "stuff" on fire

In the Fire Elemental description in the Monster Manual, it states:

Fire Form. The elemental can move through a space as narrow as 1 inch wide without squeezing. A creature that touches the elemental or hits it with a melee attack while within 5 feet of it takes 5 (1d10) fire damage. In addition, the elemental can enter a hostile creature's space and stop there. The first time it enters a creature's space on a turn, that creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage and catches fire; until someone takes an action to douse the fire, the creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

This is all well and good and means the Fire Elemental can wreak havoc on large swaths of enemy creatures as it moves through them.

It would also appear that this would set both friend and foe on fire, since there's no distinction in the description of creatures.

However, there's no mention of objects until we get to the Fire Elemental attacks:

Touch. Melee Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, reach 5 ft., one target. Hit: 10 (2d6 + 3) fire damage. If the target is a creature or a flammable object, it ignites. Until a creature takes an action to douse the fire, the target takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

By RAW, it would appear that while Fire Elementals can ignite and damage lots of creatures by moving through them, and the ability to set objects on fire is limited to touch attacks only. This seems odd as its fire does affect both friend and foe.

Am I right in limiting its ability to set objects on fire to requiring a touch attack? Or is this a grey area where the failure to extend this to objects is an oversight in the rules?

Additionally, if for some reason this did affect objects, wouldn't that mean it sets fire to every flammable object it moves through?

Thanks in advance!

Worth noting: This question has (sort of) been asked before, but for Pathfinder not 5e.

I've found an odd discrepancy in the Fire Elemental's ability to set "stuff" on fire

In the Fire Elemental description in the Monster Manual, it states:

Fire Form. The elemental can move through a space as narrow as 1 inch wide without squeezing. A creature that touches the elemental or hits it with a melee attack while within 5 feet of it takes 5 (1d10) fire damage. In addition, the elemental can enter a hostile creature's space and stop there. The first time it enters a creature's space on a turn, that creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage and catches fire; until someone takes an action to douse the fire, the creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

This is all well and good and means the Fire Elemental can wreak havoc on large swaths of enemy creatures as it moves through them.

It would also appear that this would set both friend and foe on fire, since there's no distinction in the description of creatures.

However, there's no mention of objects until we get to the Fire Elemental attacks:

Touch. Melee Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, reach 5 ft., one target. Hit: 10 (2d6 + 3) fire damage. If the target is a creature or a flammable object, it ignites. Until a creature takes an action to douse the fire, the target takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

By RAW, it would appear that while Fire Elementals can ignite and damage lots of creatures by moving through them, and the ability to set objects on fire is limited to touch attacks only. This seems odd as its fire does affect both friend and foe.

Am I right in limiting its ability to set objects on fire to requiring a touch attack? Or is this a grey area where the failure to extend this to objects is an oversight in the rules?

Additionally, if for some reason this did affect objects, wouldn't that mean it sets fire to every flammable object it moves through?

Worth noting: This question has (sort of) been asked before, but for Pathfinder not 5e.

Source Link
Σ of eDπ
  • 3.1k
  • 20
  • 47

Fire Elementals and setting Objects on fire

I've found an odd discrepancy in the Fire Elemental's ability to set "stuff" on fire

In the Fire Elemental description in the Monster Manual, it states:

Fire Form. The elemental can move through a space as narrow as 1 inch wide without squeezing. A creature that touches the elemental or hits it with a melee attack while within 5 feet of it takes 5 (1d10) fire damage. In addition, the elemental can enter a hostile creature's space and stop there. The first time it enters a creature's space on a turn, that creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage and catches fire; until someone takes an action to douse the fire, the creature takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

This is all well and good and means the Fire Elemental can wreak havoc on large swaths of enemy creatures as it moves through them.

It would also appear that this would set both friend and foe on fire, since there's no distinction in the description of creatures.

However, there's no mention of objects until we get to the Fire Elemental attacks:

Touch. Melee Weapon Attack: +6 to hit, reach 5 ft., one target. Hit: 10 (2d6 + 3) fire damage. If the target is a creature or a flammable object, it ignites. Until a creature takes an action to douse the fire, the target takes 5 (1d10) fire damage at the start of each of its turns.

By RAW, it would appear that while Fire Elementals can ignite and damage lots of creatures by moving through them, and the ability to set objects on fire is limited to touch attacks only. This seems odd as its fire does affect both friend and foe.

Am I right in limiting its ability to set objects on fire to requiring a touch attack? Or is this a grey area where the failure to extend this to objects is an oversight in the rules?

Additionally, if for some reason this did affect objects, wouldn't that mean it sets fire to every flammable object it moves through?

Thanks in advance!

Worth noting: This question has (sort of) been asked before, but for Pathfinder not 5e.