I've been playing D&D over the last 20 years through 3 editions. I've recently picked up Savage Worlds Deluxe and really like what I see. I'm looking for some information on which setting/fantasy supplements might be the best for me - I'm less concerned with the setting details and more concerned with mechanics since I'll likely use the campaign world I've been using for the last 20 years.

Things that are important to me:

  • Magic items are special - they're not part of the math of the game and at any given time a character isn't assumed to have obtained a magic item in order to be powerful enough to overcome a challenge.

  • "Traditional" fantasy elements - They don't have to be exact, but I'd like to see the capability to create similar characters, NPCs, and monsters as what fits as "traditional" to me (i.e. D&D). Ability to reproduce the theme of D&D classes and races.

  • Casters are powerful but magic is risky - the Backlash feature of the magic Arcane Background does a really good job of handling the risky part (at least it seems so on paper!). I'd be happy for more power/spell options, but would like to see more alternative caster types.

  • Combat is important but not the sole focus. Not every encounter the player's come across has an assumption of player victory.

I understand there's an out of print Fantasy Companion book (go go PDF?) that might fit my needs, but I've also seen a number of people say that some of the settings have more superior options that make the Fantasy Companion redundant.


  • \$\begingroup\$ If your setting involves a lot of travel (specially boat travel) you might want to look into Sundered Skies. Some nice gaming aids for these. \$\endgroup\$ Commented Oct 29, 2012 at 2:20

1 Answer 1


The setting that springs to mind is Hellfrost. It is based in the realm of Rassilon, a fully detailed world with an extensive Gazetter and Bestiary in addition to the Player Guide. The world is varied and interesting, with plot hooks liberally sprinkled through the published literature, and although it adheres to many of the common fantasy tropes, there are sufficient twists to keep things interesting. This is partly because of how heavily it draws on Saxon and Scandinavian history and mythology. Also, the setting can cater for many different styles of campaign from dungeon delves through political intrigue in the Magocracy and heroic quests to relieve seiges on dwarven strongholds.

Addressing your criteria specifically...

Magic items are special

There are three types of magical items, and these do not form part of the maths of the game as they do in some other systems:

Hedge Magic - effectively a form of herbalism, items created can range from powders through oils, infusions, vapours etc. Their effects are typically quite weak, including antitoxin, purgative and soporific, and these items are the cheapest and most readily available in the setting. Importantly, they are not necessarily obviously magical.

Alchemical Devices - these are magical one shots created by magicians. They are relatively expensive and any sentient being who touches them realises their magical power. These are relatively rare, and can typically only be found in the largest of towns.

With both of the above types, players are able to learn how to create them themselves.

Legendary Relics - these are extremely rare, permanent magical items, and are equivalent to the sword +1 types that you might get in D&D. You never find them for sale, and there are whole organisations devoted to rooting them out and securing them to prevent their use by the general populance. As with alchemical devices, touching one immediately reveals its power, but it takes a little extra effort to actually be able to use the power it has. The art of creating them has been lost of many years, so all that are left are those created by the masters of old.

"Traditional" fantasy elements

  • Races - There are orcs, goblins, dragons, dwarves and elves, albeit with some of these having a twist.
  • Heroic game - The setting is written with the expectation that PCs are going to be heroic characters, and there are specific rewards to encourage this behaviour.
  • Classes - Although not a class based system, Hellfrost and Savage Worlds allows you to create the same archtypes as other fantasy settings (rogue, archer, fighter etc). However, the flexibility of the system is what I love about it, and should you choose to use it I would encourage you to try and think outside of the narrow classes you are forced to use in other settings.

Casters are powerful but magic is risky

Broadly speaking, magic is dangerous, and the setting is seen as 'low-magic'. Most types of caster are subject to a form of back-lash known as 'siphoning' which at its worst, can see you lose your powers for days, gain wounds or suffer a permanent drop in your spell casting ability.

There are different types of 'magical' characters as follows, and their powers are a subset of the total available in the setting. Within each power you have to choose a 'trapping', e.g. sound, lightening, that affects what your spells look like when cast and possibly add a mechanical effect as well: Hedge magicians - these are your herbalists, and there is little/no risk in what they do, offset by the fact that their powers are the weakest.

Druids - Limited to specific races, they gain bonuses/penalities to their rolls depending on their surroundings.

Elementalism - Focused on one of fire, water, earth, air with powers that mirror the chosen specialisation.

Hrimwisards - Draw power from the cold in their surroundings. These are seen as social pariahs in many parts of the realm due to the encroaching cold weather gripping the land.

Heahwisards - Noble wizards from a particular part of the realm. Their power focuses through their staves, and the longer they have to prepare their casting, the more powerful their spells can be.

Rune magicians - Limited to dwarves who learn runes, each of which is a collection of three different spells. Their ability to learn new spells is more restricted than the other types.

Priests/Paladins - The setting has a fully fleshed out pantheon of gods, and clerics have to choose their patron deity. This gives them access to specific powers, but they also have to adhere to the tenets of their god, including avoiding specific minor, major and mortal sins and observing feast days. This is largely done through roleplay, and the penalties for sinning can be extreme, including losing your powers permanently until some major restorative quest is undertaken.

Combat is important but not the sole focus.

Combat in Savage Worlds generally is dangerous, and this forces players to think very carefully before engaging in any fight, even with puny goblins. Encounters in Hellfrost are expected to be less 'balanced', which can work both ways. The party might stumble on a small group of emaciated goblins licking their wounds from a fight the previous day. Alternatively, they could happen apon a powerful Hellfrost Dragon they have little hope of beating, and have to run for their lives.

Combat itself is usually over quickly, and there is less prep work required for the GM when compared to many other systems. The combat also scales well, allowing truely epic fights with tens of NPCs on either side.

In addition, there are rules for social combat, dramatic tasks, chases, dramatic interludes, managing a resource such as a temple, trade caravan or mercenary group. It took me a little while to get used to it, but now I would estimate that only 1 in 3 or 4 of my 'encounters' are combat related.

  • \$\begingroup\$ Wow! This is an excellent answer. Thank you! I'll have to check Hellfrost out - sounds awesome. \$\endgroup\$
    – Steve G
    Commented Oct 20, 2012 at 15:26
  • \$\begingroup\$ +1 Phil I cannot agree more with Phil's detailed and thorough response. I agree, Hellfrost is a great setting. I will add that the setting has a healthy amount of setting level intrigue--especially with respect to the Siphoning of magic, the Hellfrost itself and the relationship of the gods to each other and mortals as well. Great stuff! \$\endgroup\$
    – Galieo
    Commented Oct 22, 2012 at 15:12

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .