Questions tagged [player-agency]
For questions about the players' essential ability to make choices, and take actions, that have a meaningful impact on the game world.
18
votes
7answers
2k views
Does asking a player to not to do something violate their agency?
This is something I am rather conflicted about as I have met with several gamemasters and I was told that asking players to not to have their character do something breaks their immersion and violates ...
14
votes
4answers
2k views
Is it feasible to let a newcomer play the “Gandalf”-like figure I created for my campaign?
I'm writing and DMing a campaign based around members of a nonprofit organization in a province of a decaying empire undergoing a civil war.
The premise
The player characters are new members of the ...
41
votes
11answers
6k views
How to roleplay my character's ethics according to the DM when I don't understand those ethics? [closed]
Recently in a Pathfinder campaign I encountered the following in a combat situation, after our group made an ambush on a castle inhabited by a small Gnoll clan. Our group clearly had the upper hand ...
62
votes
7answers
10k views
Is it a violation of my player agency if another player is allowed to wish away memories from my character?
A situation occurred in a recent game in which one PC ended up in control of a being of power from the outer planes via their true name.
The being confirmed that they would attempt to "slip the ...
6
votes
2answers
281 views
Encouraging piety in classes besides Paladin/Cleric [closed]
As a DM who has almost always played with inexperienced or casual players, I find many or most of those players trend towards homogeneity. They choose a patron deity and alignment when they roll up, ...
38
votes
7answers
8k views
How can I, as DM, dictate the emotions and actions of the players (magically)?
(Some of) my players are trying to role play in a meta-gaming sort of way.
For instance, I had an array of weapons in a dungeon, and when they took them, they had to make a Wisdom saving throw, else ...
23
votes
5answers
3k views
How do I keep a published adventure playthrough “on rails” without removing player agency? [duplicate]
Split from: How do I deal with players who make friends with goblins?
I want to run a campaign "from the book" for a group of new players (played RPGs before, but stuff much much lighter then D&D,...
9
votes
5answers
292 views
Does skipping an ability check for a hazard needed to advance the dungeon remove player agency?
I'm currently running a sort of mega-dungeon made of other dungeons cobbled together. I know most of my players browse here frequently so I'll keep the description brief.
At the end of the current ...
13
votes
3answers
1k views
How can I run the Orolunga ziggurat pyramid challenge with a little more player agency?
I'm running the Tomb of Annihilation adventure, and my players are about to come to Orolunga.
There's a particular "gateway" challenge there:
The text says "It might help to think of the whole ...
46
votes
6answers
7k views
NPC casting Suggestion on PC: who decides it's reasonable?
A simple scenario:
The DM wishes to break a cleric's concentration on their bless spell, and a foe uses suggestion to tell the cleric to cast silence on an enemy spellcaster. The rationale is that ...
12
votes
3answers
975 views
Should I request an ability check only when the player asks for it?
I am struggling with something in my sessions: should I ask for an ability check only if the player attempts to do something?
For example, the players stumble upon a stone door with some symbols on ...
22
votes
6answers
6k views
How can I politely explain to a DM that removing player agency is usually bad?
Playing D&D 5e.
I asked a similar question on reddit, so I will copy the summary of events from there:
Okay; I admit that part of what I am about to say is fairly absurd,
because we do ...
8
votes
3answers
451 views
Running an Unstructured Narrative
What measures and pitfall should I consider when running an especially unstructured narrative in Pathfinder?
In the campaign I am running that has started recently, I am attempting to run a fairly "...
32
votes
5answers
3k views
How can I narrate Charm/Fear/Rage/etc effects in a liberating manner?
Or, How can I implement behavior-centric status effects without giving the players a sense of having lost their autonomy?
It's something I have found to be a personal agitant as a roleplayer, and ...
7
votes
1answer
459 views
How can I deal with a DM I feel is over-exerting control over our characters?
I play AD&D 2e and we rotate DM's every few months. Each one runs a different campaign. When we reach a good point we pause one campaign and switch to another and eventually come back to the ...
12
votes
2answers
522 views
How do I add player agency to a canned adventure?
Our current GM is going to be out of town for a few weeks, so I have decided to try my hand at GMing our group using the We Be Goblins module from Pathfinder. The module is short and has good reviews ...
23
votes
4answers
4k views
How do I get my players to be more decisive and take the initiative?
I've been running HotDQ with a group of people for about 9 months now (about 20 sessions; we're on Ep 6.)
My current frustration is that things go along OK as long as I'm narrating and asking ...
2
votes
2answers
433 views
How much should I limit a plot-driving GM 'avatar'?
I am GM for a group of (mostly) new Pathfinder players who are extremely off-the-rails in their approach. This is fun, but made it nearly impossible to prepare for a session — they are as likely to ...
13
votes
8answers
3k views
How do I handle a PC who likes to move allies out of danger during his turn?
I have a player who loves to just grab other PCs or NPCs to get them out of danger in the middle of combat. He's got the highest DEX mod in the party so he's usually at the top of the initiative ...
26
votes
6answers
19k views
How much of a hindrance should my cleric's low intelligence score be?
I'm playing D&D 5e with a group of friends, and for most of us (me included) it is our first time. We rolled for ability scores, and as luck would have it, on one of my rolls I got all ones (which ...
72
votes
11answers
11k views
Is saying “Your PC wouldn't do that” to a player denying their agency?
In a comment to my answer to What would be the side effects on a Druid of wearing metal armor?, @Kevin asked:
"So, RAW a druid will never choose to wear metal armor or use metal shields, so the ...
65
votes
3answers
21k views
What is Player Agency and what is it good for?
Agency, specifically player agency, is a term that frequently comes up as a reason for why a particular rule or GM decision is better than another. How is agency defined in this context and why is it ...
80
votes
14answers
9k views
How do I keep the game moving without undermining player agency?
In basically every game I've run or played, regardless of the system, I've encountered the same problem: things that should be quick decisions end up taking ten, twenty or even thirty minutes, and not ...
