7
\$\begingroup\$

Reading Mordenkainen's Tome of Foes, I realized that the thing that makes elves trance and remember all the stuff they have experienced in the past is the fact that they all are still connected to Corellon in some way. They have visions of Arvandor at a young age, and everything makes them believe that they will come back someday.

But what happens if an elf doesn't know about Corellon, or he has decided to worship something else? The only clue I've found is a little text about drow trance in Mordenkainen's Tome of Foes (p. 53):

Drow enter trance just as other elves do, but they do not experience memories of a primal soul or past lives. Often they recall nothing at all, but simply dwell for a time in darkness and silence, a respite from the dangers of their daily lives.

Obviously, drow have these "empty" trances because of their treason to Corellon and also because they worship Lolth, the main enemy of Corellon.

The confusing thing for me is that, if drow can not trance, why would an elf who has embraced a fiend or another deity be able to trance? Wouldn't it be considered an act of treason to Corellon as well?

If an elf is worshiping Lathander, or Helm, his relation with Corellon is compromised. Would they be able to trance normally?

My party has an elf warlock of the Fiend that fully believes that his fiend is the only and most powerful god in the multiverse.

Should he be able to trance? Isn't worshiping another thing other than Corellon enough reason to stop any kind of connection with him? If not, why would somebody that has been experiencing memories of Arvandor for at least 100 years worship a different god? Of course, you could worship multiple gods, but our warlock just worships one god, and that god is an evil fiend.

\$\endgroup\$
  • \$\begingroup\$ Welcome to RPG.SE! Take the tour if you haven't already. and check out the help center for more guidance. \$\endgroup\$ – V2Blast Mar 16 at 2:16
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Hi Varstark! It appears you've made two accounts. You can follow the instructions here to merge them and regain control of your question. Once you do so you'll be able to leave comments requesting clarification from answers. However please note comments aren't for extended discussion or for asking altogether new questions beyond the bounds of your original question: instead ask a new question so that you and the answerers to it can earn rep for it. \$\endgroup\$ – doppelgreener Mar 16 at 12:21
  • \$\begingroup\$ Are you the DM? \$\endgroup\$ – NautArch Mar 16 at 13:21
  • \$\begingroup\$ You say "The confusing thing for me is that, if drow can not trance" immediately after a quote that says they do trance, just differently. \$\endgroup\$ – T.J.L. Oct 11 at 12:51
11
\$\begingroup\$

Normal trances reflect elves' connection to their primal soul, their current mortal life, and their past lives

Your quote from Mordenkainen's Tome of Foes leaves a lot of relevant information out. "Chapter 2: Elves" goes into quite a bit of detail about elves' trances.

Under the heading "The Elven Diaspora" (p. 36), it notes:

No matter where they are in the multiverse, elves of all sorts feel a special connection to the realm of Faerie, for it was their race’s first home after they were cast adrift. Even if they can’t name that realm or don’t know how to return there, vestigial memories of the place sometimes glimmer in their minds when they trance.

And under "Living in Reverie" (p. 37-38):

Perhaps more so than any other race, elves are familiar with all aspects of memory. From birth, elves don’t sleep but instead enter a trance when they need to rest. In this state, elves remain aware of their surroundings while immersing themselves in memories. What an elf remembers during this reverie depends largely on how long the elf has lived, and the events of the lives that the elf’s soul has experienced before.

It explains that during an elf's first few years, "the memories evoked during trance are drawn not from current life experiences, but from the fantastic past adventures of the elf’s immortal soul." It's not until adolescence (in the elf's second or third decade) that they first experience a memory of waking life during their trance.

They are considered adults towards the end of their first century of life, when they experience "the Drawing of the Veil": they no longer experience their primal memories, and only recall the events of their current life. As adults, they learn how to control the memories they experience during a trance, often choosing to recall useful or comforting ones as needed.

Finally, they experience another change and become "elder elves" in their third or fourth century:

At some point during adulthood, the reverie of an elf’s trance is first interrupted by a new form of unbidden thought. This seemingly errant memory arises not from the elf’s personal experience, nor from the memories of the elf’s primal soul, but comes from another life and another time.

As these intrusive thoughts become more frequent, they focus less on the world and their focus turns inward.

Regardless of how soon or how often elves experience such memories, most consider them a blessing from the gods. The experiences of other lives that are revisited during trance can be examined for lessons to be applied during one’s waking life, signs from the gods, or ways to open an elf’s perspective to other points of view.

A handful of elves in any generation never experience an other-life memory during trance. It’s hypothesized that these select few might be reincarnations of the original primal elves who sprang from Corellon’s blood and were allowed to stay in his company. Although most elder elves become more serene, these rare folk spend the rest of their lives throwing themselves into dangerous situations, as if daring death to try to take them.

The "Dreams from Beyond Memory" sidebar notes that all elves can sleep and dream as normal if they choose, but most surface elves avoid it; actual dreams, as in humans, are uncontrolled products of the subconscious, and most elves find them bizarre.

Towards the end of its life, an elf gets

cataracts in the shape of crescents, points down, that appear over the pupils of both eyes when the elf is in trance. This change, commonly known as Transcendence, is evidence that Sehanine Moonbow has opened the door to enable the elf’s soul to return to Arvandor — a direct sign from the gods that it’s time to get one’s affairs in order.

Drow can trance, though it's different in nature

As I mentioned, you've left out quite a significant portion of the "Drow Trance: Entering the Void" sidebar (p. 53, emphasis mine):

Drow enter trance just as other elves do, but they do not experience memories of a primal soul or of past lives. Often they recall nothing at all, but simply dwell for a time in darkness and silence, a respite from the dangers of their daily lives. When drow do dream, whether in trance or in sleep, they look for signs from Lolth or others of the Dark Seldarine. That drow do not experience trance the way other elves do lends credence to the idea that their souls do not reincarnate. Did Corellon forever bar the souls of dark elves from Arvandor and change them in some fundamental way? Or does Lolth somehow weave new souls for her followers, in the way that Moradin forges new spirits for dwarves? Only those entities know for certain.

The nature of a drow's trance seems to have nothing with who they worship or how they feel about Corellon personally. Rather, it seems to be tied to something innate, specifically relating to their souls.

Therefore, non-drow elven warlocks can trance just as any other elf does

An elf's class has nothing to do with their ability to trance, or what they see during it. Nor does their religion, or what god or being they follow. Rather, the nature of an elf's trance seems to be tied to their soul and their ancestry; put simply, whether or not they're drow.

The primal elves that became mortal and followed Lolth in her betrayal against Corellon were exiled to the Underdark, and eventually became drow. In this way, the nature of their trance seemingly has nothing to do with their current actions as mortals, and everything to do with their primal souls' past action of following Lolth. The only thing that might potentially contradict this is in the section on Arvandor (p. 48, emphasis mine):

Elves who live on Arvandor are no different from elves living anywhere else, except for the intensity of their passion. All manner of elves can be found there, including eladrin and even a few extraordinary drow. The splendor of the Seldarine illuminates their days, and their trances are filled with the intoxicating, blissful feeling engendered by their nearness to Corellon’s magnificence.

The section does not clarify how this interacts with the typical nature of a drow's trance.

Beyond this, the DM can always rule that a non-drow's trance is different in some way, depending on who they worship. Perhaps (for instance) an elf warlock who makes a contract with some evil being such as a demon or devil in exchange for their soul has a different sort of trance - like a drow's, or perhaps something entirely different. There are no rules for this sort of thing.

\$\endgroup\$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.