Skip to main content
removed link to SRD-violating site; added DNDBeyond link and page number; replaced Roll20 link with DNDBeyond link for consistency; clarified wording; edited tags
Source Link
V2Blast
  • 50.3k
  • 10
  • 223
  • 306

Are material components with unique conditions ones we can replaceattributes unable to be replaced with a component pouch or spellcasting focus?

BanishmentBanishment requires a specific material component:

Anan item distasteful to the target

So does Summon Greater Demonsummon greater demon (XGtE, p. 166):

Viala vial of blood from a humanoid killed inwithin the past 24hrs24 hours

I thought I had seen this question here before, but I couldn't find it to double-check, so I'm asking again.

Are these components with unique conditionsattributes assumed to have a cost? Or can they be replaced by a component pouch or arcane focus?

My interpretation is that costcost isn't just gold, - it is any sort of condition on the item (so, distasteful items or blood with timer requirements have a cost). Therefore, both these spells would require specific components to be cast. Is my interpretation correct?

Are components with unique conditions ones we can replace with a component pouch or focus?

Banishment requires a specific component

An item distasteful to the target

So does Summon Greater Demon

Vial of blood from humanoid killed in past 24hrs

I thought I had seen this question here before, but I couldn't find it to double-check, so I'm asking again.

Are these components with unique conditions assumed to have a cost? Or can they be replaced by a component pouch or arcane focus?

My interpretation is that cost isn't just gold, it is any sort of condition on the item (so, distasteful items or blood with timer requirements have a cost). Therefore, both these spells would require specific components to be cast. Is my interpretation correct?

Are material components with unique attributes unable to be replaced with a component pouch or spellcasting focus?

Banishment requires a specific material component:

an item distasteful to the target

So does summon greater demon (XGtE, p. 166):

a vial of blood from a humanoid killed within the past 24 hours

I thought I had seen this question here before, but I couldn't find it to double-check, so I'm asking again.

Are these components with unique attributes assumed to have a cost? Or can they be replaced by a component pouch or arcane focus?

My interpretation is that cost isn't just gold - it is any sort of condition on the item (so, distasteful items or blood with timer requirements have a cost). Therefore, both these spells would require specific components to be cast. Is my interpretation correct?

edited title
Link
doppelgreener
  • 36.6k
  • 16
  • 162
  • 255

Is Are components with unique conditions ones we can replace with a component cost just gold,pouch or can it be any sort of requirementfocus?

added 33 characters in body
Source Link
BlueMoon93
  • 47k
  • 34
  • 201
  • 319

Banishment requires a specific component

An item distasteful to the target

So does Summon Greater Demon

Vial of blood from humanoid killed in past 24hrs

I thought I had seen this question here before, but I couldn't find it to double-check, so I'm asking again.

Can specificAre these components with unique conditions be replaced byassumed to have a component pouch or arcane focuscost? Or can they be replaced by a component pouch or arcane focus?

My interpretation is that cost isn't just gold, it is any sort of condition on the item (so, distasteful items or blood with timer requirements have a cost). Therefore, both these spells would require specific components to be cast. Is my interpretation correct?

Banishment requires a specific component

An item distasteful to the target

So does Summon Greater Demon

Vial of blood from humanoid killed in past 24hrs

I thought I had seen this question here before, but I couldn't find it to double-check, so I'm asking again.

Can specific components with unique conditions be replaced by a component pouch or arcane focus?

My interpretation is that cost isn't just gold, it is any sort of condition on the item (so, distasteful items or blood with timer requirements have a cost). Therefore, both these spells would require specific components to be cast. Is my interpretation correct?

Banishment requires a specific component

An item distasteful to the target

So does Summon Greater Demon

Vial of blood from humanoid killed in past 24hrs

I thought I had seen this question here before, but I couldn't find it to double-check, so I'm asking again.

Are these components with unique conditions assumed to have a cost? Or can they be replaced by a component pouch or arcane focus?

My interpretation is that cost isn't just gold, it is any sort of condition on the item (so, distasteful items or blood with timer requirements have a cost). Therefore, both these spells would require specific components to be cast. Is my interpretation correct?

added 23 characters in body
Source Link
linksassin
  • 31.1k
  • 7
  • 127
  • 213
Loading
added 7 characters in body
Source Link
BlueMoon93
  • 47k
  • 34
  • 201
  • 319
Loading
Source Link
BlueMoon93
  • 47k
  • 34
  • 201
  • 319
Loading