Our DM is allowing me to make an aboleth my familiar. We had met this aboleth earlier in our game and changed its alignment from lawful evil to chaotic good. My question is if I make it my familiar, how do I make the aboleth breathe out of water? My DM has assured me there is a way, but I've yet to discover it.

The other option my DM presented was to use "polymorph other" on the aboleth and transform it into a phoenix. My DM told me that would turn it into a psionic phoenix, which I could make my familiar.

Also, on another note, I also have to make the aboleth fly if it is to be on land. What would be the best way to accomplish this?

  • 5
    \$\begingroup\$ Polymorph other is a D&D 3.0 spell, and was replaced in the 3.5e revision. Are you sure you are playing the 3.5e revision? It’s certainly far more common than 3.0, and I certainly recommend it, but if you are actually playing 3.0e then something from 3.5e may not be helpful. (On the other hand, your DM may have just misspoke, forgetting that they changed it or whatever.) \$\endgroup\$ – KRyan Jul 27 '19 at 0:35

Air breathing is a 3rd-level transmutation for clerics, druids, sorcerers, and wizards that lasts 2 hours per level (e.g 10 hours at the minimum caster level 5th) and allows a creature that normally breathes water to instead breathe air (it is exactly the opposite of water breathing). It’s printed in several books: Champions of Ruin, Savage Species, Stormwrack, and Spell Compendium. A continuous item of air breathing would, per the guidelines (which are only guidelines, check with your DM), cost 30,000 gp. I would value it less than that.

Stormwrack and Savage Species also have fins to feet, a 2nd-level transmutation for druids, sorcerers, wizards, and weirdly enough, spellthieves, that takes a creature with a swim speed and gives it a land speed instead. For a Large or larger creature (like an aboleth), that would be a speed of 40 feet. Unfortunately, it also costs the aboleth its tentacle attacks, and it only lasts 1 hour per level. As a continuous item, per guidelines, it costs 12,000 gp. It isn’t really worth that much, so your DM may be willing to price it below that guideline.

Anyway, beyond walking, there are a large variety of ways to gain a flight speed; the cheapest, at 10,000 gp, is a feathered wings graft (Fiend Folio), but unfortunately now that your aboleth is no longer evil, those will drive it mad. Check Ernir’s Lists of Necessary Magic Items for other approaches to flight, though. A flying carpet might be the best thing, at 20,000 gp.

None of these deal with an arguably-bigger problem for this aboleth: drying out. Aboleths need to remain immersed in water in order to survive; per Lords of Madness page 17, if one is out of water for more than a few (“excruciatingly painful”) hours, they will enter “the long dreaming,” in which they cannot act, and which aboleths consider “a fate worse than death.” Some few aboleths, known as amphibious aboleths, can tolerate living in swamps and the like; see Lords of Madness page 20. Conjuring water, putting a gigantic tank of water on that flying carpet, and so on, could be solutions, but they’re all going to be awkward at best.

Beyond that, there is the polymorph option your DM suggested.

Lords of Madness describes an uobilyth, an “‘aerial aboleth’ as they are known to the few who have encountered them.” These “do not have the aquatic subtype or a swim speed. They gain the air subtype and a fly speed of 60 feet (good).”

Where uobilyths come from, how they form, and so on, is unmentioned. It may actually just be evolution; the preceding section on amphibious aboleths is a result of evolution.1 But anyway, they exist, and they’re very similar to aboleths. That means that polymorph any object, an 8th-level transmutation for sorcerers and wizards, can turn an aboleth into an uobilyth and it’s going to be permanent—it could still be dispelled, but otherwise, the now-uobilyth can fly and breathe air (obligate water-breathing is a function of that aquatic subtype that uobilyths don’t get). Hiring someone to cast polymorph any object for you once costs a mere 1,200 gp, but finding someone capable of doing it may be difficult. A scroll of it costs a minimum of 3,000 gp, and may be somewhat more manageable to find (according to the random 8th-level scrolls table, 3% of 8th-level scrolls are polymorph any object). Since it is vastly cheaper than the other options, having a back-up in case it gets dispelled is likely a good idea. Note that if you cannot yet cast 8th-level spells yourself, it is a DC 16 caster level check to successfully cast it (and if you fail, it is a DC 5 Wisdom check to avoid a mishap).

Polymorph any object could also, as your DM suggested, turn an aboleth into a phoenix. That would probably also be permanent, assuming that it doesn’t get extra Intelligence for being a phoenix (unlikely, aboleths are super-Intelligent to begin with). The uobilyth is probably stronger and doubtlessly, at least in my opinion, cooler.

Finally, just... a word of caution. An aboleth is a preposterously overpowered as a familiar. Aboleths are some of the most fearsome and dangerous creatures in the books; there’s a reason why in, Lords of Madness, a book devoted to aberrations, their chapter came first. Playing as an aboleth is dubious in the extreme. Having one as an extra add-on class feature just, I don’t even know, I’m speechless. I get that your DM allowed it. I strongly suggest considering just... not doing that. There’s a really high risk of it damaging the game, overpowering you, trivializing encounters and outshining the rest of the party. I would never, ever allow that in my games.

  1. Actually, it sounds rather Lamarckian, since it sounds like an individual aboleth can gradually become accustomed to a wet-but-not-immersed life.
  • \$\begingroup\$ According to Dragon #293 — predating the 3.5 revision — a typical aboleth has a derived level adjustment of +9 (55). So an aboleth cohort isn't impossible as the game's ending. Similarly, a level 16 caster can take the feat Improved Familiar and pick as a familiar a CR 8 hellwasp swarm. So while this DM would rule that an aboleth is just too big to be a familiar, I can see some accommodations being made for an archmage. However, at levels lower than this, I totally agree that an aboleth anything — cohort, familiar, ally, drinking buddy, bowling team member, whatever — is pretty nuts. \$\endgroup\$ – Hey I Can Chan Jul 27 '19 at 1:31
  • 3
    \$\begingroup\$ @HeyICanChan Aboleths are, probably more than any other monster in the game, more than their combat ability, though. Sure, it’s a “mere” CR 7, but any given aboleth should be a master schemer with plots going back literal millennia, not to mention personal memories of the entirety of history back to the multiverse’s creation. Giving players casual access to that is nuts. There’s a reason why aboleths are dismissive of the gods—as far as they’re concerned, the gods themselves are young upstarts. \$\endgroup\$ – KRyan Jul 27 '19 at 1:36
  • \$\begingroup\$ O, I know that from a role-playing perspective, aboleth lore paints them as incredibly powerful. (The homebrew setting in a campaign I'm running puts them in the background as nearly extinct and almost mythical beings because I couldn't imagine them not conquering the setting if used as LoM describes and existing casually!) I'm just saying that among more casual players who are unaware of the aboleth's baggage beyond the Monster Manual the aboleth's math works out as them being okay as a cohort or even (gulp) a familiar… for sufficiently high-level characters, obviously. \$\endgroup\$ – Hey I Can Chan Jul 27 '19 at 1:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.