10
\$\begingroup\$

The Entertainer background (from the PHB, p. 130) has the following feature, and I'm not sure I'm understanding it correctly.

Feature: By Popular Demand

You can always find a place to perform, usually in an inn or tavern but possibly with a circus, at a theater, or even in a noble's court. At such a place, you receive free lodging and food of a modest or comfortable standard (depending on the quality of the establishment), as long as you perform each night. In addition, your performance makes you something of a local figure. When strangers recognize you in a town where you have performed, they typically take a liking to you.

It says "always find a place to perform", but it doesn't specify any surroundings, or duration of search. Is it just meant to be "when in a city, find some kind of venue within a few hours", or can the entertainer walk into (for example) a Dragon's lair or enemy warcamp and be expected to allowed to perform there?

Likewise; would the feature work in the middle of a forest, with no civilization around?

I'm assuming this is supposed to be a "downtime only" feature, used when you're already in a safe haven, but it doesn't mention anything about that. Only that you can "always find a place to perform".

\$\endgroup\$
18
\$\begingroup\$

The embedded assumption of that skill feature is that lodging (of some kind) is available.

That is made clear in the text of the description if one reads the whole description that you cited (PHB p. 130). Taking that one clause out of context -- "always find a place to perform" -- harms its contextual meaning. If you are in the middle of the forest, that ability will not create a tavern, an inn, nor a town in which to perform. (Granted, the birds and forest creatures may appreciate your song for its own sake). If you look at the last two sentences of the description,

In addition, your performance makes you something of a local figure. When strangers recognize you in a town where you have performed, they typically take a liking to you.

the initial condition (prerequisite?) is that there are other people around in a settlement of some size (town, village, city) to react to you favorably.

Are the woods really empty?

Per our discussion in comments, another way to look at this is to discuss with the player "who are you singing to here in the woods? Who is the audience?"

Is she singing to:

  1. Animals?

  2. Plants?

  3. Possible fey who are invisibly watching?

Any performer will usually perform for an audience. Rather than let this be an "on-off switch" there is a chance for some player input on how to make more use of this class feature in non-standard environments.

  • Example:

    The PCs are in the woods on a very cold night. They have seen some animal life around, but it's cold and getting colder. The Bard sings or plays music and a bear comes near, interested in the music. It then lies down near the Bard and leaves a space for the Bard to snuggle right up to nice warm bear fur.

    While that's a "cross-species" scenario, and you may want to call for a check to recall what kind of music calms beasts (Intelligence(Nature) check?); it's the kind of thing you and the Bard' player can work together on to get more out of the class feature.

It's not necessarily restricted to downtime activity

An adventure does not stop (although a given adventure day might end) simply by the need to take a long rest. Even with those nice lodgings that were earned by a performance, you can have encounters during the night such as:

  1. Thieves trying to steal the money you earned
  2. Groupies or fans trying to disturb your sleep (welcome or unwelcome)
  3. A local bard or musician visiting with a few thugs to run you off, or to scare you off, since you are seen as a threat to his income ...
  4. Your ex wife (or ex husband) is living in this town, unbeknownst to you, and drops by later to talk to you about your running off for this life of adventure ... so much for that good night's sleep, regardless of how nice the tavern is.

Not necessarily down time, although if you do take downtime in a town or city, you can avoid spending money on that style of living.

Regarding old bards, and old bold bards

If you try this in an enemy war camp, you are likely to have to first make another kind of ability check so that you are given a chance to perform for them. Once on stage, "I'm dyin' up here" might not be as benign as at a tavern!

If you try this on a dragon, the same applies. Dragons have high wisdom and intelligence scores, and decent charisma scores. Depending upon how well you first establish a rapport with a dragon, a performance might keep you from being the main course. That's too situation dependent to turn "on" or "off" with this class feature, but it could make for a great interaction with a dragon!

\$\endgroup\$
-8
\$\begingroup\$

This feature works mostly on populated areas like towns, cities, villages and the like.

Think as if you you're self is a regular at bar or local gathering spot. Being a regular gains you some privileges like priority seating, entrance, discounts or a "Tab" (IOU's).

But is related to a performers' well...performance (giggity) were you are welcomed to return to such locations so long as you performed well. You must have a least been to that area once and did well enough to be asked back, as literal meaning of "By Popular Demand" ..."they" want you back.

Other way of thinking is you have knack of knowing where in populated areas to perform where you believe you can make the most profit out of.

This can be used in game and great for role playing purposes or even in "down time". I'd prefer to do it in game as good time to make gather info checks whiles looking for a place to perform and or if your repeat performer and in high demand....there other benefits beside monitory gains...

\$\endgroup\$
  • 5
    \$\begingroup\$ Only the first sentence of this answer actually addresses the question that was asked. \$\endgroup\$ – Icyfire Aug 13 '17 at 16:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.