14
\$\begingroup\$

My character, a barbarian with the feat Improved Unarmed Strike,1 occasionally eschews his greataxe and punches monsters. After reading this 2009 thread and this 2009 thread, I don't know what works and what doesn't so that this barbarian's unarmed strike is considered, for example, a +1 brash (MIC 30) furious (OA 125) fury (HB 130) weapon.

What magic items can and should2 be used to add magic weapon special abilities to this barbarian's unarmed strike and why?

  • The amulet of mighty fists (DMG 246)?
  • The bracers of striking (Magic of Faerûn 155-6)?
  • The necklace of natural attacks (Savage Species 58)?
  • An item not listed here?

I'm almost certain the DM won't allow the barbarian to pay 300 gp for a masterwork unarmed strike suitable for turning into a magic weapon (this question and some of its answers notwithstanding), despite how well-intentioned and sound such reasoning may be. That dog won't hunt, so don't argue for that.

This barbarian won't have monk levels until very high levels,3 but it would be a shame if the barbarian acquired an item that granted these weapon special abilities for his unarmed strike only to have to replace the item granting them when he finally gained those monk levels, so if the item also works during a monk's flurry of blows, that'd be awesome.


1 Having taken the alternative class feature city brawler (Dragon #349 92), this barbarian only gets "the effects of the feat Two-weapon Fighting (PH 102) when fighting unarmed," so I'm pretty sure this means a magic gauntlet (PH 116, 117-8) or a magic ward cestus (Sword and Fist 70, 74) won't work with this class feature, but if an advocate can be found, that's cool.
2 That is, should from an optimization standpoint: the item requiring the smallest outlay of resources that nonetheless achieves the stated goal.
3 Actually, he'll have levels in the variant chaos monk (Dragon #335 89), which doesn't, in fact, get the special ability flurry of blows but the similar enough flailing strike.

\$\endgroup\$
1
  • \$\begingroup\$ I'd Like to point out that, going by the principality(?) rule, Gauntlets allow you to deal Lethal Damage with your unarmed strikes and "A strike with a gauntlet is otherwise considered an unarmed attack."(SRD, Weapons) The table might say it's a weapon that deals 1d3 damage, but the test says it's an Unarmed Strike. So going by the book Gauntlets should totally work with Flurry, though the consensus on the internet seems to be that they shut down monks HARD \$\endgroup\$
    – Drejzer
    Commented Feb 11, 2020 at 15:42

3 Answers 3

8
\$\begingroup\$

If unconcerned with enhancement bonuses and only needing the weapon special abilities, the 1st-level artificer infusions personal weapon augmentation [trans] (Eberron Campaign Setting 117) et al. and personal natural weapon augmentation [trans] (Races of Eberron 188) et al. grant weapon special abilities to one of the creature's weapons or natural weapons.1 A wand of personal weapon augmentation (1st-level spell at caster level 1) (15 gp/charge) is inexpensive enough that even if adding the magic weapon special ability brash (MIC 30) to one's unarmed strike every encounter, that will still be cheaper than having such as permanent magic weapon special ability using the methods below. The magic weapon special ability furious (OA 125) is in a similar but worse position, as such an effect can only be granted by a wand of weapon augmentation [trans] (ECS 117) (4th-level spell at caster level 7) (420 gp/charge), likely making long-term use too expensive to use such an item to consistently have, for example, furious fists.

If the enhancement bonus is desired, an alternative is finding a way to cast the 4th-level Drd spell superior magic fang [trans] (SpC 136). This is a very expensive wand (a wand of a 4th-level spell at caster level 20 costs 1,200/charge), but that 60,000 gp item grants all of the creature's natural attacks a +5 enhancement bonus and, by the time such a wand can be afforded, the character probably won't be participating in 50 more fights during his career.2 Note that this also assumes the spell superior magic fang can affect unarmed strikes. (While the spell magic fang implies that spell can, the spell superior magic fang lacks such language.)

However, all these all run afoul of the opportunity cost needed to activate them, so I understand why you'd avoid them. Attempting to generate such effects faster makes the price higher and makes the options below even more appealing.

Let's do some math!

Amulet of Mighty Fists (DMG 246)
The amulet of mighty fists specifically improves both the wearer's unarmed strikes and the wearer's natural attacks, but only grants both enhancement bonuses on attack rolls and damage rolls.

Amulet of Mighty Fists
Enhancement Bonus
Cost
+1 6,000 gp
+2 24,000 gp
+3 54,000 gp
+4 96,000 gp
+5 150,000 gp

Unfortunately, the amulet of mighty fists apparently can't grant the wearer's unarmed strikes and natural weapons magic weapon special abilities (that is, at least it can't without DM permission).

Bracers of Striking (Magic of Faerûn 155-6)
These cost 1,310 gp, weigh 1 lb., occupy the bracers slot, and grant the wearer the ability to make unarmed strikes as if the wearer possessed the feat Improved Unarmed Strike (very carefully not granting the actual feat). They can be made magical as if they were a blunt double weapon (hence any magical enhancement bonus or special ability costs double, the text implying that each "fist" (or head, I guess?) can't be magicked separately).

Bracers of Striking
Enhancement Bonus
Cost
+1 4,000 gp
+2 16,000 gp
+3 36,000 gp
+4 64,000 gp
+5 100,000 gp
+6 144,000 gp
+7 196,000 gp
+8 256,000 gp
+9 324,000 gp
+10 400,000 gp

The item is not as explicit as it could be (the bracers can be modified with additional magic weapon special abilities but don't say those affect the wearer's unarmed strike, and I've read at least one argument wherein it was said seriously that the bracers' themselves must be used to beat a fool to employ their weapon special abilities), but if one assumes the enhancement bonuses apply to unarmed strikes and one's only making unarmed strikes, the bracers are a better deal than the amulet of mighty fists.

Necklace of Natural Weapons (Savage Species 58)
This item affects but a lone natural weapon unless more cash is paid. It's acknowledged that unarmed strikes are not natural weapons (but there's a counterargument couched in the fanged ring, below), so this probably doesn't do you any good, but it's included for completeness because you asked. The cost is multiplied by the number of natural weapons the amulet affects.

Necklace of Natural Weapons
Enhancement Bonus
Cost
(1 NW)
Cost
(2 NWs)
Cost
(3 NWs)
Cost
(4 NWs)
Cost
(5 NWs)
+1 2,600 gp 5,200 gp 7,800 gp 10,400 gp 13,000 gp
+2 8,600 gp 17,200 gp 25,800 gp 34,400 gp 43,000 gp
+3 18,600 gp 37,200 gp 55,800 gp 74,400 gp 93,000 gp
+4 32,600 gp 65,200 gp 97,800 gp 130,400 gp 163,000 gp
+5 50,600 gp 101,200 gp 151,800 gp 202,400 gp 253,000 gp
+6 72,600 gp 145,200 gp 217,800 gp 290,400 gp 363,000 gp
+7 98,600 gp 197,200 gp 295,800 gp 394,400 gp 493,000 gp
+8 128,600 gp 257,200 gp 385,800 gp 514,400 gp 643,000 gp
+9 162,600 gp 325,200 gp 487,800 gp 650,400 gp 813,000 gp
+10 200,600 gp 401,200 gp 601,800 gp 802,400 gp 1,003,000 gp

This makes the necklace of natural weapons a better deal than the amulet of mighty fists only if the wearer has but one or two natural weapons, except that the necklace explicitly can have magic weapon special abilities, and the DM must approve the idea that magic weapon special abilities can be added via the amulet.

Other Options
Below are a few options unmentioned by your question.

  • The fanged ring (Dragon Magic 101) (10,000 gp; 0 lbs.) doesn't say it can be further magicked to grant unarmed strikes enhancement bonuses or weapon special abilities, but a generous DM may allow it. Further, the fanged ring implies that an unarmed strike is a natural attack, so it's useful for attempting to convince the DM that a necklace of natural weapons really can affect one's unarmed strike.
  • The ward cestus (Arms and Equipment Guide 6, 10) (10 gp; 4 lbs), an exotic weapon, says that attacking with it "is considered an unarmed attack," and attacks with it deal the same damage as the wielder's unarmed strike. If the DM permits the alternative class feature city brawler to fight with a ward cestus yet still be considered unarmed, this is a viable alternative.
  • Just in case you later become concerned with enhancement bonuses, a Drd20 charges 600 gp to cast the 3rd-level spell greater magic fang [trans] (PH 250) on an unarmed strike (possible according to the 1st-level Drd spell magic fang [trans] (PH 250)). A Sor20 charges 8,500 gp to cast the 5th-level Sor/Wiz spell permanency [univ] (PH 259-60) on that greater magic fang spell. Although vulnerable to dispel magic effects, this combination is inexpensive enough to get done several times over the course of an adventurer's career before acquiring +5 enhancement in some other fashion is more prudent. (Costs are according to Spellcasting and Services (PH 129), but actually locating such powerful casters is campaign-dependent.)

"So what do I buy?"

If you're using only unarmed strikes, you'll need the bracers. Fortunately, some of the weapon special abilities you want only require the weapon to be wielded, so, for example, you could get the following:

  • brash (MIC 30) (+1 bonus; 0 lbs.) furious (OA 125) (+2 bonus; 0 lbs.) fury (HB 130) (+1 bonus; 0 lbs.) bracers of striking (Mag 155-6) (65,310 gp; 1 lbs.). Note: The bracers' description says that they "may be modified with special weapon abilities as if they were a blunt weapon." Ask the DM if that means the bracers need a +1 magical enhancement bonus before they can have further magic weapon special abilities.
  • +1 brash (MIC 30) (+1 bonus; 0 lbs.) furious (OA 125) (+2 bonus; 0 lbs.) fury (HB 130) (+1 bonus; 0 lbs.) ward cestus (AE 6, 10) (50,310 gp; 4 lbs.). Note: As an exotic weapon, the cash saved from buying a ward cestus will probably spent overcoming the −4 penalty for nonproficiency.

And if, for example, you bind the soulmeld girallon arms (Magic of Incarnum 68) to your totem chakra and want magic weapon special abilities for that soulmeld's four claw attacks, you'll need the necklace.

  • fury (HB 130) (+1 bonus; 0 lbs.) necklace of four natural weapons (SS 58) (10,400 gp; 0 lbs.). Note: See the bracers Note, above, the necklace description containing similar vague language.

Note: The magic weapon special ability fury (HB 130) (+1 bonus; 0 lbs.) needs to apply to every natural weapon and unarmed strike for it to be worthwhile, yet the special ability deals but an extra +1d6 points of damage (albeit untyped) each and only while raging, so, really, I suggest just skipping that magic weapon special ability. The same and more goes for the weapon special ability berserker (MIC 29) (+1 bonus), and more being that the weapon special ability is limited to two-handed weapons (which, with an inappropriately large magical ward cestus, is a possibility but a silly and impractical one).

Other Useful Items

  • The beast claws (SS 49) (9,610 gp; 1 lbs.) are a pair of +1 spiked gauntlets (PH 117, 118) that grant the wearer 2 claw attacks with a +1 enhancement bonus and, if the wearer already has claws, the enhancement bonus increases to +2 and the wearer's claws deal an extra +1d6 points of damage. Note: Combined with the soulmeld girallon arms, these are pretty spiffy, but, given the item's age (and provenance!), the DM will likely update the description for a contemporary campaign. However, any DM that allows these into the campaign may also allow them to be further magicked.
  • The collar of venom (BV 114) (50,000 gp; 3 lbs.) causes the wearer's natural attacks to become poisonous (Fort DC 14, primary damage 1d10 Con, secondary damage 1d10 Con).
  • The demonhair shirt (Dragon #356 69) (26,000 gp; 3 lbs.) grants the wearer immunity to fear, and the wearer can spend 2 rages simultaneously to enter a demonic fury that, among other effects, grants the wearer impressive bonuses that explicitly stack with rage and frenzy (!) and makes all the wearer's weapons (including natural weapons) chaotic for overcoming aligned DR.
  • The gauntlets of ghost fighting (MIC 216) (4,000 gp; 1 lbs.), among other effects, causes the wearer's melee attacks to affect incorporeal creatures normally.
  • The ghoul gauntlets (MIC 104-5) (10,000 gp; 1 lbs.) grant the wearer, before making an attack, the ability, once per round, to declare one natural or unarmed attack as capable of paralyzing a hit foe (Fort DC 13 negates).
  • The ring of adamantine touch (MIC 121) (6,000 gp; 0 lbs.) causes the wearers weapons (including natural weapons) to overcome DR X/adamantine as if they were adamantine. Given its rarity, this is likely a late-game purchase if at all.
  • The tentacle extension (illithid) (Und 75) (32,000 gp; 2 lbs.) grant a lone tentacle a +2 enhancement bonus on attack and damage rolls, a 1-step size increase to damage, and an extra 5 ft. of reach. Note: The soulmeld displacer mantle (Magic of Incarnum 64) bound to your totem chakra grants 2 tentacle attacks. However, that doesn't make this a good deal.
  • The wyrmfang amulet (MIC 148) (1,350 gp; 0 lbs.) causes the wearer's natural attacks and unarmed strikes to overcome DR X/magic as if they were magic weapons. Given how frequently this arises, this is likely an early-game purchase, later sold when better options become available.

1 Fortunately, the infusion personal weapon augmentation targets but a weapon and its description only mandates it affect a weapon, saying nothing about the weapon being manufactured, so affecting an unarmed strike should be a thing even if not a monk.
2 This overstates things a little. The character'll probably need to buy two or even three eventually. Each wand contains sufficient charges to use 1 charge per encounter for about 3 levels worth of encounters. A third wand tips things in favor of the amulet over the course of the character's career.

\$\endgroup\$
6
  • \$\begingroup\$ in searching for that question, i found another question that pointed out that in 3.5 RAW, "an unarmed attack is always considered a light weapon". i may have been confusing 5e, where "unarmed" is officially NOT a weapon, but can be used like one. i've removed my previous comments. \$\endgroup\$
    – tzxAzrael
    Commented Apr 18, 2017 at 13:45
  • \$\begingroup\$ Something that might improve this answer is discussion of minor schemas (Magic of Eberron). A CL 1 minor schema of personal weapon infusion costs 400gp for a 1/day use of the infusion, and its Use Magic Device DC is only 22. In the short term, the wand is likely more effective (and its UMD DC is only 20), but getting several of these to use during the day may be good in some sorts of games, as they'll never run out and remain quite strong all the way to 20. \$\endgroup\$ Commented Nov 25, 2017 at 11:54
  • \$\begingroup\$ Got an upvote on my answer, bringing my attention here: would you mind if I converted your monospace tables to proper table syntax? \$\endgroup\$
    – KRyan
    Commented Jun 10 at 16:42
  • \$\begingroup\$ @KRyan I would not mind at all. And If, while you're there, you also changed acknowledge to acknowledged that'd be great. (There's another typo in there, too, but I don't want to read the answer again to find it.) Thank you. \$\endgroup\$ Commented Jun 10 at 16:56
  • \$\begingroup\$ Well, I got “acknolwedge[d],” but didn’t see the other. There’s no “colspan” equivalent for the table markup, so I had to rework the NNW table some; hopefully it’s still to your liking. (And hopefully I didn’t make any mental math errors in its creation.) \$\endgroup\$
    – KRyan
    Commented Jun 10 at 17:54
5
\$\begingroup\$

I recommend fanged ring and necklace of natural attacks.

  • The fanged ring gives Improved Unarmed Strike, Improved Natural Attack (unarmed strike), and bonus Con damage on a critical hit. You don’t need Improved Unarmed Strike, but Improved Natural Attack is pretty nice, as is the Con damage.

    Dragon Magic—10,000 gp

  • The necklace of natural attacks can get special weapon properties, unlike the amulet of mighty fists, and for fewer than three natural attacks, the necklace of natural attacks is cheaper.

    The bracers of striking are only a little more expensive if you are using Two-Weapon Fighting (110 gp), and free up a ring slot which may be worthwhile.

    Savage Species—For each natural weapon affected, 600 gp plus the cost of the weapon properties applied. For TWF, even unarmed, I would presume that to be 2×(600 + bonus2 × 2,000 gp + miscellaneous) gp.

Aside from these, I’d probably focus on getting as big as possible. That will benefit all modes of attack.

\$\endgroup\$
4
  • \$\begingroup\$ With already having the Improved Unarmed Strike feat and not having the Improved Critical (unarmed strike) feat, I'm not sure that +0.5 damage and 1 point of Constitution damage on a critical hit is worth 10,000 gp. Also, I know what the items say (and cost) according to the books, but folks claim they interact differently and with different special abilities, natural weapons, and unarmed strikes. \$\endgroup\$ Commented Jul 2, 2015 at 16:22
  • \$\begingroup\$ @HeyICanChan Agreed; the fanged ring would be a rather late-game pick-up, after you have a larger die to work with and 10,000 gp is worth less to you. \$\endgroup\$
    – KRyan
    Commented Jul 2, 2015 at 16:32
  • \$\begingroup\$ @HeyICanChan In the spirit of 'getting big' perhaps a level, or three, of Psychic Warrior; or asking to retrain a feat for Hidden Talent. Expansion is most unarmed fighters' dream come true. \$\endgroup\$
    – Ruut
    Commented Jul 2, 2015 at 17:11
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ @Ruut Personally, I have a profound yet largely unquantifiable prejudice against size-changing effects (probably stemming from some jerk a decade ago taking an hour at the table in the middle of combat to recompute his character's stats after an enlarge person), so I don't use 'em and hesitate suggesting them to others, despite their vast utility. It's my quirk, I know, but I gladly own it. \$\endgroup\$ Commented Jul 2, 2015 at 17:19
1
\$\begingroup\$

Monks have much better based unarmed damage. While gaining levels as monks might not be an options, there are items that help "play pretend", see this GiantitP thread:

  • Gauntlets of the Talon (Relic), +5 Monk Level (or 1d8), 20,000 gp (Complete Divine, p. 97)
  • Monk's Belt, +5 Monk Level (also gain AC), 13,000 gp, (Dungeon Master's Guide)
  • Monk's Tattoo, +4 Monk Level (restricted to monks), 80,000 gp (Magic of Faerun, pg 163)

Of those, Monk's Belt is an obvious choice, both cost efficient and granting a bonus +1 AC when unarmored.

Also, as mentioned by KRyan, increasing size is a very effective way of gaining more damage:

  • the character's Strength increases
  • the weapon/unarmed damage die increases

As a result, any items that allow growth can be worth your while:

  • a Wand of Enlarge Person only costs 750 gp for 50 charges for +1 size category, and a friendly Sorcerer or Wizard can easily use it on you
  • Expansion or Giant Size are other options, but I could not find how to get them in an item efficiently (a Dorje of Expansion can only attain Manifester Level 6 (1+5) when it would take ML 7 to get a +2 size categories and Giant Size is a 7th-level spell so you would need a rod or scepter); friendly casters are still an option of course

In the same vein (and although not strictly on topic), I would advise nabbing Powerful Build if possible as it increases your effective size by 1 size category, however I only know of Goliath (Races of Stone) and Half-Giant (Expanded Psionics Handbook) to have this racial trait and know of no other way to get it. Of course, Goliaths are pretty good Barbarians, so it could mesh well with your concept.

A Goliath under the effect of an augmented Expansion would be Huge and count as Gargantuan for the purpose of computing the damage it deals with Unarmed Strikes.


Dice and average damage (per unarmed attack) dealt by various combinations.

Medium size

  • Regular Medium character: 1d3 => 2
  • Goliath Medium character: 1d4 => 2.5
  • Monk 1 Medium character: 1d6 => 3.5
  • Goliath/Monk 1 Medium character: 1d8 => 4.5
  • Monk 5 Medium character: 1d8 => 4.5
  • Goliath/Monk 5 Medium character: 2d6 => 7

Large size

  • Regular Large character: 1d4 +1 (Str) => 3.5
  • Goliath Large character: 1d6 +1 (Str) => 4.5
  • Monk 1 Large character: 1d8 +1 (Str) => 5.5
  • Goliath/Monk 1 Large character: 2d6 +1 (Str) => 8
  • Monk 5 Large character: 2d6 +1 (Str) => 8
  • Goliath/Monk 5 Large character: 3d6 +1 (Str) => 11.5

Huge size

  • Regular Huge character: 1d6 +2 (Str) => 5.5
  • Goliath Huge character: 1d8 +2 (Str) => 6.5
  • Monk 1 Huge character: 2d6 +2 (Str) => 9
  • Goliath/Monk 1 Huge character: 3d6 +2 (Str) => 12.5
  • Monk 5 Huge character: 3d6 +2 (Str) => 12.5
  • Goliath/Monk 5 Huge character: 4d6 +2 (Str) => 16

Note: I just saw your comment about having to recompute statistics when changing size. I would expect a character built around this concept to either maintain several character sheets (1 per size) or to have a character sheet annotated with all the gains/losses in the appropriate sections; obviously recomputing one's character sheet mid-game is a big no-no.

\$\endgroup\$
3
  • \$\begingroup\$ This is a lot of information that doesn't directly answer his question. He is asking about adding special abilities to his unarmed strikes. Perhaps putting this into your answer will make it a better answer. Would hate to see all of the math involved down-voted. \$\endgroup\$
    – Ruut
    Commented Jul 5, 2015 at 11:48
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ @Ruut: Ah! I focused so much on improved Unarmed Strikes that I completely forgot about the fact that the question was about granting them special abilities and not improving them in general... I am afraid it does actually makes this answer off-topic... \$\endgroup\$ Commented Jul 5, 2015 at 12:10
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ There's nothing wrong with asking then answering your own question on such a topic, moving this answer to that. But, yeah, it doesn't exactly answer the question. (I do now want to turn my character's 2 monk levels into 16 monk levels for 113,000 gp, though!) \$\endgroup\$ Commented Jul 5, 2015 at 19:22

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .