12
\$\begingroup\$

I've been playing Tomb of Annihilation lately and asked my DM for his thoughts on using Unearthed Arcana material. He said he was cool with it which got me thinking. I've been interested in trying out the Revived Rogue subclass, but then I realized ToA has the Death Curse as the big driving plot point.

Any humanoid on the planet that has been brought back from the dead begins to waste away. Its hit point maximum is reduced by 20 (1 for each day the Soulmonger has been active) and decreases by 1 every midnight until the Soulmonger is destroyed. If a humanoid’s hit point maximum drops to 0, it dies. Traveling to another world or plane does nothing to halt the wasting effect once it has begun.

I mentioned this in the chat but not everyone seemed convinced that the Revived Rogue would be considered revived for the sake of the death curse reducing its HP max. One person even said that the rogue could have just been brought back to life before the Soulmonger was activated which it would have had to have been regardless as nobody can be resurrected anyway once it activates and Syndra even mentions that she died before saying

“I was an adventurer years ago. I died once and was raised from the dead. I have since closed the door on that stage of my life.”

The subclass specifically mentions in its description

You’ve had a soul-shaking realization: you’ve been dead before, yet somehow you are alive again.

and

You might have convinced a deity to let you return to the Material Plane, perhaps you signed a deal with a fiend, or maybe you used an artifact that revived you.

So I ask here; Is the Revived Rogue subclass considered to have been raised from the dead for the sake of the Death Curse in Tomb of Annihilation?

Note: I am primarily looking for a RAW answer but you are welcome to include how you would rule as well.

\$\endgroup\$
15
\$\begingroup\$

Your hp maximum is probably reduced

Any humanoid on the planet that has been brought back from the dead...

and

...you’ve been dead before, yet somehow you are alive again.

Are pretty clear. You definitely lose hp if you fulfill line one. The only reason I say probably in the header instead of definitely is because you aren't necessarily humanoid or 'on the planet'; centaurs, for example, are fey, and polymorph et al can also let you dodge the Soulmonger's midnight trigger.

\$\endgroup\$
4
\$\begingroup\$

There's Ambiguity Here

Enough that you could make an argument to a DM, at any rate.

This life isn’t your first; it might not even be your second. Your past life, or lives, are unclear to you, but you know that you passed through the gates of death.

You know what else has passed through the gates of death? Angels, demons, devils... extraplanar entities of all kinds (not all of them, but many) were once alive, but were remade into something else after they died.

You haven't been revived. Heck, you might not have even been reincarnated. Your soul has been recycled, yes, but what you've been made into is undeniably something other- both mentally and physically, as we'll see- than what you were before, which puts you closer to an angel or devil (or even undead) in construction than the person you once were.

You don’t need to eat, drink, or breathe.

You don’t need to sleep.

These don't sound like you've been "revived" at all.

You have learned to unleash bolts of necrotic energy from within your revived body.

But this sure does.

[W]henever you have 0 hit points and are healed or stabilized, you can change any of your personal characteristics: personality trait, ideal, bond, or flaw.

You certainly haven't been revived by the traditional sense of the word. More like... recycled.

you are one of death’s representatives among the living.

\$\endgroup\$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.