Questions tagged [metagaming]

For questions about topics concerning using, managing, or separating player knowledge and character knowledge.

Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
22 votes
7 answers
7k views

What do I do if my players are acting in a way that is meta-gaming and are refusing to accept my decision?

The Situation I have a party of 5 players all sleeping in a barn on an abandoned farm at night. This is near the beginning of the campaign and each player likes having little secrets about each other....
Space Dead's user avatar
-1 votes
5 answers
737 views

What is the rules basis for the idea that characters don't know about mechanics like hit points, hit dice, and class levels?

It's commonly said that values you find on a character sheet like hit points, hit dice, and class levels aren't diegetic. That is, the characters in the world that we're roleplaying in have no idea ...
user avatar
13 votes
3 answers
3k views

Do players/characters know when a monster uses its Legendary Resistance?

Assuming that players are causing a monster with the Legendary Resistance ability to make enough saving throws that it will use them all up, should the players be aware when that point has come? (As a ...
Kerrick's user avatar
  • 4,044
10 votes
3 answers
3k views

What can I do about a fellow player who forgets his class features and metagames?

I need advice on how to handle the behavior of a fellow PC. Situation Our group formed about 4 Months ago, we are 4PCs + 1DM. We are playing D&D 5e Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden. Our DM ...
PeterHartz's user avatar
2 votes
3 answers
229 views

Magic Items and their allocation [closed]

I have a predicament I've come across in a campaign I'm running. Here it is. In a past session my DM (a friend of mine) challenged me to complete the entire trial with strict restrictions. The ...
Mox's user avatar
  • 37
5 votes
2 answers
246 views

How to stop everyone taking a crack at a challenge? [duplicate]

I'm relatively new to DMing and I'm struggling to manage the flow of the game when there's an "obvious" skill or ability check, such as a barred door. If, for example, the wizard confidently ...
Eterm's user avatar
  • 151
22 votes
9 answers
5k views

How to stop a player from looking up monster stat blocks in combat?

In my 5th edition Eberron campaign I have a player who is determined to metagame in combat which makes it really hard for the others to actually get much enjoyment. Recently the problem player gained ...
Argo's user avatar
  • 3,445
21 votes
9 answers
6k views

One game's great GM is another game's problem player-- How to handle for a novice GM?

I am a player in a long-term Pathfinder campaign which I like very much. The players in that campaign are myself, my fiance, the GM's fiance, and the GM's co-worker. We're all in our twenties, and I ...
insouciant's user avatar
6 votes
2 answers
991 views

What if one PC wants to do something without party?

As a player, how would you approach your DM about your character doing something out of session that neither the others players/party wouldn't witness.? (Example, asking to sneak away from the party) ...
user avatar
20 votes
3 answers
4k views

Metagaming Concern? Or just normal player culture?

I am a DM for 5e who recently gave the team a magical item. Everyone is very excited for it, however the player who chose to keep it in their inventory has been researching it. He has looked up how ...
Susty Rackleford's user avatar
28 votes
3 answers
6k views

Should players know other creatures' HP? How do you deal with players not knowing the opponent's HP if not?

I recently started playing D&D, and I was wondering about this. I know it is up to the DM to choose whether or not players know enemies' remaining HP in combat: is it recommended to do so? ...
Charel's user avatar
  • 283
8 votes
3 answers
397 views

How to avoid alienation by expected but slow mood shift, and still keep players out of spoilers?

I run a My Little Pony(MLP) campaign. By design, at the start of the campaign what the citizens (PCs) know about the world is true, but it's not the whole and complete truth, and many issues of the ...
Cloud Ring's user avatar
19 votes
2 answers
2k views

Do reactions that trigger on saving throws give knowledge of saving throws that would otherwise be secret?

Preliminaries. Some reactions have triggers which are tangible events in the fiction of the game. For example, feather fall's casting time is: 1 reaction, which you take when you or a creature within ...
Thomas Markov's user avatar
2 votes
1 answer
266 views

Does a character know the source of an unseen force attempting (and failing) to act upon their mind? [closed]

If a creature attempts to Dominate, deal save-or-suck psychic damage, or otherwise psychologically influence a PC, what do they know about the attempt? Obviously the player themselves know when I say, ...
TheNeeoo's user avatar
  • 311
4 votes
5 answers
518 views

Should I warn the GM of probable mistakes he made or could make?

The question isn't strictly bound to rules - although sometimes there are mistakes about those too, the GM is kind of a novice - but is mostly related to reading some statblocks in the book. To better ...
Snakehelm's user avatar
  • 2,417
15 votes
1 answer
2k views

Does my character know he's ill while incubating a disease?

My character was bitten by a Dire Rat and through accidental meta-gaming reasons, I know he's incubating Filth Fever. I want to ask the Paladin in our party to remove it before it can affect my stats, ...
Karrion42's user avatar
  • 1,179
28 votes
8 answers
5k views

Using succubi as villains in a low-sexuality game

Question I'm seeking expertise regarding using iconically sexual creatures without leaning on that nature. Specifically, one of the players in my group has a backstory that prominently features ...
Ben S.'s user avatar
  • 4,872
22 votes
6 answers
2k views

How to provide knowledge to players?

I've read a lot of articles on player vs. character knowledge, where the crux of the article is always that players know more than their characters, and metagaming is an issue. For good or for bad, I ...
ggutenberg's user avatar
16 votes
5 answers
3k views

How can I handle a player who seems to utilize skills their characters don't have?

Well the tag is slightly misleading as these players do not cause problems. However I have encountered several players who exhibit skills their real life counterpart has without actually metagaming. ...
Maiko Chikyu's user avatar
  • 20.9k
1 vote
5 answers
1k views

Is there a reason to investigate illusions like Phantasmal Force other than some kind of metagaming?

If I cast phantasmal force on an NPC to make him think a creature has jumped onto his back and is trying to strangle him, assuming he fails his initial roll, why would he use an action to make an ...
NibblyPig's user avatar
  • 1,577
3 votes
0 answers
138 views

What do you think of 1/session items? Or help me find a better way to solve this plot hook. I'm stumped [closed]

I wanted to give my players a homebrew item, but I'm having a hard time balancing it around in-game / in-universe limitations. Normally this is like 1/day, 1/encounter etc. I was thinking of doing 1/...
HelpfulPaul's user avatar
2 votes
0 answers
126 views

How to handle rolls for in-game DND game [closed]

My group is playing a scenario set in the modern everyday world (late 20th century) and we have got into a position where the characters must play a DND game. The outcome of this game is important ...
equin0x80's user avatar
  • 121
36 votes
12 answers
5k views

How do I play in an adventure as a player that I have run as a DM?

After playing the starter edition as a DM, a player that I was playing with wanted to give DMing a shot and asked me to join him. And I happily did. We are now 2 sessions in and I have noticed a ...
darnok's user avatar
  • 4,760
33 votes
8 answers
4k views

Do characters know they did a poor job if the result of a dice roll isn't automatically obvious?

During a discussion I had with @jgn based on the question discussing rolling twice on an investigation check, I realized we were operating with entirely different ideas of how dice rolls actually ...
Theik's user avatar
  • 36.4k
6 votes
3 answers
387 views

How to fool characters while avoiding metagame

Normally, both player and DM rely on stealth checks and secret messages when one player wants to do something without the rest of the party knowing, regardless of the motivation behind it. This ...
Melferas's user avatar
  • 629
2 votes
1 answer
1k views

Player is out of character and refuses to play her character correctly [closed]

A player in my campaign (I am the DM) is going way out of control-by not playing her character. Whenever I point this out, she says that it is something her character would do, but a look at her ...
ThePuzzlerThree's user avatar
6 votes
6 answers
339 views

Improving Lie Detection and Credibility Assessment Rules

Many systems have two or more skills/traits/other numeric values that can be pitted against each other in situations where side A tries to assess side B's credibility, where side B may or may not be ...
vicky_molokh- unsilence Monica's user avatar
6 votes
2 answers
719 views

Can you use your action to interrupt another player's action from earlier in the same round?

I play in a game when everyone plays the way they want on their own turn : saying to another player what he should do is forbidden. Your turn = your action. I think this is pretty fun and it adds a ...
cdauphin's user avatar
  • 323
43 votes
4 answers
6k views

What techniques can I use to seduce a PC without arousing suspicion of ulterior motives?

I am looking to have an NPC try and seduce one of the PCs in my party. The NPC has an ulterior motive of course, but I don't want the player immediately suspecting a succubus or similar. What ...
SeriousBri's user avatar
22 votes
3 answers
10k views

Can you decide not to sneak into a room after seeing your roll?

If someone asks to stealthily open a door but rolls poorly, can they just choose not to do it, and let someone else open the door?
Imspringin's user avatar
32 votes
2 answers
5k views

Should my "average" PC be able to discern the potential of encountering a gelatinous cube from subtle clues?

Relatively new to DnD/TTRPGs. Playing a Barb with +0 to INT and -1 to WIS. I just realized that my party might be walking right into a gelatinous cube. What is considered "average" intelligence and ...
ToweringTrouble's user avatar
6 votes
2 answers
263 views

How aware is a character of the damage their spells/attacks deal?

Say a character casts two Fireballs at CL 10. The character aims at a field intentionally and hits nothing. Normally That'd be 10d6 damage. But in this scenario the first deals minimum damage (10) and ...
Balefire Liege's user avatar
57 votes
7 answers
10k views

As a DM, how to avoid unconscious metagaming when dealing with a high AC character?

In my previous campaign, a player started the campaign with a tanky fighter build with a chain mail, a shield, and Defense fighting style, for a total of 19 starting AC. For a level 1. I was still ...
Vylix's user avatar
  • 32.6k
34 votes
9 answers
8k views

How can I find out about the game world without meta-influencing it?

I'm a fairly new D&D player and as you can see from one of my other questions I'm attempting to play as spoiler free a game as possible. With this in mind I try and keep my reading about D&D ...
RyanfaeScotland's user avatar
25 votes
6 answers
28k views

How creative should the DM let an artificer be in terms of what they can build?

Just how creative should the DM let the Artificer be? One of my players is a guy who thinks way too hard on how to solve problems he's not meant to 'Solve' as a player. For example, I have a little ...
PyroTornado's user avatar
9 votes
3 answers
3k views

Will rerolling initiative each round stop meta-gaming about initiative?

I am thinking of implementing Speed Factor Initiative, but I don't really want to use all of it. Speed Factor Initiative "RAW" would work like this: Everyone must declare an action prior to rolling ...
SaggingRufus's user avatar
  • 4,313
41 votes
14 answers
8k views

How can I give a Ranger advantage on a check due to Favored Enemy without spoiling the story for the player?

The Scenario I am the DM for a group who have just entered a town that was attacked by cloud giants a few days before their arrival. The players and characters don't know this though, so part of the ...
BradenA8's user avatar
  • 2,824
40 votes
10 answers
6k views

How can I enjoy being a DM when I have an explorer personality?

I live in a small Finnish town with my wife and we want to play. But we cannot find any GMs there. So I decided to try to be GM myself. The problem is - I love to explore the worlds, story, monsters, ...
Dmitriy Repin's user avatar
58 votes
6 answers
9k views

I deciphered the meaning of a cryptic language out-of-game: should my character know what the meaning is?

I have just started my first D&D 5e campaign, and have encountered a seemingly mind-controlled bandit who keeps writing the same thing over and over on the wall. Our DM wrote out what it looks ...
Chris Cirefice's user avatar
5 votes
1 answer
357 views

Do ability scores force a character to act in a certain way? [duplicate]

As a group, most of the players at our table are fans of rolling for stats. This leads and has led to multiple amazing characters and some .. a bit less amazing. Something that is rather consistent ...
Patrick's user avatar
  • 217
68 votes
6 answers
11k views

If I run a game of Paranoia, will knowing the rules lead to a worse experience if/when I participate as a player in the future?

I received the boxed starter set of Paranoia for Christmas, and find myself in the classic dilemma of tabletop players everywhere: do I want to run this game, or try to find someone else to run it, so ...
Cooper's user avatar
  • 9,566
17 votes
4 answers
3k views

When do I tell my players when they're under an NPC's class effects that cause disadvantage on attacks?

There's a pretty good chance that my PCs will enter a team-battle tournament soon. One of the characters that they might fight has an ability that would give disadvantage to attack someone other than ...
A Joe of the Average Variety's user avatar
23 votes
6 answers
7k views

What to do with a player I have issues with due to metagaming?

I want to start this by saying that I am very new to D&D as a whole. This is my first campaign and I am playing a Lizardfolk paladin (it works in this story); the problem player is playing a gnome ...
Oxtrooo's user avatar
  • 498
22 votes
3 answers
4k views

Are casters aware of spell slots?

Players use spell slots as a meta concept to manage a character. For instance, Liz the Wizard gets so many spell slots at this level, and so many spell slots at that level. It says so right there in ...
Jack's user avatar
  • 32.1k
15 votes
3 answers
6k views

Was this “severe" metagaming or cheating per Adventurers League rules? [closed]

It is the night before our last session to finish Tomb of Annihilation. For the previous three sessions we had seen things in the tomb that gave us a clue to what creature we might face. [spoilers] ...
Praxiteles's user avatar
  • 11.9k
14 votes
3 answers
3k views

How to prevent metagame in betrayal/PvP scenarios?

Context/Research Often the metagaming problem is about how the DM presents the things to the players. We have lots of questions and good answers in the metagaming tag. Most of them are about ...
HellSaint's user avatar
  • 37k
2 votes
2 answers
1k views

Advice for dealing with a metagaming player. [closed]

This is my first post here, so bear with me. I've been running a dnd group with some friends over the past couple months. Doing some one off adventures to start but have lately been doing a full ...
Prootzy Zoots's user avatar
18 votes
2 answers
6k views

Do characters know if someone else, who they can see, has failed a saving throw?

Do characters know if someone else, who they can see, has failed a saving throw? In particular, let's consider the following cases: a caster has cast a spell, that requires a saving throw, and that ...
orcorco's user avatar
  • 1,349
5 votes
1 answer
2k views

If I overheal someone with Lay on Hands do the extra points return to my pool?

One of my player's asked me what happens if the number they choose for Lay on Hands is greater than the difference between the target's current and maximum HP. Will they will get refunded the ...
David Coffron's user avatar
117 votes
17 answers
18k views

How to prevent metagaming induced by trying to not metagame?

We have a lot of questions on how to prevent metagaming on this tag. But usually the metagaming is something like Using player's knowledge to optimize your character's actions. Now, I've ...
HellSaint's user avatar
  • 37k