Today during session a question came up about Three Reasons to Live. Is the bard able to get the +6 bard level bonus to a bardic performance without using the once per day power, or is starting a performance with the horn a part of the same ability?


The two functions are separate

The item description says:

...Once per day the horn can be blown to [produce an effect]. If a bard uses the horn to start a bardic performance, [the performance is enhanced].

These are two separate abilities. The first ability is a 'command-word' function, 'paid' for by being a consumed daily use ability of the item. The second is a function of the item enhancing the Bardic Performance ability of a bard, which is already a limited resource, limited to \$Cha + 2 × Level +2\$ rounds per day.

The wording makes them separate too...

The way the sentences read also makes them unconnected. The first sentence is a physical description of the instrument. The second describes an ability of the instrument, while the third and fourth sentences each refer back to the previous sentence, connecting them to it:

2 Once per day the horn can be blown to affect all allies...
3 Affected creatures gain sonic resistance [etc]...
4 This protection lasts...

the fifth sentence does not refer to the previous ability so is unconnected to the first ability. Thus it describes a separate ability. The sixth, and last, sentence again refers back to the previous sentence, making it part of the second ability:

5 If a bard uses the horn to start a bardic performance...
6 This doesn't grant the bard...


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.