Questions tagged [railroading]
For questions about running games (or elements thereof) with pre-determined outcomes, including how to avoid its negative implications and how to do it well.
33 questions
2
votes
2
answers
822
views
How to handle a party's bad choices? [closed]
Not too long ago I started a campaign in Pathfinder 2e, and at a certain point I hinted at an enemy group's location and (superior) strength, while telling the party to go somewhere else and complete ...
- 2,427
6
votes
2
answers
312
views
Origin of Illusionism?
Now and then, I've seen people use the term 'Illusionism', used for describing a kind of railroad, such as in this answer and elsewhere. I'd like to learn the origin of Illusionism, both in the sense ...
17
votes
12
answers
8k
views
How to set up a "Forced choice" for players in a game?
I have come up with a plot twist to create a "wrong person, wrong place, wrong time" situation. That part is important, and I don't want to change it. However this obviously causes a potential ...
- 23.2k
19
votes
2
answers
906
views
How do I encourage my GM to relax her grip on the story and let the players have some free will?
I've been playing a number of different games with the same core group of friends for years now. We meet once a week with the occasional exception.
For the last few months, one of our players has ...
- 433
4
votes
0
answers
432
views
How to deal with DM that railroads you, and then says you skipped things? [closed]
Mid-campaign we approached a building, and then the DM railroaded us into a certain side room, says that we barged in, and the guards in the room shouted to a different room for backup. The DM then ...
- 41
8
votes
0
answers
149
views
How to deal with a DM who pointedly ignores important details? [duplicate]
The campaign was intended to be difficult. We knew and accepted that up front, and it sounded like a fun challenge. But we never knew until we were already a fair ways into it how much of the ...
- 883
8
votes
3
answers
630
views
One shot - how important is a happy ending? [closed]
I’m drafting a one-shot D&D/Pathfinder concept and the more time I spend writing it, the more I feel like the prospect of a downer ending is inevitable.
The story concept revolves around someone ...
- 81
10
votes
4
answers
2k
views
How can I avoid "railroading" my players by giving them a limited set of choices with only basic descriptions?
I play Dungeons and Dragons 5e.
I have a habit of highlighting certain choices, without realizing I'm doing it, because what I feel like I'm doing, is telling not showing. I have a problem with my ...
- 117
24
votes
9
answers
5k
views
How can I avoid railroading in a sci-fi campaign?
I run a fantasy campaign and a sci-fi campaign. I always find it much easier to create interesting content in the fantasy world than the sci-fi world. In fantasy, for instance, a dungeon can be many ...
- 359
22
votes
5
answers
4k
views
How do I keep a published adventure playthrough "on rails" without removing player agency? [duplicate]
Split from: How do I deal with players who make friends with goblins?
I want to run a campaign "from the book" for a group of new players (played RPGs before, but stuff much much lighter then D&D,...
- 779
8
votes
1
answer
2k
views
How can I make a linear adventure feel like it's not linear? [closed]
I have been recently delving into D&D 5e and I decided to start GMing. So despite the bad criticism, I picked the two books of “Hoard of the Dragon Queen” since I wanted to see for myself what a ...
- 1,047
3
votes
1
answer
606
views
Being Railroaded (Advice)
So, I'm in a Pathfinder campaign with my friends. However, some of us are not enjoying the campaign. This is mostly in part by the lack of player agency. The world is well developed but we're left the ...
- 41
10
votes
6
answers
3k
views
How to subtly railroad players to go in a certain direction?
Now I know that railroading is one of the cardinal sins of DM-ing, along with hard rules changes to fit your needs, and sloppily homebrewing every other custom rule. However, right now I feel like my ...
- 2,727
75
votes
7
answers
12k
views
Our GM won't let us affect the story; the more I play the less fun I have. What do I do?
I was wondering if anyone could give me some advice or anything on a GM situation.
My current GM is running a campaign and it is very video game/anime like. It started out super fun and the deeper ...
- 693
3
votes
4
answers
736
views
What can I do to give the players more freedom? [closed]
I'm a newish DM playing a fantasy RPG similar do D&D but a lot simpler, either way, it won't matter that much.
I'm not very good at improvising yet and if i do it too much it may become a mess ...
- 551
6
votes
2
answers
5k
views
My DM is hardcore railroading us - dropping excessive amounts of hints, regardless of our response
We are playing a D&D 5e game, and our DM is constantly dropping the same hints, and re-iterating the same details over and over again, to try and get us to go where he wants.
I've played enough ...
- 23.2k
32
votes
8
answers
5k
views
Can lack of planning railroad players?
There's plenty of questions on here about how to, as a GM, prepare less for sessions and learn to go with the flow your players create rather than railroading them into your plans. I'm interested in ...
- 8,140
3
votes
2
answers
551
views
How much should I limit a plot-driving GM 'avatar'?
I am GM for a group of (mostly) new Pathfinder players who are extremely off-the-rails in their approach. This is fun, but made it nearly impossible to prepare for a session — they are as likely to ...
- 351
19
votes
13
answers
10k
views
How do I respond when players stray from my prepared material?
As a new DM I have had the problem of my players straying way off course to the point where it was not a easy fix problem that where I slowly can guide them back to the objective.
An example of this ...
- 209
29
votes
3
answers
11k
views
How to deal with a DM who controls us with powerful NPCs?
I'm currently in a campaign run by a friend, and so far, I'm having a great time. However, he does do one thing that has been irritating to me, he makes all of the important allied NPCs far more ...
- 9,197
18
votes
8
answers
5k
views
As DM, how do you advise against a course of action without speaking out of character?
I have just experienced my first D&D game, and I was thinking about creating my own world to DM a campaign in. I'm trying to learn and research as much as possible for this.
One thing is that, ...
- 963
30
votes
6
answers
10k
views
How to get players to do something without them feeling railroaded?
I'm DM'ing a play-by-post campaign and I'm at a point in the adventure where the group all meets for the first time. They've all had something stolen from them at the same time and saw a creature that ...
- 8,522
13
votes
4
answers
11k
views
How to effectively (pre)build encounters for a 'Sandbox' Setting
I have a dilemma for my user created (original) High Fantasy setting. I have every zone, NPC, region and it's potential creatures all designed and solid. It's been a long running RP over Forums for ...
- 18.7k
53
votes
5
answers
10k
views
Why wouldn’t I just run away from the eldritch horror?
I am struggling with character motivations in Call of Cthulhu or similarly investigative horror settings. For some reason I seem to have issues imagining the reasoning behind characters who really ...
- 10.4k
32
votes
5
answers
5k
views
How do I prevent my players from hopping on a railroad when I'm not railroading?
All my previous GMing experience is with tightly-plotted railroads, and my players are used to (and generally happy with) riding the rails. Right now I'm setting up a sandbox campaign to break out of ...
- 7,645
16
votes
5
answers
3k
views
How do I avoid railroading in dungeons?
Well, I'm a very big fan of 4E's character creation system and also its combat, but a problem I've found is that exploration seems pointless in this edition and everything's built around combat (...
- 7,645
29
votes
5
answers
3k
views
How to present players with options without railroading them?
We're playing Dungeons and Dragons 4th edition. I'm a new GM, mastering a party of mostly new players.
I take campaign design rather seriously, and I hate railroading. I love coming up with crafty ...
- 54.2k
28
votes
7
answers
10k
views
How do you deal with a DM who says "no" to everything?
I am in a campaign with several players who also DM, on a rotating schedule.
One DM in particular has a control issue, in my opinion. He tends to say "no" to just about any action the PC wants to ...
- 671
20
votes
10
answers
2k
views
How to determine how much plot guidance is too much? [closed]
I've played in many games that were extremely railroaded. There was basically only one feasible course of action and we, as players, were expected to take that route. (The GM would get very upset if ...
- 3,474
31
votes
9
answers
1k
views
How do I help create story around the table without writing it?
I love RPGs. I think they can create some of the most fun and enjoyable stories, both from an out-of-game and in-game standpoint.
I also realize that "story" is the result of the game played by the ...
- 757
6
votes
4
answers
679
views
How to avoid the feeling of railroading in my campaign pregame?
This question is related to my other question. Please see that one for campaign background, rather than me repeating it all here.
I don't want the players to feel "trapped" and forced into a "tunnel",...
- 331
40
votes
12
answers
2k
views
How do I allow player agency in situations with predetermined outcomes?
One of the current members of our group joined a little later than everyone else. His character's history wasn't developed too well, so I am running a one-off session so that the group can play out ...
- 17.6k
63
votes
9
answers
51k
views
What is 'railroading', and what are its pros and cons?
What does the term 'railroading' mean? When some people use the term it seems to be considered to be something negative. Is it purely negative or does it have pros and cons, and if so, what are they?...
- 4,306