Recently, in a mixed WoD 20th Anniversary game, we came upon an unexpected problem.
Phoebe's Veil - a level 3 Fetish, Gnosis 7
While the Veil says, "Neither mundane creatures nor spirits nor technology may sense her in any way except touch." the argument was made that Vampires are not mundane - and thus Auspex should pierce it.
On the Flip side of the coin, it is the bound spirits who are concealing the werewolf — in this case, a multiple spirits: a Lune, a chameleon and a shadow. Since Vampires cannot see nor interact with spirits via Auspex at all, it should not.
I have searched a bit on the net and tried to find some kinda of errata for the fetish or something that might give the players a understandable and logical conclusion. (I never like saying, "It works or does not because I said so." I try and give reasoning.) Obviously, saying having Auspex 7 (its Gnosis rating) to see though is kinda out of the question, but also having a 3 (level of fetish) does seem to "limit" its power and usefulness. Ideas?