Skip to main content
deleted 385 characters in body; edited tags; edited title
Source Link
user8248
user8248

Binding agreements Is there a way to itemsindicate a binding agreement on an item?

Foreword

We're in RAW land here, please make sure your answers are consistent with the rules as they are written or edited by an errata. Also, if you want to tell me that D&D3.5E is the wrong system for doing what I want to do, please don't bother. I know that. Consider this an experiment with a storytelling medium.

The setting

SettingThe setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

###Question I'mI'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice: Any

Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgeable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

###My take on that CurrentlyCurrently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems. S.t., such that blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those. Would

It would be great if we were able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks s.t.such that officers are able to scan marked items easily. Given

Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criterias.

###So... The Questioncriteria. (No, really)

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgeable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world?

Binding agreements to items

Foreword

We're in RAW land here, please make sure your answers are consistent with the rules as they are written or edited by an errata. Also, if you want to tell me that D&D3.5E is the wrong system for doing what I want to do, please don't bother. I know that. Consider this an experiment with a storytelling medium.

The setting

Setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

###Question I'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice: Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgeable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

###My take on that Currently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems. S.t. blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those. Would be great if we were able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks s.t. officers are able to scan marked items easily. Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criterias.

###So... The Question. (No, really)

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgeable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world?

Is there a way to indicate a binding agreement on an item?

The setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

I'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice:

Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgeable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

Currently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems, such that blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those.

It would be great if we were able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks such that officers are able to scan marked items easily.

Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criteria.

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgeable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world?
grammar and missing word
Source Link
Nigralbus
  • 5.6k
  • 2
  • 30
  • 38

Foreword

We're in RAW land here, please make sure your answers are consistent with the rules as they are written or edited by an errata. Also, if you want to tell me that D&D3.5E is the wrong system for doing what I want to do, please don't bother. I know that. Consider this an experiment with a storytelling medium.

The setting

Setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

###Question I'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice: Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgableforgeable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

###My take on that Currently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems. S.t. blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those. Would be great if we would bewere able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks s.t. officers are able to scan marked items easily. Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criterias.

###So... The Question. (No, really)

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgableforgeable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world.?

Foreword

We're in RAW land here, please make sure your answers are consistent with the rules as they are written or edited by an errata. Also, if you want to tell me that D&D3.5E is the wrong system for doing what I want to do, please don't bother. I know that. Consider this an experiment with a storytelling medium.

The setting

Setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

###Question I'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice: Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

###My take on that Currently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems. S.t. blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those. Would be great if we would be able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks s.t. officers are able to scan marked items easily. Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criterias.

###So... The Question. (No, really)

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world.

Foreword

We're in RAW land here, please make sure your answers are consistent with the rules as they are written or edited by an errata. Also, if you want to tell me that D&D3.5E is the wrong system for doing what I want to do, please don't bother. I know that. Consider this an experiment with a storytelling medium.

The setting

Setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

###Question I'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice: Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgeable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

###My take on that Currently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems. S.t. blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those. Would be great if we were able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks s.t. officers are able to scan marked items easily. Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criterias.

###So... The Question. (No, really)

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgeable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world?

Foreword

We're in RAW land here, please make sure your answers are consistent with the rules as they are written or edittededited by an errata. Also, if you want to tell me that D&D3.5E is the wrong system for doing what I want to do, please don't bother. I know that. Consider this an experiment with a storytelling medium.

The setting

Setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

###Question I'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice: Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

###My take on that Currently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems. S.t. blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those. Would be great if we would be able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks s.t. officers are able to scan marked items easily. Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criterias.

###So... The Question. (No, really)

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world.

Foreword

We're in RAW land here, please make your answers are consistent with the rules as they are written or editted by an errata. Also, if you want to tell me that D&D3.5E is the wrong system for doing what I want to do, please don't bother. I know that. Consider this an experiment with a storytelling medium.

The setting

Setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

###Question I'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice: Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

###My take on that Currently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems. S.t. blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those. Would be great if we would be able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks s.t. officers are able to scan marked items easily. Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criterias.

###So... The Question. (No, really)

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world.

Foreword

We're in RAW land here, please make sure your answers are consistent with the rules as they are written or edited by an errata. Also, if you want to tell me that D&D3.5E is the wrong system for doing what I want to do, please don't bother. I know that. Consider this an experiment with a storytelling medium.

The setting

Setting at hand is more or less grim irony, reflecting the modern days. Ontological categories adopted by characters in the setting map to the modern ontologies. In the storyline there are references to Manhattan project, the Beatles, popular culture. Those are well-hidden though.

###Question I'm running a moderately epic city setting and I want the following to be a common practice: Any agreement regarding a rent of an item or a mount is [magically] bound to the item or mount itself so that the law enforcement officers can quickly validate the agreement using its [magical] nature with some kind of a reader. It may be dispellable (as it has two copies), it may be detectably-forgable (with a lot of effort from the forger), it should be government-issued.

###My take on that Currently I think that a good way to approach this problem would be to have an equivalent of public key cryptosystems. S.t. blanks for agreements are issued by governments and preemptively signed by them. Both parties use a signed blank as the deal is made, sign with their own signatures and exchange those. Would be great if we would be able to mark items with the ID numbers of the blanks s.t. officers are able to scan marked items easily. Given that the setting implies a certain degree of science, I would say that this can work but I'd love to have something simpler.

This approach can work, but needs some improvements to meet all the criterias.

###So... The Question. (No, really)

  1. Is there a simpler magical way to do what I want (dispellable, hardly forgable, government-issued, item-describing agreements) in the RAW world?
  2. Is there a cool RAW way to "write" readable yet invisible symbols on items, mounts et al and let those symbols be there until those are erased?
  3. If there is no known alternative to public key crypto to accomplish that in D&D3.5, what is the best way to describe public key crypto within RAW world.
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackRPG/status/424121557125197824
deleted 2 characters in body
Source Link
DMunchkin
  • 551
  • 1
  • 3
  • 12
Loading
added 163 characters in body
Source Link
DMunchkin
  • 551
  • 1
  • 3
  • 12
Loading
added 495 characters in body
Source Link
DMunchkin
  • 551
  • 1
  • 3
  • 12
Loading
Source Link
DMunchkin
  • 551
  • 1
  • 3
  • 12
Loading