Which spells can stop a magic-user from using a summoning spell either by stopping the spell effect or by stopping the magic user from casting?
Are there any others?
Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. It only takes a minute to sign up.Sign up to join this community
Adapted from this answer.
Make the enemy unable to cast spells
Animal Shapes (PHB, pg. 212) Requires willing target.
Antimagic Field (PHB, pg. 213) 10 foot sphere around your self, requires position management.
Feeblemind (PHB, pg. 239) Int save, resave after 30 days.
Mass Polymorph (XGtE, pg. 160) Wisdom save.
Polymorph (PHB, pg. 266) Wisdom save.
True Polymorph (PHB, pg. 283) Wisdom save.
Confusion (PHB, pg. 224) Wisdoms save, 20% chance to act normally even on a failed save.
Dominate Beast (PHB, pg. 234) Wisdom save. Requires beast creature type. The only beast with spellcasting I'm aware of is Traxigor, an archmage that was polymorphed into an otter from the adventure Descent into Avernus. Traxigor does not have any summoning spells on his statblock, but the DM may choose to put some there. This will also work on an 18th level NPC druid while in Wildshape form.
Dominate Monster (PHB, pg. 235) Wisdom save.
Dominate Person (PHB, pg. 235) Wisdom save, only works on humanoids.
Slow (PHB, pg. 277) Wisdom save, possibility for a single turn delay.
Sleep (PHB, pg. 276)
Imprisonment - Slumber (PHB, pg. 275) Wisdom save.
Hold Person (PHB, pg. 251) Wisdom save, requires humanoid.
Hold Monster (PHB, pg. 251) Wisdom save.
Power Word Stun (PHB, pg. 267) Target must have 150 or fewer hitpoints.
Psychic Scream (XGtE, pg. 163) Intelligence save.
Divine Word (PHB, pg. 234) Charisma save. 40 or fewer hit points, target is blinded. 30 or fewer, target is also stunned. 20 or fewer, target is dead.
Reality Break (EGtW, pg. 189) Wisdom save. 20% chance to stun, 20% chance to blind, 60% chance to take a lot of damage but still be able to act.
Contagion (PHB, pg. 227) Requires three failed Constitution saves. Inflicts a disease of your choice, three of which are applicable here.
Symbol (PHB, pg. 280) Lots of applicable options here.
Hypnotic Pattern (PHB, pg. 252) Wisdom save.
Tasha's Hideous Laughter (PHB, pg. 280) Wisdom save.
Modify Memory (PHB, pg. 261) Wisdom save.
Many of the conjure something spells require you to target an unoccupied space you can see, so inflicting the blindness condition with Blindness/Deafness (PHB, pg. 219) or Sunbeam (PHB, pg. 279) would do the trick if the summoning spell required sight. Additionally, Darkness (PHB, pg. 230), Fog cloud (PHB, pg. 243), and Cloudkill (PHB, pg. 222) would prevent the caster from seeing any unoccupied spaces within range.
All of the summoning spells have verbal components, so the Silence (PHB. pg. 275) will prevent them from being cast.
Leomund's Tiny Hut (PHB, pg. 255) If the caster is inside the hut, they cannot target a point outside the hut, and creatures summoned inside the hut cannot leave. Casting time of 1 minute and the hut is quite small.
Stopping their spell
Preventing Planar Travel
Mordenkainen's Private Sanctum (PHB, pg. 262) Casting time 10 minutes.
Forbiddance (PHB, pg. 243) Casting time 10 minutes
Sending the caster to another plane
Imprisonment - Hedged Prison (PHB, pg. 252)
Maze (PHB, pg. 258) Just works.
Banishing Smite (PHB, pg. 216) Damage must reduce target to 50 of fewr hit points.
Banishment (PHB, pg. 217) Charisma save.
Plane Shift (PHB, pg. 266) Must hit on a melee spell attack, and target must fail a Charisma save.
And finally, you can cast wish to cast any spell in this answer, or appeal to the DM with something like “I wish you wouldn’t do that.”
1 to equip them with armor they are not proficient in, if you accept "Would forcing armour on a wizard using an illusion spell and Illusory Reality 'harm' them?"
All of the spells in Thomas' list apply.
In addition, it would seem that any spell that kills the magic-user, or at least incapacitates them by putting them to 0 hit points, would achieve the goal of "stopping the magic user from casting". Dead magic-users don't cast spells.
Which spell this could be would depend on how many hit points the magic-user has. As find familiar, a lowly first level spell, qualifies as summoning, and wizard-magic users start out with only 6 hit points, even spells that deal modest damage technically qualify. And of course the magic-user might already be hurt and only have a single hit point left, at which point any spell capable of dealing damage would apply.
That list of spells is really to long to usefully enumerate here. Some high level, high impact options likely to work well on the dinky hit point totals of magic-users are
Given you are defending an area, and with enough time to pre-cast, Hallow is pretty good. It's not a perfect answer, but it has a lot recommending it. As a default effect,
First, celestials, elementals, fey, fiends, and undead can't enter the area
'Can't enter the area' presumably means both being summoned within it and appearing outside and physically entering. The list of creature types blocked will stop most summoning spells, and is effective at shutting down: Conjure Celestial, Conjure Elemental, Conjure Fey, Conjure Minor Elementals, Conjure Woodland Beings, Summon Celestial, Summon Elemental, Summon Fey, Summon Fiend, Summon Undead, Summon Greater Demon, and Summon Lesser Demons.
Unfortunately, the list is not comprehensive and Hallow will not be a hard stop to Conjure Animals, Summon Aberration, Summon Beast, Summon Construct, Summon Draconic Spirit, or Summon Shadowspawn.
However, you have not exhausted your Hallow yet.
Second, you can bind an extra effect to the area.
Select 'all creatures' to be the targets, and the 'extra effect' to be:
Extradimensional Interference. Affected creatures can't move or travel using teleportation or by extradimensional or interplanar means.
This is not a hard block, but it will force all of the creatures not stopped initially to make a Charisma save when they first attempt to enter the area, which may eliminate most of them if the summoner does not recognize that the area is warded by a hallow spell and tries to summon them within it (as opposed to summoning them outside and then just walking them in, which this will not prevent). Your spell DC against a Charisma save will eliminate most Animals, Aberrations, Beasts, and Constructs, further winnowing the field. Unfortunately you are still going to be be moderately vulnerable to Draconic Spirits and Shadow Spawn.
Assuming a DM allows a caster to summon while inside the hut, creatures summoned to the inside cannot leave, and the caster cannot summon creatures to appear outside. Creatures summoned outside cannot enter.
Conjuration / Summoning spells in general demand concentration, so any way you have of breaking the caster's concentration will end the effect of the spells.
Damage is the simplest route. Spirit Guardians and then rushing the caster is great - it is a sustained area of effect, no hit roll required, and damage even if they make the save. (Spirit Guardians followed by Sanctuary is even better, to protect you from whatever they have summoned so you can keep your own concertation on the Guardians up).
Spells that repeatedly damage them, forcing multiple concentration saves each round are also good, such as scorching ray, which can deliver multiple independent sources of damage on each cast.