How can you convey that the majority of the world isn't supernatural?

Question

In games that exist within a supernatural/urban fantasy/modern horror setting, usually only a very small percentage of the population is actually supernatural.

Using World of Darkness as an example, it's approximately 1 vampire per 50,000 in Vampire: the Masquerade (IIRC, and vampires having the largest population of the splats), and it's less than 100 Prometheans worldwide in Promethean: the Created. Prometheans aside, when you find one of these things you're likely to find more, since almost all of them are social creatures. This means that less than 1% of the population is supernatural.

How do you portray this in games so that the players don't start thinking, "what is this, what is that?" and so that they realize that these things aren't actually super common, without making it boring?

Answer 1

Don't show more than you have to

Unless you have a very good reason not to, keep appearances of the various supernatural creatures very rare. For example, in a VtM game you have, by default, an excellent reason to have lots of vampire NPCs because the PCs are vampires and the setting encourages them to find each other and interact. However, there is no such reason why ghosts, fairies or witches would be especially common or visible to the vampires.

Some form of "Masquerade" or policy of silence is a common trope for supernatural groups in this genre. That means that even if multiple sorts of creatures are present in a city, they will probably not notice each other unless a specific plot device is bringing them into contact.

The lone example

Sometimes, having just a single representative of a group appear can help reinforce the feeling of rarity. Sure, the party is used to werewolves and probably some of them believe in ghost stories. But they've never seen a real ghost until tonight!

An encounter like this lends more credence to all of the tales of "others" that abound. It tells the players that there really are lots of hidden things in this world. Because they only saw the one, it also tells them that these things are hard to find and they probably know very little about them.

Be careful not to overdo this. If you get to see one example of every creature type then "weird supernatural critters" start to feel common even if one particular species doesn't. One example of one or two (at most) things will do the trick.

Scare the mundanes

If supernaturals are rare, then most humans don't either know know about them or have never (knowingly) seen one in action. Have a human witness in a scene who can become terrified or dumbstruck at the sight of blatant supernatural power. Let this person's emotional reaction illustrate just how fantastical the monsters really are.

Compare and Contrast with Humans

Make humans plentiful. Chance encounters with supernaturals shouldn't happen much. Either the PCs are seeking one out, or being sought out. If you're just walking down the street it should be filled with regular human beings.

Show that the monsters are different. In something like VtM, this often means setting up a situation in which the PCs' vampirism sets them apart from humanity, often in a socially isolating way.

Examples:

• Interacting with a family with children who are sleepy from being out late at night. THe vampires cannot have kids, and probably see disproportionately few children due to their nocturnal habits.

• A friendly mortal is injured in an accident, and the PCs are the nearest people. The NPC, bleeding and in pain, asks them for help. Portray the NPC sympathetically, and possibly introduce them earlier so they're already liked. Then, describe the person's blood in terms tantalizing terms. Watch you players' blood pools and time this so at least one PCs should need to check for frenzy when they try to be helpful.

If the PCs are human, show them examples of NPCs acting in ways that no same human would. This doesn't have to be outright villainy (but it can be in an us vs them story).

Example:

• Some human-form werewolves are having a civil chat with the PCs. When finished, they transform to go hunt a deer with their pack.

Answer 2

So, first off, like you said, most of these communities are social. That means that even though they are the 1% they likely all know each other, hang out together, hate each other, and otherwise interact almost solely in their own little supernatural clique. This is also true in real life; the wealthy don't tend to live side by side with the poor and, as a result, most wealthy people grossly underestimate how much more money than the average person they have, how much higher their standard of living is, etc. They think of themselves and their community as 'normal' even though, objectively, they are extremely abnormal. So this isn't something you should be doing just because Vampires are rare or whatever.

That being said, if you want to do this, regardless of your reasons, you can. If the PCs don't regularly encounter 'normal' beings, they will conclude that 'normal' beings are abnormal. If they encounter 'normal' beings most of the time, they will conclude that 'normal' beings are, in fact, the norm. In World of Darkness, for example, try giving them 'normal' opponents rather than supernatural or supernaturally connected ones. Have a heavily armed local gang hold up a PC's landlady for protection money, and kill her when she can't pay (or some such). Have horrible people trafficking drugs, people, weapons, etc. into and out of the city. Have a PC's bike stolen by a juvenile delinquent. Have the IRS come after someone for back taxes. If any of the PCs have a real job, have their new boss try and frame them for embezzlement. Etcetera.

Answer 3

EDIT (Cut since it was OT)

So try this approach:

"We are the monsters that try to stay humane, but look around, how monstrous are those calling themselves man". WoD (or any similar system) is a dark place, crime,corruption, poverty is much higher than in the real world: teenage girls sell themselves to run away from abusive parents and why you walking down the street someone is quite often willing to kill you just for your shoes. Show them that dark side: let them chase some gruesome serial killer believing that its some monster, just to find its an ordinary man - I highly recommend you to watch the movie "8 mm", where detective chases masked killer who in the end looks like a dorky maths teacher. Make the players angry, let them start killing those low-lifes, let them feel like gods among mortals...and then in one moment let them realise, how low they themselves fell. On the nicer note, introduce them to some good humans: not corrupted cop, local social worker or simply a nice boy/girl that might start feeling something towards one of your players. Make them mingle with humans and play the masquerade (if you play WOD) - avoid being detected while still force them to feed.

Answer 4

Another strategy here is to make the supernaturals in your world interact with the mundane world as if they were mundane people. Day (or night) jobs, parenting, transportation, clothes, and shelter can all add interest and depth, or even entire other dimensions, to a seemingly tropish supernatural character; for instance, one of the character concepts I kick around in my head on a regular basis is a vampire who is a first officer for UPS, flying cargo jets around.