Skip to main content
forgot to finish a sentence, adding a tangent
Source Link
KRyan
  • 360.6k
  • 59
  • 942
  • 1.5k

Rolls basically come in three flavors: “rolls” (e.g. attack, damage), “checks” (e.g. ability score checks, skill checks), and “throws” (i.e. saving throws). A circlet of persuasion only applies to the “checks,” and not to “rolls” or “throws.” And it certainly does not apply to anything based on Charisma that doesn’t involve rolling a die, like for example a sorcerer’s bonus spells or save DCs. Basically, you need to see the word “check” somewhere if you want it to apply.

But it does apply to all checks involving Charisma, rather than only ability score checks. The wording for that would be a “bonus to Charisma checks” rather than a “bonus to Charisma-based checks.” So yes, it does apply to skills and some other things.

Major examples:

  • Ability score checks, e.g. the Charisma check made during planar binding

  • Skill checks, e.g. Perform or Use Magic Device

  • Concentration checks, e.g. for a sorcerer

Major examples that are not checks:

  • Non-dice-based things, like bonus spells for a sorcerer or AC for an oracle with the nature’s whisper revelation

  • Attack rolls, e.g. with smite

    • Note that performing a combat maneuver involves rolling “an attack roll and add your CMB in place of your normal attack bonus,” so it

      Note that performing a combat maneuver involves rolling “an attack roll and add your CMB in place of your normal attack bonus,” so it also does not count.

    • Completely tangential, but while we’re here: Whether or not a situation like smite, where you add both Strength and Charisma, would count as a “Charisma-based roll” is very unclear. There are very few situations where this comes up, but if it ever does I would almost-certainly count it, myself. As far as circlet of persuasion is concerned, the question is moot because whether it’s “Charisma-based” or not, it certainly isn’t a “check.”

  • Damage rolls, e.g. with Desna’s Divine Fighting Technique and a starknife

  • Saving throws, e.g. with divine grace

Rolls basically come in three flavors: “rolls” (e.g. attack, damage), “checks” (e.g. ability score checks, skill checks), and “throws” (i.e. saving throws). A circlet of persuasion only applies to the “checks,” and not to “rolls” or “throws.” And it certainly does not apply to anything based on Charisma that doesn’t involve rolling a die, like for example a sorcerer’s bonus spells or save DCs. Basically, you need to see the word “check” somewhere if you want it to apply.

But it does apply to all checks involving Charisma, rather than only ability score checks. The wording for that would be a “bonus to Charisma checks” rather than a “bonus to Charisma-based checks.” So yes, it does apply to skills and some other things.

Major examples:

  • Ability score checks, e.g. the Charisma check made during planar binding

  • Skill checks, e.g. Perform or Use Magic Device

  • Concentration checks, e.g. for a sorcerer

Major examples that are not checks:

  • Non-dice-based things, like bonus spells for a sorcerer or AC for an oracle with the nature’s whisper revelation

  • Attack rolls, e.g. with smite

    • Note that performing a combat maneuver involves rolling “an attack roll and add your CMB in place of your normal attack bonus,” so it
  • Damage rolls, e.g. with Desna’s Divine Fighting Technique and a starknife

  • Saving throws, e.g. with divine grace

Rolls basically come in three flavors: “rolls” (e.g. attack, damage), “checks” (e.g. ability score checks, skill checks), and “throws” (i.e. saving throws). A circlet of persuasion only applies to the “checks,” and not to “rolls” or “throws.” And it certainly does not apply to anything based on Charisma that doesn’t involve rolling a die, like for example a sorcerer’s bonus spells or save DCs. Basically, you need to see the word “check” somewhere if you want it to apply.

But it does apply to all checks involving Charisma, rather than only ability score checks. The wording for that would be a “bonus to Charisma checks” rather than a “bonus to Charisma-based checks.” So yes, it does apply to skills and some other things.

Major examples:

  • Ability score checks, e.g. the Charisma check made during planar binding

  • Skill checks, e.g. Perform or Use Magic Device

  • Concentration checks, e.g. for a sorcerer

Major examples that are not checks:

  • Non-dice-based things, like bonus spells for a sorcerer or AC for an oracle with the nature’s whisper revelation

  • Attack rolls, e.g. with smite

    • Note that performing a combat maneuver involves rolling “an attack roll and add your CMB in place of your normal attack bonus,” so it also does not count.

    • Completely tangential, but while we’re here: Whether or not a situation like smite, where you add both Strength and Charisma, would count as a “Charisma-based roll” is very unclear. There are very few situations where this comes up, but if it ever does I would almost-certainly count it, myself. As far as circlet of persuasion is concerned, the question is moot because whether it’s “Charisma-based” or not, it certainly isn’t a “check.”

  • Damage rolls, e.g. with Desna’s Divine Fighting Technique and a starknife

  • Saving throws, e.g. with divine grace

covering why it isn’t just Charisma checks
Source Link
KRyan
  • 360.6k
  • 59
  • 942
  • 1.5k

Rolls basically come in three flavors: “rolls” (e.g. attack, damage), “checks” (e.g. ability score checks, skill checks), and “throws” (i.e. saving throws). A *circlet of persuasioncirclet of persuasion only applies to the “checks,” and not to “rolls” or “throws.” And it certainly does not apply to anything based on Charisma that doesn’t involve rolling a die, like for example a sorcerer’s bonus spells or save DCs. Basically, you need to see the word “check” somewhere if you want it to apply.

But it does apply to all checks involving Charisma, rather than only ability score checks. The wording for that would be a “bonus to Charisma checks” rather than a “bonus to Charisma-based checks.” So yes, it does apply to skills and some other things.

Major examples:

  • Ability score checks, e.g. the Charisma check made during planar binding

  • Skill checks, e.g. Perform or Use Magic Device

  • Concentration checks, e.g. for a sorcerer

Major examples that are not checks:

  • Non-dice-based things, like bonus spells for a sorcerer or AC for an oracle with the nature’s whisper revelation

  • Attack rolls, e.g. with smite

    • Note that performing a combat maneuver involves rolling “an attack roll and add your CMB in place of your normal attack bonus,” so it
  • Damage rolls, e.g. with Desna’s Divine Fighting Technique and a starknife

  • Saving throws, e.g. with divine grace

Rolls basically come in three flavors: “rolls” (e.g. attack, damage), “checks” (e.g. ability score checks, skill checks), and “throws” (i.e. saving throws). A *circlet of persuasion only applies to the “checks,” and not to “rolls” or “throws.” And it certainly does not apply to anything based on Charisma that doesn’t involve rolling a die, like for example a sorcerer’s bonus spells or save DCs. Basically, you need to see the word “check” somewhere if you want it to apply.

Major examples:

  • Ability score checks, e.g. the Charisma check made during planar binding

  • Skill checks, e.g. Perform or Use Magic Device

  • Concentration checks, e.g. for a sorcerer

Major examples that are not checks:

  • Non-dice-based things, like bonus spells

  • Attack rolls, e.g. with smite

  • Damage rolls, e.g. with Desna’s Divine Fighting Technique and a starknife

  • Saving throws, e.g. with divine grace

Rolls basically come in three flavors: “rolls” (e.g. attack, damage), “checks” (e.g. ability score checks, skill checks), and “throws” (i.e. saving throws). A circlet of persuasion only applies to the “checks,” and not to “rolls” or “throws.” And it certainly does not apply to anything based on Charisma that doesn’t involve rolling a die, like for example a sorcerer’s bonus spells or save DCs. Basically, you need to see the word “check” somewhere if you want it to apply.

But it does apply to all checks involving Charisma, rather than only ability score checks. The wording for that would be a “bonus to Charisma checks” rather than a “bonus to Charisma-based checks.” So yes, it does apply to skills and some other things.

Major examples:

  • Ability score checks, e.g. the Charisma check made during planar binding

  • Skill checks, e.g. Perform or Use Magic Device

  • Concentration checks, e.g. for a sorcerer

Major examples that are not checks:

  • Non-dice-based things, like bonus spells for a sorcerer or AC for an oracle with the nature’s whisper revelation

  • Attack rolls, e.g. with smite

    • Note that performing a combat maneuver involves rolling “an attack roll and add your CMB in place of your normal attack bonus,” so it
  • Damage rolls, e.g. with Desna’s Divine Fighting Technique and a starknife

  • Saving throws, e.g. with divine grace

Source Link
KRyan
  • 360.6k
  • 59
  • 942
  • 1.5k

Rolls basically come in three flavors: “rolls” (e.g. attack, damage), “checks” (e.g. ability score checks, skill checks), and “throws” (i.e. saving throws). A *circlet of persuasion only applies to the “checks,” and not to “rolls” or “throws.” And it certainly does not apply to anything based on Charisma that doesn’t involve rolling a die, like for example a sorcerer’s bonus spells or save DCs. Basically, you need to see the word “check” somewhere if you want it to apply.

Major examples:

  • Ability score checks, e.g. the Charisma check made during planar binding

  • Skill checks, e.g. Perform or Use Magic Device

  • Concentration checks, e.g. for a sorcerer

Major examples that are not checks:

  • Non-dice-based things, like bonus spells

  • Attack rolls, e.g. with smite

  • Damage rolls, e.g. with Desna’s Divine Fighting Technique and a starknife

  • Saving throws, e.g. with divine grace