7
\$\begingroup\$

I am trying to turn the 3.5e SRD's degrees-of-turn-per-feet-of-game-movement numbers (such as 45 degrees of turn per 5' of movement with 45 degrees of maximum turn per square for a creature classed with poor flight maneuverability) into an actual minimum possible turn radius for a flying creature; however, I cannot figure out from the SRD text on the topic whether this figure is supposed to be interpreted as 45 degrees of turn between two points 5 feet apart, 45 degrees of turn over 5' of along-track movement by the creature, or flying 5' and then turning 45 degrees about a point.

Apparently, all the SRD has to say about the figures in question in the table is:

Turn

How much the creature can turn after covering the stated distance.

Maximum Turn

How much the creature can turn in any one space.

The DMG says the same, and the PHB doesn't have anything more to add. Where can I find more detailed information about how flight maneuverability works on the grid?

\$\endgroup\$
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ @KRyan What's the link to your house rules for flying again? \$\endgroup\$ – Hey I Can Chan Jul 31 '15 at 11:59
16
\$\begingroup\$

I think Shalvenay's answer from the Draconomicon is the only official answer you're going to get, and it may well be good enough for your purposes. But, I feel like giving an alternative answer anyway, based on the SRD and applied to all levels of manoeuvrability.

Turning Rules

Here is the relevant SRD text (with one more entry than the question included), followed by my expanded explanations. Comments on Perfect manoeuvrability are excluded, because Perfect fliers have no turning restrictions whatsoever.

Turn

How much the creature can turn after covering the stated distance.

To turn while moving forwards, a creature needs to move forwards a certain distance (10 ft. for Clumsy fliers, 5 ft. otherwise). They can then add a turn to their movement for no additional movement cost (90° for Good fliers, 45° otherwise)

Turn in Place

A creature with good or average maneuverability can use some of its speed to turn in place.

At a cost of 5 ft. of movement speed, Good fliers can turn 90° without needing to move out of their square at all; Average fliers can only do 45° for the same cost.

Maximum Turn

How much the creature can turn in any one space.

Related to the above. Good fliers are able to hover, and so their ability to turn in place is only limited by their movement speed. Average fliers are limited to a 90° turn in place (two 45° turns, at a cost of 10 ft. of movement), and will have to move forwards at least a little bit before they can turn again. Also, since they can't hover, they have to have maintained their minimum forward speed once all their turning is done, or else fall out of the sky.

Presumably, this turning limitation applies whether the first 45° was a turn after movement or a turn in place. This would be why Poor and Clumsy fliers are limited to 45° in one space: that's how much they're allowed to turn after movement, and they can't add a turn-in-place to that.

So, conclusions from the above rules...

Perfect

Perfect manoeuvrability has no RAW limitations on turning. You can do a 1080° spin in your square for zero movement cost, if you want to.

Hence, the Perfect turning radius is 0 ft.

Good

At a cost of 5 ft. of movement for every 90°, a creature with Good manoeuvrability can complete an otherwise unlimited turn in place, giving them a turning radius of 0 ft.

If moving forwards instead of hovering (i.e. not using turn in place at all), they can turn sharply enough to do a complete 360° in four squares, making their turn radius 5 ft. in that case.

Average

The tightest turn a creature with Average manoeuvrability can manage is a series of 45° turns in place, 5 ft. forwards movements, and 45° turns. (This also guarantees that they'll maintain their minimum forward speed, since it's 5 ft. of genuine movement for every 5 ft. of "lost" movement.)

Hence, they can manage a 90° turn for every 5 ft. of forwards movement, just like Good fliers, but at a total cost of 10 ft. of movement speed; their turn radius is 5 ft.

Without turn in place, an Average flier is reduced to exactly the same turning options as a Poor flier; see below.

Poor

A creature with Poor manoeuvrability cannot turn in place at all. For every 5 ft. of forwards movement, they can turn 45°, allowing them to do a complete 360° in a space 20 ft. wide: a turning radius of 10 ft.

Clumsy

Creatures with Clumsy manoeuvrability turn like those with Poor manoeuvrability, except that they need 10 ft. of forwards movement instead of 5 ft. They can manage to turn a complete 360° in a space 35 ft. wide, for a turning radius of 17.5 ft.

I was concerned that the intricacies of diagonal movement might have affected that answer (because one diagonal movement might have been 10 ft. in one square, allowing them to stop moving diagonally sooner), but it turns out that it doesn't--as long as we assume that they start with their "diagonal movement counter" at zero, so their first diagonal only costs 5 ft.

Diagram

Here's a picture:

Turning circles according to the rules

Key:

  • Black arrows are forwards movement combined with a free turn.
  • Red arrows are turns in place.
  • Numbers give the movement cost of the adjacent arrow.
  • Asterisks mark diagonal movements.
  • Circled letters give the manoeuvrability shown by each loop: Clumsy, Poor, Average, or Good (with and without turns in place).
  • For Perfect manoeuvrability, just picture a whirlwind of red arrows.
\$\endgroup\$
6
\$\begingroup\$

It turns out that the diagram from p.61 of the Draconomicon provides the answer to this question:

Flight maneuvering diagram from p.61 of the Draconomicon

\$\endgroup\$
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Is that the entire diagram, or does it have other levels of manoeuvrability listed? \$\endgroup\$ – Tim Pederick Jul 31 '15 at 4:26
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ There may be a diagram on another page that depicts worse maneuverability levels, I'd have to dig it up though... \$\endgroup\$ – Shalvenay Jul 31 '15 at 11:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.