Consider the following scenario:

Two groups are making discussion, and it seems hostilities are about to erupt.

One side's Assassin rogue readies an action to throw a dagger as soon as that happens.

Does the assassin score an automatic crit for hitting a surprised enemy?

(I realize the readied attack is a questionable call, but let's keep the answers focused on the Surprise)


Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.