18
\$\begingroup\$

The froghemoth from Volo's Guide to Monsters has a tentacle attack that can grapple a target from 20ft away. Grappling means that a targets speed is reduced to 0. Does that mean that characters cannot attack the froghemoth with melee attacks if they are 20ft away and grappled?

\$\endgroup\$
26
\$\begingroup\$

According to Jeremy Crawford, the character can attack the grappler

The intent is that monsters that are grappling a creature can be attacked through their limbs. Lead rules designer Jeremy Crawford ruled on twitter that "A creature grappled by a giant octopus can attack the octopus via the grappling tentacle." Giant octopi have 15 foot reach with their tentacles.

The rules don't assume you're playing with grid and don't give special treatment to specific body parts. The designers might've expected that it would be obvious that part of the creature is within your reach in this case, or that most DMs would allow it since it's a perfectly sensible thing to do. That said, the rules certainly don't give the impression that you can do this, and it would've been nice if it had been spelled out explicitly if this was the intent all along.

\$\endgroup\$
6
\$\begingroup\$

Players can attack the Grappling monster's tentacles

The Players can not attack creatures outside of their five foot attack range, ten depending on your weapon. However Jeremy Crawford has stated on twitter that you can attack a Giant Octopus by attacking the arm that is grappling you, which would give us an exception to the normal attack range as you attack its arm.

As NathanS has pointed out, you might want to take a look at the Roper MM (pg. 261) if you'd like to include something on having tentacles fall off after a certain amount of damage, or making them harder to hit than normal as in the case with the Roper.

This doesn't work for all monsters, attacking what they use to grapple you, as some creatures can grapple you from afar with things that aren't parts of their body, such as chains.

\$\endgroup\$
4
\$\begingroup\$

No, it only prevents melee attacks that don't have 20' reach.

The Froghemoth has a 20' Reach Melee Attack, which if successful, then (Volos, 145):

the target is grappled (escape DC 16) if it is a Huge or smaller creature.

Grappled reduces a creature's speed to zero, so they would not be able to move closer to the Froghemoth.

This would remove any potential melee attack unless the creature has a 20' reach.

They can still use any sort of ranged attack without any problem.

20' reach does not mean you can attack the Tentacle grappling you

Without any sort of given mechanic that allows you to attack the tentacle (like the Roper), adding that to the monster stat block would be a Home Rule. The RAW is that tentacle is not a viable target for the Froghemoth. Losing the reach advantage would potentially be a very big change and should change the CR rating of the Froghemoth. Comparing the two, a Roper is CR5, while the Froghemoth is CR10. It's a more powerful creature, let it be more powerful.

\$\endgroup\$
0
\$\begingroup\$

You can't attack the Froghemoth in melee while you're grappled and out of range. There are no general rules in 5e for attacking the limbs or weapons of a creature with reach when the creature itself is out of reach, so you can't e.g. attack its tentacles. Another creature with similar mechanics, the Roper, gives the tentacles their own AC and HP pool and permits players to attack it.

The Froghemoth was clearly never playtested, or if it was the experience gained was not folded into the published creature; any player grappled will ask that exact question. Either rules for attacking the tentacles should be present, or it should be explicit about not being allowed to be attacked.

Treat it as a low quality inspiration for a monster, and write a reasonable answer with good in-fiction justification, or don't use the monster.

\$\endgroup\$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.