1
\$\begingroup\$

The published Dungeons &Dragons 5th Edition adventure DDEX3-07 Herald of the Moon awards a magic item called Shadowsong.

In the original adventure, Shadowsong is a very rare modified Oathbow (bold for emphasis mine):

Shadowsong (Oathbow)

Weapon (longbow), very rare (requires attunement by a ranger)

Each of the elven oathbows are possessed of mythical power and ancient legends. Shadowsong is hewn from a supple length of yew and features curious green metal tendrils snaking through its length. It glows dimly in the presence of humans. The description of this item can be found in the Dungeon Master's Guide.

In Adventurers League play, after the Content Catalog v9 update (p. 28), this bow was changed to a +2 weapon (bold for emphasis mine):

DDEX03-07 Herald of the Moon

This adventure features an item that is no longer acceptable under D&D Adventurers League guidelines, as it deviates from the attunement standards in the DMG. Instead of Shadowsong, this adventure instead unlocks a +2 weapon (longbow or shortbow). This +2 weapon has the sentinel property and glows dimly in the presence of humans.

A +2 weapon is rare, not very rare.

So, taking into account this change, what rarity is Shadowsong?

The content catalog doesn't mention the rarity.
Does this mean that it is unchanged, and still "very rare"?
Or should it be the rarity of a usual +2 weapon, and thus just "rare" instead?

\$\endgroup\$
1

1 Answer 1

7
\$\begingroup\$

The bow you receive is Rare

Because of the phrasing of the note in the Content Catalog (p. 28), players don't receive a bow called "Shadowsong" at all:

Instead of Shadowsong, this adventure instead unlocks a +2 weapon (longbow or shortbow). This +2 weapon has the sentinel property and glows dimly in the presence of humans.

They instead receive a +2 weapon which has an additional minor property. This +2 weapon doesn't have a name, which seems a bit odd since it has an additional property.

A +2 weapon is rare, and adding a minor property doesn't change that.

So, players don't receive the very rare bow Shadowsong, they receive a rare +2 weapon with an additional minor property.

\$\endgroup\$

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .