15
\$\begingroup\$

I've run one-shots, I've heard the stories, and now I'm about to start a real long-running Paranoia campaign. And there's one thing I'm not sure of:

Is the expectation that every major adventure begins with a whole set of new clones?

Also...

Is there anything that players can carry from adventure to adventure?

The Player's Handbook claims that security clearances can be upgraded by spending XP Points... is this false hope? Do players roll up whatever security clearance they need for the specific adventure?

I'd expected that players would try to keep their clones alive through as many adventures as possible; this was implied by the Mission Book that comes in the Red Clearance boxed set. There are three missions, and the characters survive through the three. OK.

However, in the Mission Book 2.0 that comes with Acute Paranoia's boxed set, there are three larger adventures; and each one ends poorly for the Troubleshooter team. For example, the end of one mission has...

...the Troubleshooters being executed and any remaining clones being sent to an IntSec re-education camp.

That's a pretty terminal ending. The other two aren't as brutally terminal, but they DO end with the party pretty much screwed.

The adventure in the Mission Book seems to expect a story arc for clones. The arc of missions end...

...with the clones either killed for treason OR being allowed to kill a Blue-clearance terrorist, implying a future for the clones.

So, assuming the clones are supposed to have an arc, do you just gen up new clones when the last clone of a party member dies? This implies new clones.

Assuming the clones are supposed to die, what's the point of Achievements that trigger at the end of the plot?

Is there some sort of Last-Will-And-Testament system that can be used to pass on XP Points and/or loot and/or information between adventures? Or is the expectation that it all gets vented to the Underplex?

\$\endgroup\$
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Welcome to RPG.SE! (...Though your account is over 2 years old, this seems to be your first question.) Take the tour if you haven't already, and check out the help center for more guidance. \$\endgroup\$ – V2Blast Apr 6 at 4:51
  • 4
    \$\begingroup\$ @okeefe Yes. I've heard it called Paranoia 2017 and Paranoia Rebooted. You'd think by now companies would learn to stop making sequels/reboots and that just naming them after the first release is a horrible idea. I've recommended Mongoose go to their nearest IntSec re-education centre and given them five treason stars for doing so. \$\endgroup\$ – Zoey Boles Apr 8 at 19:33
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ @ZoeyBoles It's endless confusion with the Paranoia editions, but then it is Paranoia, what more can we expect? \$\endgroup\$ – lightcat Apr 10 at 5:07
  • 3
    \$\begingroup\$ @lightcat the actual name of the system is just above all of our clearance levels. \$\endgroup\$ – Rubiksmoose Apr 11 at 20:42
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ @lightcat To be fair, The Computer in Rebooted has been perfected. It was completely perfect in XP, 2nd edition and Classic, but it's more more perfect now. If, in it's infinite wisdom, it decided the game should be named Paranoia, who am I to argue with Famous Game Designers? \$\endgroup\$ – Zoey Boles Apr 11 at 20:56
8
+150
\$\begingroup\$

Note: In this answer, I will be quoting from PARANOIA 2nd Edition and PARANOIA XP. I think the advice here may still be applicable to the new edition, especially because very little in PARANOIA depends on the rules of the game. I am an experienced GM, having ran PARANOIA XP missions since the 2000s.


First, let's deal with the published missions.

I suspect that most PARANOIA missions are written with the assumption of being one-shots, hence the terminal endings to serve as a nice, memorable bookend for characters.

But that does not mean that you must always run one-shots. You just have to modify the missions and change the endings to be less lethal and to imply that players are impacting the larger plot in some shape or fashion.

Modifying the published missions was actually encouraged in both 1st Edition and 2nd Edition. For example, 2nd Edition wrote:

You can always take a published adventure, use its basic structure or premise, then twist it in whatever direction you like. There are no Game Design Police who will come to your home to make sure you run an adventure the way it was published. In fact, for Paranoia, this is our recommended method - use the published adventure for structure and inspiration, then create and improvise to your heart's content.

I have done that before for a few missions, where I liked most of the content, but not all of it (like, say, the hosejob endings). It's rather empowering, really.


However, even when you modify a mission to be less lethal, players may still die. What then? Here's a quote from a passage from the PARANOIA XP rulebook about running PARANOIA campaigns:

[W]hat about the fatality rate? Easy: Treat the players themselves as the continuing characters. A player has one Troubleshooter now; he’ll have another next time; so what? Let all his characters know what he knows. Let the player carry his knowledge of deathtraps and proper conduct forward from one Troubleshooter to the next. Is that any more implausible than the whole identical-clone-backups device?

In PARANOIA, unlike a lot of other (non-fun) RPGs, many players regard their characters not as roles to play but as mere puppets or placeholders. This is fine—in fact, it may be the best way to play. The Computer requires all Alpha Complex citizens to think and behave pretty much alike. So regardless of his PC’s specific background, a player has ample rationale to just play the character as if he himself, the player, were there in the briefing rooms and corridors, doing what he himself would do. This works out well, as long as the player feels the fear and insanity of the setting.

Then, too, there are ways to keep even individual Troubleshooters alive. Under the Straight rules for treason accusation and clone backups, experienced and careful players can keep their characters around long enough to reach decently high clearances. At that level the nature of the game shifts to a less immediately deadly form.

This is a question about PARANOIA Rebooted, not about PARANOIA XP, so here's the basic gist of those rules so you can convert them to PARANOIA Rebooted if you think you need to do so:

  • The "Straight rules for treason accusations" boil down to requiring more evidence before convicting somebody and reducing the punishment for treason down to more reasonable levels (so, maybe 1-2 treason stars for a minor offense)...
  • The "Straight rules for clone backups" boil down to allowing players purchase new clone backups. Though players may get themselves in debt (and may dig themselves even deeper into debt if they want to 'clean' their genetic template), at least they get to live longer past the 6-clone limit. Note that if players go too deep into debt, The Computer may erase their clone template as punishment.

Basically, just dial down the lethal nature of the game and allow players to purchase new clones in case they get close to running out.


Is there some sort of Last-Will-And-Testament system that can be used to pass on XP Points and/or loot and/or information between adventures?

As mentioned in the PARANOIA XP's quote, it's perfectly fine to pass on information to your next character. However, I would tell the player that such information would be considered "rumors"...and rumors are treasonous (so don't get caught knowing it).

So, the question turns to passing on XP Points and loot...

In PARANOIA XP, you had Perversity Points (a meta-currency that players earn for being entertaining and can spend to boost character success). Perversity Points belong to the player (not the character), so if a character loses all their clones, no sweat, the player still keep their Perversity Points and can use them when running their new character.

Paranoia Rebooted doesn't have Perversity Points anymore, and it may be weird to treat XP as a kind-of-Perversity since they have in-game fluff and technically belong to the character. But...

Since the GM can still award players XP for being entertaining (through the Achievements system), I'd say you can just have players inherit the XP of their previous character. You can probably rationalize it by saying to the unlucky player as he writes up a new character sheet:

"Yes, The Computer tried to vent the excess XP Points to the Underplex. Emphasis on tried. Your secret society have secretly recovered the XP Points, and gave them to your new character as a reward for their previous treasonous activities. Don't mention this to anybody though, or The Computer will ask some interesting questions."

Alternatively, you could just boost the security clearance of the new character, as okeefe suggested in his answer to running a PARANOIA campaign using PARANOIA Rebooted rules.

Doing so means you don't need to trot out a transparently bogus rationalization to justify why the player still retains their XP Points, while still boosting the player well-enough to compensate for his loss of XP Points (especially since the only way to get a security clearance promotion is by...spending XP Points).

Last, items. I wouldn't allow items to be carried over (but I don't really have a good reason why - I suppose I think carrying over information and meta-currency tends to be good enough for a new character, and it makes more sense for items to be unrecoverable). If you want items to be carried over though, use the same excuse I did for justifying how a new character recovered XP Points.


Additional Reading: okeefe's answer to "How can I run an ongoing Paranoia campaign?" (answer also addresses how to run campaigns using PARANOIA Rebooted)

\$\endgroup\$
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Wowsers! This is fantastic! I'm going to chew on this a couple of times. This was exactly the sourcing I was looking for. The rules of Rebooted are, as stated in the game master guide, a guideline... But they should be consistent. Hence why I wanted to see how the two decades plus of the universe has solved this problem. \$\endgroup\$ – Zoey Boles Apr 9 at 6:47
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ I'm going to accept this answer, it's incredibly detailed. I also picked up the Paranoia Service Pack 1 manual and it's GM section is way more fleshed out than the Rebooted manuals. I'll probably grab the second edition manual as well, just to collect wisdom. Thanks for your work on this answer! \$\endgroup\$ – Zoey Boles Apr 11 at 16:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.