4
\$\begingroup\$

The Undead Controlling armor special ability says:

The wearer of a suit of armor or a shield with this property may control up to 26 HD of undead per day, as the control undead spell. At dawn each day, the wearer loses control of any undead still under his sway.

It does not say you can only activate it once per day. It also has a different duration to the spell used.

Can you get control of a few zombies here and later on a few ghouls there?
If an undead succeeds in his Will Save, does its Hit Dice count towards your 26 daily limit? Or is it an once per day activation?

\$\endgroup\$
5
\$\begingroup\$

The wearer of a suit of magic armor that possesses the special ability undead controlling (DMG 219) (49,000 gp; 0 lbs.) can take a standard action to employ an effect like the spell control undead [necro] (PH 214) as if cast by a level 13 wizard (hence a Will save DC 20) except that no matter how often this effect is employed over the course of the day the wearer can't control more than a total of 26 Hit Dice of undead creatures and that controlled undead creatures are freed of this control at dawn.

Thus the armor special ability's control undead effect has always had a 13-min. duration, which makes the be-careful!-control-expires-at-dawn! limitation a little weird. (This reader speculates that the special ability's author may have mixed up the duration of the spell control undead with the duration of the 2nd-level Sor/Wiz spell command undead [necro] (PH 211), which is a healthier 1 day/level). Likewise, it's also weird that the special ability has no limit to how often it can be activated, but after a certain point—that is, when the day's Hit Dice cap is reached,—the special ability does nothing if it's activated again.

However, this DM doesn't see any problem with the special ability—even allowing the PC to have a head-up display that counts down his armor's Hit Dice controlled today cap seems a reasonable accommodation given the special ability's price—, and the special ability remains playable enough as written despite its quirks. I mean, I guess eventually even that 26-Hit-Dice lich will roll a 1, and you'll control it for the next 13 min.; use that time wisely… and try to time things so that the lich fails its saving throw more than, like, 1 round before dawn.


Note: The armor special ability undead controlling was absent from the Dungeon Master's Guide (2000), first appearing as a +4 bonus in 2001's Defenders of the Faith (23). The ability was added to the Dungeon Master's Guide by the 3.5 revision, its description largely unchanged from its original appearance.

\$\endgroup\$
0
\$\begingroup\$

The wording of this property seems to be lacking: it specifies something about controlling a certain amount of undead, and seems to leave out anything about what you do to actually gain control those undead.

Ultimately, the reference to control undead makes no sense unless it grants you the ability to use control undead. On the other side, 49,000 gp for what appears to be an at-will persistent control undead (which should be something like \$13 \times \left(7 + 6\right) \times (1\ 800\text{ gp}) = 304\ 000\text{ gp}\$ per the item-creation guidelines and the Persistent Spell feat’s +6-level modifier) seems like a staggering bargain. Even at 1/day, that would still be over 60k gp.

But then perhaps control undead is underpowered. Despite astonishing discount, I might consider allowing the control undead effect to be used at-will, within the 26 HD total cap.

\$\endgroup\$

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.