Is this homebrew variant of True Strike too strong to be a cantrip?

Question

Here is my homebrew variant of the true strike cantrip:

Lethal Strike

Enchantment cantrip

Components: V, S
Casting Time: 1 bonus action
Range: Self
Duration: Until the end of the current turn

When you roll a 19 on a weapon attack, that attack is also a critical hit, then this spell ends.

This spell is brewed for my players' Arcane Trickster, who would like a combat cantrip that will enhance his Sneak Attack. He does not like true strike because it wastes one full turn before he can attack, so I made this one require a bonus action instead.

I'm worried that making it require a bonus action instead of an action will make this overpowered.

Is this homebrew spell overpowered as a cantrip? If yes, what is the suggested spell level for this? What can be modified so this can stay as a cantrip?

Answer 1

It's about on par with Green-Flame Blade, a spell published in the Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide (at least for characters with only one attack).

Lethal Strike's expected bonus damage for a sneak attacking level 3 rogue is 0.575 damage (5% * 1d8+2d6 (11.5) = 0.575), considerably less than Green Flame Blade, which deals damage equal to the caster's ability score modifier (we'll say 1-3, since the rogue casting it most likely has a decent Int score), albeit to a second target in melee range.

I'd counter the argument that others have made about it being zero cost to cast this. Rogues have a huge number of uses for a bonus action, and this is competing with all of them. For example, if the character were instead dual wielding short swords, rather than using lethal strike with a rapier, as above, their damage instead increases by 1d6-1 or 2.5 * 1.05 = 2.625 (-1 from going from d8 to d6 on their main hand attack, with a 5% crit chance), assuming they hit with both attacks.

All that aside, your duration doesn't fit with other published spells. Every spell I'm aware of that buffs the next attack is written with the following duration:

Duration: Concentration, Up to 1 round

As long as the only character to ever get this spell is this rogue, I don't really see a huge problem with it. If a character with a less crowded bonus action economy learned it, however, it could be problematic.

---

Answer 2

This is too weak to be a cantrip

Just like with Green Flame Blade, you can't use Two Weapon Fighting. Unlike GFB, the DPR increase is small.

Assumptions:

• Start with Dex 16
• Increase at levels 4 and 8
• 65% hit chance
• GFB's secondary damage is calculated as half¹

[DPR-Level] chart, with the 3 possibilities: Two-Weapon Fighting (TWF) Green-Flame Blade (GFB) and Lethal Strike (LethalS):

As clearly visible from this graph, Lethal Strike is strictly weaker than simply Two-Weapon Fighting.

It can be combined with GFB, but even than it is marginal, while the combination takes up at least half of a Trickster's cantrips.

---

1) Spreading the damage is less effective than concentrating it on one target, and there might not even be a legit secondary target in range.

Answer 3

In isolation, it's fine...

Compared to the Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide weapon cantrips - Green-Flame Blade, Booming Blade, etc. - I don't find it to be terribly powerful. The can-stab-trips all deal guaranteed extra damage on a hit (scaling by tier) of an elemental type (which may trigger vulnerabilities or other effects, like fire vs. some regenerators). Your cantrip has a 1 in 20 chance (only when a 19 is rolled) of adding damage, and for most casters that damage does not scale.

... and for an Arcane Trickster, it's even better but still not overwhelming...

In the hands of an Arcane Trickster, the additional damage from a critical hit scales, but it's infrequent enough (again 1 in 20) to be equivalent or perhaps even worse than getting bonus damage on every hit. An additional downside for the rogue is the verbal component. Without the benefit of a Sorcerer's Subtle Spell, casting a spell is a loud process. If one uses this spell before attacking, one is no longer hidden. If the rogue has some other way to get Sneak Attack, so be it.

...but you have to be wary of unintended synergy.

A character with True Strike and Lethal Strike could cast True Strike on one turn, then Lethal Strike and attack on the next. Advantage and increased threat range without any real expenditure of resources is a bit much. And in the hands of a Rogue, the ability to build in advantage and an extended critical range is too much.

Answer 4

For a single-classed Arcane Trickster, it's fine.

The Bonus Action is pretty valuable for a Rogue of any type, and using their Bonus Action to cast this cantrip instead means they're not

• Hideing to gain advantage (or to avoid damage)
• Attacking with an off-hand weapon to improve the odds of landing their Sneak Attack
• Moving their Mage Hand

Or any of a number of other things they might prefer to be doing on this turn.

Meanwhile, gaining an extra Crit on a 19 only adds about 4-10% damage to your hit, depending on your level and the AC of your target, as shown by this table I generated of DPR values:

Level	Normal AC0	Normal AC14	Normal AC20	LS AC0	LS AC14	LS AC20
1	10.850	7.000	3.700	11.250	7.400	4.100
3	14.350	9.275	4.925	14.925	9.850	5.500
5	18.800	14.050	8.350	19.550	14.800	9.100
7	22.300	16.675	9.925	23.225	17.600	10.850
9	26.750	22.700	14.600	27.850	23.800	15.700
11	30.250	25.675	16.525	31.525	26.950	17.800
13	33.750	30.350	20.150	35.200	31.800	21.600
15	37.250	33.500	22.250	38.875	35.125	23.875
17	40.750	38.700	26.400	42.550	40.500	28.200
19	44.250	42.025	28.675	46.225	44.000	30.650

^{Rogue starts with 16 Dexterity, only takes Dexterity ASIs until they reach 20, fights with a non-magical Rapier as their Finesse weapon.}

The Full Stats for this character can be found here: https://gist.github.com/Xirema/01a95b6a1994afaa39ecb610ff363d9f

What's important is that Lethal Strike does increase DPR, especially against high-AC characters, but it's still a pretty marginal gain. Hideing to gain advantage will usually result in a higher DPR gain than by using this Cantrip. So if they already have a source of Advantage, or otherwise just want those sweet sweet crits, this will help them do that without completely overpowering the character.

Answer 5

Doubling your crit chance with a bonus action that doesn't waste other resources is unbalanced.

A possible solution is to make this spell level 1. However, being level makes it too weak, IMO...

I think you can tweak this a bit (make it have a duration, like a full Round, but cost a level), but being a cantrip seems too strong for me. If you follow the idea of having a 1 round duration, it means you benefit with this on attacks, reactions, Hasted actions, etc. Might be worthy then.

Answer 6

Too strong as cantrip; weak as leveled spell

It's too strong as a cantrip. However, it's also too weak for a first level spell. The reason it's too strong as a cantrip is because there's really no reason not to use it.

Rogues have more things to do with their bonus actions than most classes, but unless you really need to hide or dash, there's literally no reason not to use this cantrip to double your chances to crit, which is stepping on the fighter's toes a bit, because one of their archetypes has that as an ability.

Once you make it a first level spell however, it becomes far too weak, because it's not really worth a spell slot to have a 5% higher chance of critting. The only reason it's too strong as a cantrip is because it doesn't cost you anything, and there's no real reason not to use it. Once it costs spell slots, it's not worth it.

I don't think there is any real way to salvage the spell to make it cantrip worthy.

On bonus action costs

A lot of other answers are pointing out that the cost "isn't next to nothing" because you could be using an off-hand attack, but in all seriousness, what Arcane Trickster is ever going to be using an off-hand attack? You are far more likely to be using Green-Flame Blade or Booming Blade as a cantrip, which means you can't use an off-hand attack.

You can, however, use Lethal Strike and then Booming Blade or Green-Flame Blade.

If you are using the optional flanking rules it'd be fairly trivial to get advantage and double crit chance on a Booming Blade or Green-Flame Blade attack.