First-time poster, I actually have a multipart question.
So, our DM got upset when my Paladin crit with my smite ability while having a hunter's mark on this Werewolf encounter. So in the end it was as so.
2d8 Slashing (Longsword) 2d6 Hunter's Mark 6d8 Radiant Damage (level 2 spell used up for smite) +4 Strength Modifier
So he argued that critical strikes won't work that way and since I struck with a melee weapon it is the melee attack that crits, not my smite. I did show him the comment from Crawford and argued the smite is not so much a spell as linked to my sword strike and arguably can at least be a hybrid attack and should choose which dice roll to double at least.
In the end, it is deemed that critical strikes do not double all damage dice because he feels it is too encounter breaking. So pretty much, even though a Paladin is still great with smites, it really takes away a holding smite factor for that one bomb strike.
End result: 2d8 melee 1d6 Hunters 3d8 Radiant +4
So far less spectacular for rolling that nat 20.
I believe he also has it in his mind since I am the party tank, I guess I should not be capable of such massive strikes. Despite the damage output of our resident rogue and Warlock.
So with that explanation out, here are my questions!
What abilities or spells can help maintain more consistent damage output with the lose of saving my smites for criticals now?
What are good class alternatives that can soak damage and return the damage to the table that would perform better than a nerfed Paladin?