6
\$\begingroup\$

Battle Master maneuvers can give to-hit modifiers, attack advantages, damage bonuses and various effects to regular attacks.

My question is : can they do the same for Shoves (trips & pushes) and Grapples, which are classified as "special attacks" ?

Examples :

  1. Applying a Precision Attack maneuver to a Shove-Trip roll;
  2. Getting an advantage on a Grapple thanks to a Feinting Attack maneuver;
  3. Using the Disarming Attack maneuver during a Shove-Push;
  4. Adding the Menacing Attack maneuver effect to a Grapple;

etc.

Note 1 : although this question is related, it pertains to Pathfinder instead.

Note 2 : It is probably up to your DM whether a Shove can be made with a weapon, and although a Grapple must be made with a free hand, it is currently unconfirmed whether Battle Master maneuvers requiring a weapon can be applied to an unarmed attack.

\$\endgroup\$
14
\$\begingroup\$

No

Each of the maneuvers you have listed clearly state either

When you hit a creature with a [melee] weapon attack

or

When you make a weapon attack roll

Emphasis Mine.

Grapple, Shove, and Trip are all Athletics checks, not weapon attacks. Therefore, you are not making a weapon attack roll, or hitting with a weapon attack. You are performing an Athletics check to grapple, trip, or shove.

See the definitions of Grappling and Shoving a Creature on PHB 195, and Attack Rolls on PHB 194. A Grapple or Shove is a distinct type of attack from a Weapon Attack. The presence of 'weapon' in those maneuvers is there to indicate that the maneuvers only work when you make a Weapon Attack. Not when you make any attack.

This is the same rule that prevents things like grappling with Green Flame Blade, or Sneak Attacking with a Shove.

| improve this answer | |
\$\endgroup\$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.