I am searching for the best combination of spells (Druid and Wizard only, no Enchantment or Evocation) with which to craft a magic item (Wondrous, manacles + leg irons) that could be used to permanently trap a creature in a pocket dimension without actually killing them. So far I figured that a combination of Rope Trick, Create Food and Water, and Arcane Lock would be close enough, but I am lacking an "element of imprisonment", which I was told only something like Secret Chest could give.

Given that Wondrous Items do not always use their spells exactly as described, but sometimes in alternative ways, what is the most optimal – in terms of cost and level availability – that I could craft an item of this nature?

  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Must the captured creature be conscious? Does the item need to create the extradimensional space, or will you take the captured creature to the extradimensional space after its capture? \$\endgroup\$ Jan 28, 2014 at 15:26
  • 3
    \$\begingroup\$ Given that custom magic items are almost entirely a matter of DM fiat, there is no such thing as an objective, system-based "optimal". To optimise something you need a known system, which is missing here. \$\endgroup\$ Jan 28, 2014 at 16:20
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ @AceCalhoon Eh, you could probably do this (ab)using the magical trap rules. The magical trap rules are really silly. \$\endgroup\$
    – KRyan
    Jan 29, 2014 at 0:15

3 Answers 3


The Easy Ways
These aren't exactly what you want because they're not magic items, but these spells can be put sometimes into wands, sometimes into staffs, or into wondrous items.

  • Cast the 3rd-level Sor/Wiz spell sepia snake sigil [conj] (PH 276) on a document that the creature to be imprisoned must read. A failed saving throw puts the creature in stasis for 1d4 +1 day/level. Cast the 2nd-level Sor/Wiz spell rope trick [trans] (PH 273). After finding a way to communicate with an Int 3 magical beast from the lower planes, cast the 1st-level Sor/Wiz spell summon monster I [conj] (PH 285-6), gaining the services of a fiendish monstrous scorpion (Small) (MM 287). Command the scorpion to take the creature affected by the sigil into the trick and retract the rope. Note: A wand of rope trick modified by the feat Extend Spell (PH 94) (2nd-level spell modified to a 3rd-level spell at caster level 20) costs 900 gp per charge and creates a 40-hour trick.
  • The 5th-level Sor/Wiz spell soul shackles [necro] (BoVD 104) traps a creature's soul in a tchotchke for questioning later. If the soul's hostile and succeeds on a saving throw when questioned, the soul's freed. The spell is technically broken (the Target is a living creature but the description says the spell's cast on a dead creature), so house rules are necessary to make the spell work. I'm thinking this might be the effect you're looking for without the hassle of making an item.
  • Cast on the creature to be imprisoned the 6th-level Sor/Wiz spell smoky confinement [trans] (CM 117). A failed saving throw instantaneously traps the creature in a "tiny receptacle" costing at least 100 gp.
  • Cast on the creature to be imprisoned the 7th-level Sor/Wiz spell plane shift [conj] (PH 262), with a failed saving throw sending the creature to a plane with the trait limited magic (DMG 150) that stifles the imprisoned creature's ability to escape the plane. In most campaigns I DM it would be extremely difficult--perhaps even impossible--to find information about such a plane (e.g. the precise kind of "small, forked metal rod" needed as a material component for the spell plane shift to visit the plane via that spell).
  • I'd like to recommend the 7th-level Sor/Wiz spell amber sarcophagus [evoc] (BE 90), which is like the spell sepia snake sigil except requiring only a ranged touch attack and a 500 gp material component, but evocations aren't an option.

A number of even higher level options are available, of course, but that list is beyond this abbreviated one's scope as you're looking for the lowest level one available.

The Hard Way

What you're asking for is an extremely high-level--probably epic--magic item. Killing creatures in D&D 3.X is simple; the dead condition is an easily removed status effect that high-level PCs are supposed to casually negate. Capturing things--that is, not killing something but leaving the creature at one's mercy but without options--is a far harder effect to generate. The game resists the very idea because it's not fun; no player wants such power in the DM's hands (because--poof!--there goes the PC forever), and no DM wants such power in the PCs' hands (because--poof!--there goes the plot forever). But it can be done with time and vast wealth.

  • Craft a custom magic item that generates a continuous effect like the 8th-level Sor/Wiz spell veil of undeath [necro] (SpC 229). This costs 360,000 gp (base 2,000 gp x8 for spell level x15 for caster level x1.5 for the 10 min./level duration of the veil spell). In addition to the spell's other effects, a creature wearing the item no longer breathes, eats, or sleeps, and the creature's immunity to nonlethal damage makes it so the creature takes no damage from thirst. Note: I could locate no lower-level Sor/Wiz or Drd spell that allows a creature to go without drinking, eating, and--hardest of all--breathing. Finding one would reduce the cost of the custom item appropriately.
  • Add to the custom item the effects of antimagic shackles (BE 116) (132,000 gp; 5 lbs.) at a cost of 198,000 gp.
  • Add to the custom item the effect of the 5th-level Sor/Wiz spell lobotomize [trans] (Dragon #339 77), picking to affect the skills Escape Artist and Open Locks. This costs 270,000 gp (base 2,000 gp x5 for spell level x9 for caster level x2 for the 1 min./level duration of the lobotomize spell x1.5 for adding the effect to the custom item).
  • Add to the custom item the effect of the 1st-level Sor/Wiz spell ray of clumsiness [trans] (SpC 166). This costs 60,000 gp (base 2,000 gp x1 for spell level x10 for caster level x2 for the 1 min./level duration of the ray spell x1.5 for adding the effect to the custom item). I'd argue that this inflicts a -8 penalty to the shackled creature's Dexterity, and but no matter what would helps prevent creatures with high Dexterity scores from simply slipping the shackles.

Then, after crafting and securing the creature, find a place to put the shackled creature. The antimagic field of these shackles will make this difficult. I suggest first using plane shift to locate a secure spot then shackling the creature.

What follows is the suggested end result for a custom magic item incorporating the previous effects.

Shackles of Eternal Confinement (888,000 gp; 5 lbs.)
These adamantine manacles fit any Small to Large creature and, when fastened, give the creature a -8 penalty to its Dexterity while creating an antimagic field to a radius of 5 feet. The DC to slip out of the shackles is 28, but breaking them is nearly impossible, requiring a DC 40 Strength check. Further, a shackled creature can make only untrained Escape Artist skill checks (as if the creature had 0 ranks in the Escape Artist skill) to slip the shackles, and the creature can't make Open Locks skill checks to unfasten them. Finally, a shackled creature is immune to mind-affecting spells and abilities, poison, sleep, paralysis, stunning, disease, death, extra damage from critical hits, nonlethal damage, death from massive damage, ability drain, energy drain, fatigue, exhaustion, damage to physical ability scores, and any effect requiring a Fortitude save unless it is harmless or affects objects. The creature need not breathe, eat, or sleep, and is damaged by cure spells and healed by inflict spells. Strong necromancy; CL 15th; Craft Wondrous Item, antimagic field, lobotomize, ray of clumsiness, veil of undeath; Price 888,000 gp; Weight 5 lbs.

"Wait... What?": Beyond the scope of this question is how any magic item that creates an antimagic field continues functioning when the magic item itself creates an antimagic field. Apparently such items do continue generating their antimagic fields even when the items themselves are in the item-created antimagic field because, well, such items exist in officially published sources sans eratta (e.g. bulwark of antimagic (Dr 118)), and one must assume that activating those items doesn't also immediately deactivate those items. I imagine it's like Magic: The Gathering's White Ward in that the item's own antimagic field doesn't affect the item... um... for some reason (e.g. "A wizard did it"). The above item assumes such a ruling's in place for this item (which is a custom item anyway), making the addition of the shackles of antimagic to the base item possible without having the antimagic field dismissing the item's other effects.

An Assumption: I assume you want the creature conscious so that the capturing creature can interrogate the captured creature or--more likely--gloat over the captured creature's plight. I mean, I would. If that's not a thing--that is, the captured creature need not be conscious--, craft a custom magic item from masterwork manacles (PH 126-7, 128) (50 gp; 2 lbs.) incorporating a continuous effect like the spell feign death [necro] (TB 89) costing 30,050 gp (base 2,000 gp x3 for the spell level x5 for the caster level and +50 gp for the masterwork manacles). The DM must determine how the manacles of the sleeping prisoner (or whatever they'd be called) work--as he must whenever custom items are involved--, but unconscious creatures are always willing, so a downed foe so manacled is pretty much permanently unconscious and doesn't need any of that air, food, or water stuff. Then the capturing creature can simply toss the captured creature into the nearest extradimensional space of choice.

  • \$\begingroup\$ Manacles of the Sleeping Prisoner are absolutely perfect. \$\endgroup\$
    – Phill.Zitt
    Jan 29, 2014 at 17:39
  • \$\begingroup\$ I have troubles understanding how a magic item can work inside an anti-magic field that it created on its own. \$\endgroup\$
    – TwoThe
    Jan 30, 2014 at 14:39
  • \$\begingroup\$ the forked metal rod (a focus, by the way) comes handy in every spell component pouch, being free. These pouches, costing 5 gp, can be purchased without issue from any settlement, even exceedingly small ones. If no settlements exist, they can be crafted provided you have 5/3 gp in relevant materials. \$\endgroup\$ Aug 29, 2015 at 7:03
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ @thedarkwanderer Hey, I prefaced it with In most campaigns I DM. My house rule has the only forked metal rod in a spell component pouch be the one for the plane on which the pouch was purchased; most others are available from vendors at low costs, but such a house rule, for example, prevents every spell component pouch from having every forked metal rod for every rope trick, bag of holding, and portable hole. I like the control over the cosmology such a house rule gives me as DM. (Also, I'd argue that the raw materials for spell component pouch crafting are pretty hard to find.) \$\endgroup\$ Aug 29, 2015 at 11:55

Crafting a magical item is a little more than casting some spells then put everything together using super-glue. As the rules state, inventing a new magical item requires tremendous research, which as well implies, that there is some form of complexity involved to put the "arcane matrix" together.

Since a DM should base the power-level of items close to similar items or spells, the actual request would be close to an imprisonment spell, which is level 9 for a good reason. Anything less would have to be balanced with less features or side-effects, like being highly volatile, possibly killing the target, or affecting other targets than intended. Something that would not make this regularly useful on lower-level characters.

The lowest form I could come up with would actually be an illusion spell, that makes the target think that it is imprisoned and act accordingly, which could be archived with something minor like Silent Image (level 1).


Trapped Portable Hole

Ah, the perfect gift! A Portable Hole is a standard magic item in the DMG requiring Plane Shift (Cleric 5/Wiz 7 Conjuration) for construction. Normally, "This hole can be picked up from inside or out by simply taking hold of the edges of the cloth and folding it up. Either way, the entrance disappears, but anything inside the hole remains." So someone could go inside, fold it up and then (I think) unfold it from the inside when they wanted and get out.

If you customized yours, and added something like Dimensional Anchor (adjuration Cleric/Wiz 4) cast at least at 10th level for a 10 minute or more duration or Dimensional Lock (Cleric/Wiz 8 - this one has duration of days) into the making of it, the effect could be that for this particular Hole, if someone goes inside and folds it up, the 'Lock' is triggered. They can't unfold it and get out like a normal Portable Hole. Oops! (consult your GM on that)

"It contains enough air to supply one Medium creature or two Small creatures for 10 minutes."

Since you want them to survive indefinitely in there, be sure to include inside the hole (as a courtesy) a clearly labeled "Potion of Flesh to Stone". (Wiz 6, Transformation) They'll need to decide if they want to drink it or not and they'll have about 10 minutes to make that decision ;)

That's probably how I'd do it; but its looking like you are going to need at least a Wiz who can cast 7th level spells (13th level Wiz) and that's probably a good thing. Imprisoning someone permanently in pocket dimensions shouldn't be easy or for low level casters - if it was, everyone would be locked up.

For reference, other Wondrous Items that do something 'kinda similar' to what you are describing in the DMG are things like the Iron Flask (20th! level Caster, 170,000gp market price) and the Mirror of Life Trapping (17th level Caster, 200,000gp market price), requiring spells like Imprisonment (Adjur Wiz 9th) and Trap the Soul (Conj Wiz 8th). A regular portable hole is practically a bargain at 20,000gp, CL 12.

  • \$\begingroup\$ Nitpick: Flesh to Stone doesn't fit into a potion, its level is too high. Love the idea, though. \$\endgroup\$
    – Ernir
    Jan 29, 2014 at 15:57
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Instead of Flesh to Stone, to address the air/food shortage, leave them a Bottle of Air and a that spoon that makes an endless supply of horrible-tasting food. Unlike the Flesh to Stone, this does fail to account for their lifespan, but maybe also include a copy of Lichdom for Dummies and the requisite materials, or that cursed cloak that turns you into a vampire if you use it too much. \$\endgroup\$ Jan 30, 2014 at 1:29
  • \$\begingroup\$ If the creature chooses to die ("Death first!"), miracle [evoc] (PH 254), true resurrection [conj] (PH 296), true reincarnation [trans] (MW 96), and wish [univ] (PH 302) can still bring back the dead prisoner, even if his body's at the bottom of the hole. If you put in the hole a trap creating an effect like the spell soul bind [necro] (PH 281), now we're talking. \$\endgroup\$ Jan 30, 2014 at 15:26

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .