17
\$\begingroup\$

Our home games have been running with the Variant Rule: Flanking while playing on a grid. It came to a surprise to us, when we first played in the Adventurer's League, that Flanking is not allowed in AL play.

I'm considering adapting the no-flanking rule in our home games now, and was wondering what comment or statements WotC have said about why they don't allow flanking in AL. I am hoping to gain insight on which to base a decision.

To be clear, I'm not looking for an answer on whether I should or should not allow flanking (this would obviously differ from table to table), neither am I inviting speculation as to the reason why AL doesn't allow it. I am looking for a WotC-representative (or similar) commentary on why the DMG rule variants, especially flanking, is not allowed in organized Adventurer's League play.

\$\endgroup\$
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ "this would obviously differ from table to table" Don't you think that this is already the obvious answer why it's not in use in AL? \$\endgroup\$ – nvoigt Apr 6 '17 at 13:24
  • \$\begingroup\$ @nvoigt If AL tells DMs and players that flanking is a rule they all must follow, then not really. If they treat it like feats and multiclassing where everyone can get it, then it won't differ from AL table to table. \$\endgroup\$ – daze413 Apr 6 '17 at 15:27
20
\$\begingroup\$

In general, both Adeptus' and IcyFire's answers are correct. Specifically, the flanking rule makes positioning on a map more important since some class abilities are based on having advantage. This applies mostly to the Rogue, which already has a way to get advantage when an ally is adjacent to an enemy, so it would mostly only serve to cause another decision point in a player's turn while they seek the best way to get advantage while not provoking attacks of opportunity from other foes. All of which takes time. Multiply that by 6 players and each round is going to take a bit longer trying to make that decision, every round in every combat. Ultimately not allowing flanking makes the game simpler and speeds up combat.

Source: I am the Community Manager for the D&D Adventurers League, Robert Adducci

\$\endgroup\$
29
\$\begingroup\$

Because the DMG wasn't finalized when AL started

I did a bit of digging, and found this article from December 2014: (excerpt, emphasis added)

Rules contained in the Dungeon Masters Guide may be permitted in future storyline seasons by future versions of the Player’s Guide. Until then, the Dungeon Masters Guide can only be used in D&D Adventurers League games to look up magic items and for general advice on how to run games. This rule was necessary in part because the book was still in editing when the D&D Adventurers League started.

This was written by Art Severance, who was Regional Coordinator for the US Far West region at the time that article was written (I'm not sure if he still is).

Variant gameplay rules cause inconsistencies between tables

The same article also states,

Just as the name implies, the D&D Adventurers League is a league game, in which everyone plays by the same rules, whether they always play in the same place or play all over the world. Characters within the League are portable, so a player who visits another area or moves there or who plays in an online game expects to be able to play his or her character there without having to make any modifications and without having to learn any local rules.

Allowing DMs to decide whether or not to use variant rules that modify gameplay, such as flanking, would mean that there would be "local rules," which runs counter to the philosophy that rules and gameplay are identical between AL tables.

Note that in V3.0 of the FAQ, nearly all of the variant rules that are allowed only affect characters, not gameplay. The one exception is playing on a grid, which I'd argue is a well-accepted, almost standard rule.

\$\endgroup\$
  • 2
    \$\begingroup\$ I think this is very relevant: "However, D&D Adventurer's League play does not use any other optional or variant rules as presented in the Dungeon Master's Guide." I am not convinced that the variant rules weren't allowed because the DMG was still in editing at the time. The way the above quote is written, it seems like they already excluded the DMG variants even before release. \$\endgroup\$ – daze413 Apr 6 '17 at 6:16
  • \$\begingroup\$ @daze413, why is that not convincing? While it is a bit weak, that's at least part of the stated rationale. I've added the passage that explains the transferrability principle, which is a bit stronger and probably explains why they haven't added those rules since, while they have added other variants rules. \$\endgroup\$ – Icyfire Apr 6 '17 at 6:22
  • \$\begingroup\$ Yes, this is a good find and I understand the need for uniformity in AL play all across the world, but the question was why flanking, and the other variants in the DMG (like tumble/overrun and multiple attackers), weren't included (along with feats, grids, multi-classing, and point-buy) in the rules. If it was for uniformity, couldn't they have included it uniformly among all AL? \$\endgroup\$ – daze413 Apr 6 '17 at 6:30
  • \$\begingroup\$ Unfortunately, the article I posted is the only solid developer commentary I could find; while I can definitely speculate (the DMG frames those rules as options, so forcing them in all AL would be inconsistent), I'm not sure that clear statements on gameplay variant rules are out there. \$\endgroup\$ – Icyfire Apr 6 '17 at 6:51
14
\$\begingroup\$

Part of the idea behind AL is to keep the rules consistent between tables. Looking at the variant rules able to be used, the only one not relating to character creation is Playing on a Grid.

From the AL FAQ:

Can I use the Variant and Optional Rules in the PHB/DMG?
The only optional or variant rules available for use are:

  • Variant: Customizing Ability Scores (PHB)
  • Variant Human Traits (PHB)
  • Half-Elf Variants (SCAG)
  • Option: Human Languages (SCAG)
  • Tiefling Variants (SCAG)
  • Variant: Playing on a Grid (PBR)

Without specific campaign documentation, any other variant or optional rules, such as Variant: Quasit Familiar (MM) are not available for use.

From the AL DM's Guide:

Rules for Dungeon Masters
The variant rules for “Playing on a Grid” in the D&D Basic Rules and Player’s Handbook can be used if you and your players wish. Dungeon Masters should feel free to use the Dungeon Masters Guide to help run games if they so choose. However, D&D Adventurers League play does not use any other optional or variant rules as presented in the Dungeon Master’s Guide.

Whether a game is played on a grid vs theater of the mind has little impact on tactics, but flanking makes positioning far more important, and has greater impact on balance.

So, if they allowed flanking in AL, it would have to be always in use for AL. This would make it effectively the default, which would make not using it the "variant".

\$\endgroup\$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.