Skip to main content
minor copyediting
Source Link
V2Blast
  • 50.3k
  • 10
  • 223
  • 306

You shouldn't necessarily roll out that interaction,interaction; you'd just make a judgement call.: "Is it possible for a rat to threaten this commoner in this scene?"

If it's just some random scene, then the answer is probably no and the commoner would just shoo away the rat.

If its an encounter with some player characters and it's like "the pcs, "The PCs get attacked by feral rats! And there's a peasant that might get eaten"eaten," you might roll it out. More likely you'd just narrate something like "the, "The peasant fallfalls to the floor in a panic,panic; the rats tear into him viciously, and his screams are cut short. The rats stream from his body, bloodied and shaking in madness. They move towards you. Roll initiative."

Basically d&d, D&D, especially d&dD&D fifth edition, doesn't really simulate a setting. Setting is tertiary to d&d,D&D; the most important aspects are mechanics and after that atmosphere.

HP is mostly for the player characters. A commoner have 4hphas 4 hp because that is roughly how difficult it is for a pcPC to knock them out or kill them.

Even then, note that is just a default commoner, iei.e. a random extra. In a movie, it wouldn't even be a guard that the pcsPCs take down,down; it'd be a random civilian they knock out in a scene, drag into an alley and then steal their clothes so they can, I dunno, do what they need to do. If you had a peasant npcNPC in your campaign that you wanted to be a reoccurring npcNPC, you might not even bother with stats,stats; you'd just wing it if the pcsPCs tried something. "Alfredo the peasant screamscreams and diedies as you run a sword troughthrough his gut. Cause he's a civilian and you are a soldier. Ok, now what do you do with the body?"

You shouldn't necessarily roll out that interaction, you'd just make a judgement call. "Is it possible for a rat to threaten this commoner in this scene?"

If it's just some random scene then the answer is probably no and the commoner would just shoo away the rat.

If its an encounter with some player characters and it's like "the pcs get attacked by feral rats! And there's a peasant that might get eaten" you might roll it out. More likely you'd just narrate something like "the peasant fall to the floor in a panic, the rats tear into him viciously, his screams are cut short. The rats stream from his body, bloodied and shaking in madness. They move towards you. Roll initiative."

Basically d&d, especially d&d fifth edition doesn't really simulate a setting. Setting is tertiary to d&d, the most important aspects are mechanics and after that atmosphere.

HP is mostly for the player characters. A commoner have 4hp because that is roughly how difficult it is for a pc to knock them out or kill them.

Even then note that is just a default commoner, ie a random extra. In a movie it wouldn't even be a guard the pcs take down, it'd be a random civilian they knock out in a scene, drag into an alley and then steal their clothes so they can I dunno, do what they need to do. If you had peasant npc in your campaign you wanted to be a reoccurring npc you might not even bother with stats, you'd just wing it if the pcs tried something. "Alfredo the peasant scream and die as you run a sword trough his gut. Cause he's a civilian and you are a soldier. Ok what do you do with the body?"

You shouldn't necessarily roll out that interaction; you'd just make a judgement call: "Is it possible for a rat to threaten this commoner in this scene?"

If it's just some random scene, then the answer is probably no and the commoner would just shoo away the rat.

If its an encounter with some player characters and it's like, "The PCs get attacked by feral rats! And there's a peasant that might get eaten," you might roll it out. More likely you'd just narrate something like, "The peasant falls to the floor in a panic; the rats tear into him viciously, and his screams are cut short. The rats stream from his body, bloodied and shaking in madness. They move towards you. Roll initiative."

Basically, D&D, especially D&D fifth edition, doesn't really simulate a setting. Setting is tertiary to D&D; the most important aspects are mechanics and after that atmosphere.

HP is mostly for the player characters. A commoner has 4 hp because that is roughly how difficult it is for a PC to knock them out or kill them.

Even then, note that is just a default commoner, i.e. a random extra. In a movie, it wouldn't even be a guard that the PCs take down; it'd be a random civilian they knock out in a scene, drag into an alley and then steal their clothes so they can, I dunno, do what they need to do. If you had a peasant NPC in your campaign that you wanted to be a reoccurring NPC, you might not even bother with stats; you'd just wing it if the PCs tried something. "Alfredo the peasant screams and dies as you run a sword through his gut. Cause he's a civilian and you are a soldier. Ok, now what do you do with the body?"

Source Link
user59614
  • 448
  • 2
  • 5

You shouldn't necessarily roll out that interaction, you'd just make a judgement call. "Is it possible for a rat to threaten this commoner in this scene?"

If it's just some random scene then the answer is probably no and the commoner would just shoo away the rat.

If its an encounter with some player characters and it's like "the pcs get attacked by feral rats! And there's a peasant that might get eaten" you might roll it out. More likely you'd just narrate something like "the peasant fall to the floor in a panic, the rats tear into him viciously, his screams are cut short. The rats stream from his body, bloodied and shaking in madness. They move towards you. Roll initiative."

Basically d&d, especially d&d fifth edition doesn't really simulate a setting. Setting is tertiary to d&d, the most important aspects are mechanics and after that atmosphere.

HP is mostly for the player characters. A commoner have 4hp because that is roughly how difficult it is for a pc to knock them out or kill them.

Even then note that is just a default commoner, ie a random extra. In a movie it wouldn't even be a guard the pcs take down, it'd be a random civilian they knock out in a scene, drag into an alley and then steal their clothes so they can I dunno, do what they need to do. If you had peasant npc in your campaign you wanted to be a reoccurring npc you might not even bother with stats, you'd just wing it if the pcs tried something. "Alfredo the peasant scream and die as you run a sword trough his gut. Cause he's a civilian and you are a soldier. Ok what do you do with the body?"