13
votes
\$\begingroup\$

I'm looking for an herbal for RPGs. I'm not looking for a list of herbs and their real uses or reputed uses (as in the question “Reputed Magical Effects of Real-World Herbs”). What I'm looking for an already-compiled supplement specifically for RPGs that has herbs and their medicinal uses in game-friendly terms that can be used directly during play.

The herbal does not need to be completely system-neutral if conversions between systems are simple enough, but my current solution is not as neutral as I would like. The more system-neutral or system-convertible, the better.

\$\endgroup\$

closed as off-topic by SevenSidedDie Dec 2 '15 at 22:16

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

locked by SevenSidedDie Jul 18 '16 at 18:03

This question exists because it has historical significance, but it is not considered a good, on-topic question for this site, so please do not use it as evidence that you can ask similar questions here. This question and its answers are frozen and cannot be changed. More info: help center.

Read more about locked posts here.

14
votes
\$\begingroup\$

This recommendation for The Guide to Herbs for RPGs cites my own experience using it for the purpose in the question.

I've been using Shaun Hately's venerable The Guide to Herbs for RPGs, first publicly published in 1997 and now in its fifth edition. Since it can be freely redistributed, it can be found in several places, including in HTML as The Illustrated Guide to Herbs for RPGs, 5th Edition, as well as in its original PDF format hosted on Google Drive.

The virtue of this herbal is that the medicinal effects it lists are very focused on what is relevant to the kinds of circumstances that come up in fantasy RPGs: a lot of healing herbs, herbs that can be used to defeat poison, herbs that can be used as legendary MacGuffins for "cure the dying king" quests, and so on. Herbs list the season, climate (temperate, tropical, etc.), and environment (forest, coastal, etc.) in which they can be found. These categories make provisions for fantasy-centric herbs too — for example, some fantastical herbs list "volcano", "underworld", or "corpses" for where they can be found. Its RPG-ness can also be seen in how it uses dice to determine various things, such as how long an effect might last or its rules for how long dried herbs maintain potency. It also intersperses advice to GMs on customising the herbal to their campaigns' needs.

The herbal is not system-neutral, but the effects of the herbs often are. Those that do involve mechanics use simple terms derived from D&D that can be converted to or used as-is in other RPGs easily enough.

Furthermore, it provides rules for locating, preparing, preserving, and buying and selling the herbs in terms that are immediately useful to a GM or player trying to use it during play. These rules are also loosely based on D&D, but they are general enough and a-mechanical enough that they can be converted to most any other RPG fairly easily, usually just by swapping out an equivalent skill. (I'm using the Guide in RuneQuest 6, for example.)

The appendices also include lists that collate the herbs by their season, climate, environment, and whether they are real or fantasy herbs, so that you can prune the herbal to the needs of your specific campaign. The last list means that it's easy to adjust the herbal for mundane games where fantastical herbs (like the “cephalophage” mushroom) would be inappropriate.

The only thing I have found it lacks for game utility is a way of randomly selecting herbs, which would be useful for generating herbalist shops' inventories or the medicinal contents of a specific hex on a map, but this is a minor complaint.

Two example entries from the herbal

Here are a pair of herbs from the Guide, to illustrate where it is and isn't system-agnostic and how much conversion may be needed. (Note: the name in parenthesis is the contributor, not the “Latin” name; the percentage in ‘Available’ is the daily chance to find the herb when actively searching for it, while ‘Uses’ is how much that search yields; price slash shows raw vs. prepared.)

Horseweed (Maya Kniese)
Available: Spring, Summer, Autumn 10%
Climatic Zone: Temperate
Locale: Grassland
Preparation: None
Cost: 7 gp / 7 gp
Uses: 1
Ability Check: Intelligence −2

This 25 cm-high plant has many broad, double-sawed leaves growing in a rosette. It grows large, yellow composite flowers, which will quickly grow hairy seeds that will fly far on the wind. The plant often has flowers and seed simultaneously. If a generous amount of the leaves is fed to a horse or similar creature, it will be able to travel all day without tiring, even if moving at a gallop.

Most of this can be used as-written in any game: availability, climate, locale, preparation, uses, and effect are all system-neutral. Cost is almost system-neutral, since most FRGPs use the gold standard. The main mechanical consideration for using this with some RPGs is adjusting the AD&D-style Ability Check that determines whether it has been successfully used and therefore has its effect. For example:

  • RQ6: a Lore (Herbalism) skill roll would be substituted for the Int check, and it would be made at Standard difficulty grade (since −10% is too little to bother bumping it to Hard). Cost would be the same number but in silver. Effect works as-written.
  • D&D 5e: A DC 15 (Moderate) Intelligence check + Proficiency if the PC has an herbalism-related skill. Effect works as-written.

Marsh Mallow (Shaun Hately)
Available: Always 20%
Climatic Zone: Temperate
Locale: Coastal
Preparation: 1 day
Cost: 5 gp / 8 gp
Uses: 3
Ability Check: Intelligence −7

This plant has a green fleshy stem and broad egg shaped leaves, both of which are covered with downy hairs. It has five petalled, pale pink flowers which sit at the base of the leaves. The root must be boiled and the resultant distillation applied to burns. If used successfully the herb will double the rate of healing for the burn.

Here the effect may need conversion as well. For example:

  • RQ6: Use Lore (Herbalism) at Formidable difficulty grade. Read the cost in silver instead of gold. Effect works as-written.
  • D&D 5e: DC 20 (Hard) Intelligence check + Proficiency if they have an herbalism-related skill. Make the effect "If successful and you've taken fire damage recently, the herb lets you roll and sum two dice per HD spent to heal during a short rest."

Such conversions aren't exact, but the effects are made up in the first place, so a near-enough conversion has the same precision as the originals anyway. Converting is simple enough it can be done on the fly, or by copying the text into a word processor and making the adjustments ahead of time.

\$\endgroup\$
  • \$\begingroup\$ I would love to see a sample listing in this answer – I’ll click the links to see, but I think the answer would be much improved. In particular, I am having a hard time grasping what precisely they do to make this usable in a system-neutral manner; I have some guesses, but I believe the devil is in the details on this. An example would help a lot in backing up those claims. \$\endgroup\$ – KRyan May 15 '15 at 17:39
  • \$\begingroup\$ @KRyan It's not system neutral, just system-simple-enough. I'll post an excerpt. \$\endgroup\$ – SevenSidedDie May 15 '15 at 17:43
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ I would not feel comfortable, as a DM, assuming that an AD&D gold piece is worth any particular amount in another system (a gold standard assumes a standard weight, which wouldn’t be present); I think you are underestimating the AD&D-knowledge necessary to use this resource. The ability check line is problematic for similar reasons, though that feels a little less hand-waved in the answer. Either way, one or two line-items out of several means this is still a good answer; I just think you’re overstating the claim somewhat. \$\endgroup\$ – KRyan May 15 '15 at 18:59
  • 2
    \$\begingroup\$ @KRyan The point is that the precise gold pieces value doesn't matter, because they were made up. If used in a game that has a sensitive economy (as in 3.5e, as you're likely thinking), then it would be up to the GM familiar with their target system to decide if the costs need adjustment, and write new ones suitably. Few games have the sort of economy which would call for such work though. Even rejecting the cost lines entirely, the remaining material is much more valuable to RPGing than non-RPG herbals are. \$\endgroup\$ – SevenSidedDie May 15 '15 at 19:01
  • \$\begingroup\$ Wow, amazing answer. As a 3.5e/Pathfinder nerd, I can totally see how these could be included in a campaign easily. \$\endgroup\$ – GreySage Jul 15 '15 at 21:36

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.