2 added 817 characters in body
source | link

Just let it do fire damage.

As long as you don't allow him to use feats or items to take advantage of his pet doing fire damage, there isn't really any reason to not just make it do fire damage. Having it do fire damage is actually a nerf; while there are monsters with fire vulnerability versus none with vulnerable all, fire resistance is far more common than resist all.

Or let it use his weapon effects.

I'm on vacation right now so I don't have access to my books to check how animal companions normally gain an enhancement bonus or equivalent attack boost, but beastmaster is such a sub-optimal choice compared to the other ranger options that I really don't think there's any harm in allowing his pet to use his weapon's effects and activate its powers. There probably isn't any harm in letting it benefit from all of his equipment (minus enhancement bonuses to attack and defenses); a serious optimizer might find a way to abuse that, but he doesn't sound like the type. If you take this path then he shouldn't be able to equip items on the companion itself (it has a single special slot of its own I believe, though I can't remember any notably good options for said slot).

Just let it do fire damage.

As long as you don't allow him to use feats or items to take advantage of his pet doing fire damage, there isn't really any reason to not just make it do fire damage. Having it do fire damage is actually a nerf; while there are monsters with fire vulnerability versus none with vulnerable all, fire resistance is far more common than resist all.

Just let it do fire damage.

As long as you don't allow him to use feats or items to take advantage of his pet doing fire damage, there isn't really any reason to not just make it do fire damage. Having it do fire damage is actually a nerf; while there are monsters with fire vulnerability versus none with vulnerable all, fire resistance is far more common than resist all.

Or let it use his weapon effects.

I'm on vacation right now so I don't have access to my books to check how animal companions normally gain an enhancement bonus or equivalent attack boost, but beastmaster is such a sub-optimal choice compared to the other ranger options that I really don't think there's any harm in allowing his pet to use his weapon's effects and activate its powers. There probably isn't any harm in letting it benefit from all of his equipment (minus enhancement bonuses to attack and defenses); a serious optimizer might find a way to abuse that, but he doesn't sound like the type. If you take this path then he shouldn't be able to equip items on the companion itself (it has a single special slot of its own I believe, though I can't remember any notably good options for said slot).

1
source | link

Just let it do fire damage.

As long as you don't allow him to use feats or items to take advantage of his pet doing fire damage, there isn't really any reason to not just make it do fire damage. Having it do fire damage is actually a nerf; while there are monsters with fire vulnerability versus none with vulnerable all, fire resistance is far more common than resist all.