4
\$\begingroup\$

I wish to play as a necromancer. However, despite the undead hordes protecting me, if someone were to snipe me I would be knocked out of the fight due to my low health as a squishy wizard. As a solution, I was thinking of getting myself an iron box with eye holes so I can command my undead horde from within the protection of the box.

Is this actually possible with RAW, or does the existence of the eye holes prevent it from becoming total cover?

\$\endgroup\$
10
\$\begingroup\$

What you are talking about is Improved Cover:

Improved Cover

In some cases, such as attacking a target hiding behind an arrowslit, cover may provide a greater bonus to AC and Reflex saves. In such situations, the normal cover bonuses to AC and Reflex saves can be doubled (to +8 and +4, respectively). A creature with this improved cover effectively gains improved evasion against any attack to which the Reflex save bonus applies. Furthermore, improved cover provides a +10 bonus on Stealth checks.

Total cover completely blocks any attacks coming your way. Having an "Eyeslit" gives them an opportunity to still hit you.

That said, creating a defense like this is a bit overkill

As a necromancer with your undead lackeys, they are meant to be acting as your "cover", either by creating a hindrance to direct line of sight with you, or by engaging the targets in combat so that firing out of combat puts them at a disadvantage (creating an attack of opportunity against them, I believe; I'm not sure of this).

Additionally, your spells are meant to further hinder the target, so that you are not the primary target - they will have too much else to deal with to be trying to attack you straight away.

If you are still concerned about your safety, talk to your GM. Discuss how you perceive the game to be, what you (and everyone else) want from the game, and figure out a way forward. Remember, you're not meant to be invincible, and everyone's lives are in the hands of the Dice Gods, but at the same time, the game should be fun for everyone.

\$\endgroup\$
4
\$\begingroup\$

Adventuring while wearing an iron box isn't all it's cracked up to be

Yes, a creature inside a typical iron box—even if the box has eye slits—has cover. Whether this is total cover or improved cover depends on how big a hole the box has for the eye slits. If there are really tiny eye slits, then it can be argued that the box provides the wearer with total cover, essentially offering its wearer the benefit of a tower shield on each of its 4 sides and its top. However, the necromancer within won't be able to make attacks or cast spells on anyone else or at anything or to anywhere outside the box until he exits the box. Total cover works both ways—if the enemies can't get you then you can't get them.

If the eye slits are more generous—like, says, the equivalent of being 1-ft. in diameter—, then the box grants the wearer only improved cover. On Aiming a Spell on Line of Effect, in part, says, "An otherwise solid barrier with a hole of at least 1 square foot through it does not block a spell's line of effect." This will allow the necromancer to still participate in encounters, verbally command his undead minions (which the GM may rule is impossible from the more severe box), and cast spells… but the necromancer himself can still be the target of attacks and spells, albeit gaining from the box a +8 cover bonus on AC, a +4 cover bonus on Reflex saving throws, and the benefits of the extraordinary ability improved evasion.

With either box, there is the matter of expense (there's no price for a Medium iron box, but this GM would likely have such an item cost the equivalent of 5 tower shields or 150 gp) and, more importantly, weight (again, 5 tower shields so about 225 lbs.). While the box's price is relatively trivial (except at level 1), the box's weight will slow any less-than-Strength 16 necromancer to near immobility while he's within.

There will be no hasty retreat if things go wrong while the necromancer's in that box.

Discuss this plan with the GM and the other players

Pathfinder is usually imagined as a role-playing game of heroic magical adventure. In this regard, your concern for your PC's well-being seems a slight overreaction. While it might be amusing at first, it may soon grate on the GM or the other players to have the party composed of the brave, bare-chested, axe-wielding human barbarian; the devout and sagacious yet still warlike dwarf cleric; the light-fingered, double-dagger-wielding drow rogue; and the necromancer-in-the-box.

That's not to say that adventuring while mostly in an iron box isn't a good idea in the abstract—especially considering the (frequently short and often horrible) life that's led by the typical Pathfinder adventurer—, but, on a metagame level, having a PC who so highly values his own life that he's unwilling to risk himself or his resources on behalf of his friends in combat (that is, while the PC benefits from total cover) will violate many folks' expectations, and, perhaps, even anger some of the other players. They could turn against you… or turn it up to 11: The game could become the story of four iron-box-wearing PCs who, upon encountering foes, turtle up and wait for the foes to get bored and leave. Needless to say, that's a little odd for a game of heroic magical adventure.1,2

Anyway, talk with the GM and the other players about their expectations for the campaign before committing your PC to this course.


1 I can't help but be reminded of this question.
2 This player has long imagined a group of PCs who all possess the ability to feign death and who, upon seeing foes, collectively fake heart attacks. The PCs would be by those foes looted but unharmed, they believing the PCs already deceased. The PCs would be treasure poor yet experience rich, having survived harrowing encounters with all sorts of monsters by, essentially, doing nothing. Unfortunately, this imaginary group suffers a TPK upon encountering a monster that sees dead adventurers not as postmortem treasure troves but as meals.

\$\endgroup\$
  • \$\begingroup\$ I'd also add that there are actually some very easy ways to get around the iron box to attack. The box will have a hardness and can be attacked or sundered. Numerous spells could be used to circumvent the box in interesting ways. More basically someone can just walk up and do a trip attempt to knock you over and attack your unguarded feet. (I'd probably give them a huge circumstance bonus to the trip attempt as well, a box like that has to be unwieldy. Frankly the protection is not worth the decrease in speed. There is a reasons real life archers didn't run around in boxes... \$\endgroup\$ – dsollen Mar 1 at 20:38
  • \$\begingroup\$ @dsollen Possibly were imagining a different kind of iron box. First, this would be a low-level strategy at best, so the iron box's hardness of 10 and, like, 30 hp will endure a decent amount of punishment. Also, if using the total cover box, it'd be impossible to attack the dude—he'd just scoot around at, like, 5 ft. per round. But, yeah, there are a host of problems with a portable pillbox. \$\endgroup\$ – Hey I Can Chan Mar 1 at 20:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.